22 Best Italian Restaurants near Myerstown

“Great Food, Great Service“

“My husband and I are sitting here, while I write this review. The food was delicious, the ladies whom took our order were beyond friendly and just so kind and had a smile while taking our order. I will be coming back here and will bring my boys with me. Thank you ladies for delicious pizza and subs, for having an amazing attitude with us and for making my birthday lunch special even tho we did not mention it! Thank you again!“

“I’m a Florida girl who only eats “Publix subs!” Back in town and we had the best hoagies today and they were delicious! Thanks Dave! I will be back!“

“The food was amazing and our waitress, Emerson, was so sweet. The restaurant is very clean and cozy. Definitely recommend this place!“

“Best hoagies in the county!! So fresh and delish!“

“Great food“

“Amazing experience with this place! We came here for the second part of my son’s birthday party. The pizza was an absolute hit! They even have gluten free and it was delicious! Large space inside so plenty of room and you won’t feel like you’re sitting on top of anyone else! 5 out of 5!“

“One of my favorites in Lebanon Pa. for subs and pizza.“

“We're at the Lebanon Valley Exposition Center for the dog shows and wanted to get some lunch for the group, so right across the street we ordered a Sicilian Pizza with pepperoni and it was the BEST we've had in many years! We'll be back!“

“Best pizza in the Lebanon Valley! Their homemade dough is amazing! I wish they used their homemade dough for subs. But, the sauce to cheese ratio along with the SPECTACULAR dough is a huge hit! I’ve loved this place and their pizza for many, many years!❤️🤍💚“

“The chicken bacon ranch sub is...wow. I ordered from Carusos for the first time on Thursday. On Friday I went there with friends and got the Burger sub. Again phenomenal food! The staff was so friendly and I hope to go again and bring friends“

“Never got something here I did not enjoy. My husband and I both agree it is our favorite place!“

“Found this little pizza shop on our travels. Delicious pizza, really nice customer service, they were so kind to take 2 slices of pizza and cut them again so little Dex could have his own slice of pizza fit for him. Is definitely worth the stop if you are In the area.“

“Best pastrami sandwich in area.“

“Hands down one of the best salads in the area. Their service is wonderful. Greetings with a smile and the food is served in a timely manner. Great pizza too!“

“We recently used Gus Deraco's to cater our Christmas Eve party. The hoagie platters were very nicely presented, with the fixings, chips, and condiments in separate containers, so everyone could customize their sandwich to their liking. All our guests said the food was great. We also got brownies for dessert, which were delicious and festive, too. The entire ordering process was easy and professional and cost-effective, as well. I would highly recommend Gus Deraco's if you are looking for someone to cater a personal or business event.“

“We’ve lived in the area for about 2 years and I just stumbled upon Angelo’s when I saw a “vegan cheese pizza” on DoorDash. MOD was the only vegan pizza option around that I know of, and they’ve since closed so this was a happy discovery! We ordered a vegan cheese pizza (light cheese) with mushrooms, half peppers/olives, and french fries. We were happy with our order and plan to order from them again. The pizza was cooked well so it held up to the sauce and toppings (not flimsy in the middle like most).
To the owners: I’m not sure if the vegan cheese is new but thank you for offering this! I know the vegan (or non-dairy) market isn’t huge around here, so I appreciate being able to order pizza like everyone else. I hope you continue to offer it and we can continue to support your establishment.“

“Thanks to all of you God bless you“

“I was very disappointed with Infinito's this trip. I was there at a time when everything should have been fresh. Not so. The pizza selection was low and what was there seemed to have been sitting quite a while. My favorite is the chocolate chip pizza because it usually melts in my mouth. Not this time, it was like biting into leather and wasn't at all moist. We hadn't been there for awhile and it will be a long time, if ever , till we go .back“

“I love CC’s Pizza! Have been a dedicated customer for at least 10+ years! Soft and fluffy crust! If you like it crispy I’d suggest asking for it well done! Not only is the pizza delicious all the bread is made fresh daily. To die for subs and salads! And the fresh cut french fries are always so easy to slide down the hatch. Definitely our go to spot when we don’t feel like making dinner! And unbeatable prices, if compared to other local pizza shops!!!“

“Cedar Grill is one of those small local diners that just gets it.

It’s a regular stop on my breakfast runs especially because my 88-year-old grandpa absolutely loves it, which honestly says everything you need to know. This place feels familiar, welcoming, and comforting in the best way.

My go-to orders are either the breakfast quesadilla (which is huge and packed with veggies) or the mushroom omelette, both consistently delicious and filling. The food is always good, always hot, and somehow comes out crazy fast usually within 10 minutes of ordering.

The service is what really sets this place apart. We always ask for Charla, and she is hands down the best. She remembers our order every time and often meets us at the table with coffee already poured. She knows her regulars, treats everyone like family, and makes every visit feel personal.

A quick honest note: right now, some of the booths and tables are a little run down, but they’re actively working on opening new housing right next door, so it’s clear they’re building toward something bigger and brighter. It’s absolutely not a deal breaker the heart of the place, the food, and the people are what matter, and those are solid.

Prices are affordable, portions are generous, and the vibe is classic hometown diner. If you want fast, reliable breakfast with genuine care behind it, Cedar Grill is it.“

“Have been going there for years.“