Bill's Bake Shoppe

228 N Liberty St, New Castle
(724) 654-4223

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Seddra Jones

This was the first time that I had ever visited this bakery and I will never return!!
While I was trying to decide what to buy from them I look in the case with the donuts and there’s a huge cockroach crawling around all over the donuts.
I was very disgusted and the items that I was planning to purchase, I didn’t even want anymore.
The only reason that I still bought anything is because the items that I purchased were wrapped in plastic wrap.
I know that all places that sell food probably have some issues with unwanted pests, but this was truly disgusting!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 4

Zach Bujak

The worst baked goods i have ever tasted... not to mention the owner is rude, inconsiderate, disrespectful, racist, and many other things that are not acceptable to say on here!!

Leslie Ann

Bill Cast is an amazing human!! I love his brownies and his food. Highly recommend!

Ken Langston

This place IA a disaster

Parking: Really none

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Jackie Poeggel

The building may look run down but the baked items were delicious. The staff was very friendly and were able to accommodate my last minute order for a birthday party. Everyone at the birthday party raved about the taste. Please don’t judge a book by it’s cover.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

paul yasher

Very good cinnamon rolls

Shannon Miller

excellent service great food

Tracy D

Absolutely loved the authentic old school charm of this bakery! Not to mention the baked good are delightful ?

Barbara MAUE-KNUTSON

I love this bakery ❤️

benjamin miller

Ordered my son's first bday cake here, marble with whipped cream icing, and everyone loved it. The donuts are very good too!

Jessi May

Ordered a birthday cake for my dad, had it done in 1 day. Most delicious banana cake I've ever had. Buttercream icing is perfect. We have for sure found our new cake place. My dad was incredibly happy with it. Can't wait to try more stuff!!

Shannon Lesher

Amazing ? ?️ banana pepper bread!!?

Robert Patterson

Wonderful!

Paul Safarek

Love the Place......Awesome Food......old flavor Charm!!!??♥️????

Arch angel

Best fresh backed bread and sweets in the area. Fast friendly service decently priced

Loading...