Restaurants in New Castle

“delicious pizza! easy online ordering and done very quickly!”

“Delicious recipes, easy to make with limited things you have to buy to complete them! My favorite is the sweet potato chili and I recommend adding ground lamb the flavors work so well together.”

“Ali's Upper Crust on Highland ave in New Castle, PA is the best pizza in the area. The crust uses a raised dough not the flat lifeless dough used by Pizzaman or Little Johnnys. The sauce has great flavor. Not too tangy, or sweet, or tasteless. The cheese is genuine mozzarella, a great flavor to it. And a nice amount. Toppings, well, no anchovy, but the pepperoni is thin sliced and covers the pie. I've lived here two years now, and this is the first good pizza I've had in new castle. I generally will drive to Youngstown to get an Uptown, or Cornersburg, a Cocas or Belleria when I really want GOOD pizza. I finally tried Ali's, and I won't be doing that drive anymore. Seriously, I am not kidding, the best pizza in New Castle.”

“There’s nothing like this place around here!!!! VentiSei looks like it’s straight out of a movie ❤️Great vibe friendly smiling staff great food drinks are phenomenal Can’t wait to go back”

“My son and I had a delicious lunch today. He very much enjoyed the sushi. We shared 2 appetizers and dessert. Beautiful place, friendly staff.This is a must try place .”

“Great beer and kind/friendly staff!!!”

“Great food and service. Always have daily specials.”

“My boyfriend and I went out to dinner tonight, and I must say. By far our BEST time there yet! Food was hot and amazingggg!! Dalton was fantastic!! I asked him about the steak (normally always get the bourbon chicken & shrimp) he said it was super good so I tried it! My goodness, I’ve never had a steak melt in my mouth the way this one did. We had gone to Longhorn steakhouse the night prior actually and for them being known for their steak they disappointed me. Thankfully now I know I can get good steak here! We come out to Applebees often and will definitely continue coming back!”

“Very good brews. The steak was perfect. Service was top notch and knowledgeable. Patronage were very friendly. A+”

“I stoped in over the weekend for the first time in a while with my sister, niece, and elderly parents, and had Kiley as a server. She was so sweet and patient with my parents. She was also very “kid aware,” she brought out nieces food first and had stickers at the end! All of her recommendations were accurate, everything came out perfect. Highly recommend asking for her if you eat here, we will definitely be back!”

“Amazing food! I Was in today for my first time I ordered the triple play panini which I don’t normally do reviews but I definitely think this sandwich deserves one, stack high with meat and peppers and a home made balsamic vinaigrette. It was absolutely delicious!! I got it with a side of their house made chips which I was very impressed with the seasoning and being so crispy! I also tried mango lemonade very good not to sweet it was perfect overall. I will definitely be back friendly service great prices and amazing food! Good luck to this little business. Glad to have you guys around!!”

“First time eating here and it was fabulous!! The food was delicious & the best that we have had, we will most definitely be eating here again. The portions were generous & the prices were very reasonable. The staff was very nice & attentive. Highly recommend!”

“Stopped after a long hike at McConnell's Mill State Park. The ice cream was excellent although I didn't try anything unique, I really was just craving peanut butter, but believe me the temptation was real. Hopefully I'll be in the area again before the season is over!”

“The food was delicious and the service was excellent! Thank you!”

“The best Chinese cuisine in town! High quality and consistent in taste. Great price and large serving. I look forward to visiting this place once a week. The spring rolls are awesome! They put a lot of love into their food. Amazing food and amazing people. Eat local and support our restaurants,”

“Delicious food with an amazing staff!!!”

“My daughter said this is now her favorite spot !”

“Mary’s is my personal favorite among the top three restaurants in New Castle which specialize in Mideastern cuisine. I have always been very pleased with the quality of food, service, and atmosphere, as well as the reasonable pricing….whether dining in or ordering take-out meals.”

“very friendly staff and great food.”

“We've tried everything, and everything is absolutely delicious. So there's that. We usually get takeout when we order from Pizza Man's Pizza. And what's even more important (to me) than the great food is that they actually know HOW to wrap takeout properly. They line everything with paper and then foil to prevent the hot food from melting into the Styrofoam container. (Eating food that melted through Styrofoam is a health hazard.) So A+++ to Pizza Man's Pizza for fantastic food, the intelligence to wrap it correctly, AND for the wonderful staff. Everyone is always so nice and friendly. Side note: Try the wings. They're a slice of heaven.”

“I’ve been wanting to eat at this restaurant for about two years now because of the great reviews, but I never had the time to make the 30-minute drive. I’ve tried many Middle Eastern places in the area, but this one truly stands out! The lamb is perfectly cooked, with just the right amount of spice—even mild enough for my dog to enjoy. It’s definitely worth the money and the drive. Thank you! ??”

“I love the remodel. It is so peaceful and beautiful. All the live plants makes it feel welcoming and fresh.

Kid-friendliness: Yes

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes”

“An intimate setting, very tasty freshly made sandwiches, soups and sales are available for a very reasonable price. Bottled water, soda and juices are available as well as desserts. A good place to meet friends, and on select nights, hear live music by area bands and musicians.

Parking: You can park on the street, or in the free lot just across the street.”

“Legitimately the Pittsburgh salad is probably the best salad I have had in years!!”

“Just had the Grilled Chicken sandwich and might be the best chicken sandwich that I have ever had. Great job Bills.”

“Love this family owned bar. Staff has been there for years and is wonderful friendly. Was there two or three weeks ago. The bar was packed on a Friday and music playing the waitresses and bartenders singing and dancing. Food was awesome. My lamb was tender and the godfather my husband had was great. Looking forward to coming back on Friday night for the fish.”

“Food was very good and service was excellent.”

“Absolutely loved eating here, I was in town for work and ended up eating here multiple time with absolutely no complaints. Highly recommend eating here, the steak was delicious as well as the salmo!”

“I love Fox's, have been ordering since the 1970s in the original shop. Best pizza anywhere!”

“Take out was about an hour wait, but worth it. The red sauce is great and they put a lot on the pizza. We got a poor man's pizza which is good. I like their red sauce better. I normally like hot wings, but food in New Castle can be HOT! Thank goodness we ordered the mild - they had just the right kick! Next timw I will dine in.

Vegetarian options: You can get any type of veggies on pizzas and salads. If you have acid issues from tomatoes, the poor man might be for you.”

“The most like your Italian grandmother's pizza you'll ever find outside of grandma's! Nothing but the best quality, always fresh ingredients and every pie hand made with care and love. The BEST!!

Parking: Readily accessible parking.

Kid-friendliness: Family environment

Wheelchair accessibility: Easily accessible via wheelchair,”

“Best gyros in town. Make sure you request Danielle when you go to have them made. The zucchini fries are a must when you visit. Great environment. Great food, and the staff was amazing.

Kid-friendliness: Yes

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes”

“Always a decent place to take a family with children, especially when mom or dad need a drink with dinner. Food is definitely above average for the New Castle area restaurant scene.

Kid-friendliness: Always.

Wheelchair accessibility: My husband is paraplegic and there is always ample space at the tables for my whole family”

“I've been wanting to try New Castle Nutrition for a while and they DID NOT DISAPPOINT! Clean cafe setting, friendly staff, super delicious energy drinks and shakes! We will be back!”

“We always have a great meal & dessert at Soni’s! Love their red sauce - my favorite dinner is the Italian Platter! We had Brian as our server tonight- he is fantastic- he always has a great demeanor!!!”

“great service friendly good food”

“We met friends here and had a lot of laughs. We didn't get to eat but probably not a place for dinner as they allow smoking inside.

Parking: Nice open lot, with good surface.

Kid-friendliness: Bar not kid friendly.”

“Had a great time at trivia!”

“We had a wedding reception and other parties there they are super friendly”

“Excellent place to eat and excellent staff and service”

“Just wanted to give a special shout out to Mama Jane's Eatery in Greenville. My mom and I brought my son there today for his 4th birthday. Our wonderful waitress gave him a stuffed squirrel (now known as “Tom”) and the whole staff took the time to come out with a cookie and sing to him. This was very unexpected and special for our little guy, and for us. Thanks for an outing we won’t soon forget!”

“All around amazing place. My two daughters love the food, and thats saying something because they never try new things. The servers are amazing and the atmosphere will make you feel like your in a different country. Absolutely love this place. 10/10, majorly recommend.

Kid-friendliness: Servers are really sweet to my daughters. They love this place and normally choose it over Mcdonalds. Still working on teaching my girla chopstick usage.”

“Probably as authentic as it gets in PA. Good menu. Not the most updated- Facility looks a little intimidating but the food was good. Server was polite. Quiet. My kids loved the food - decent kids menu. Tacos, quesadilla, burrito, hamburger, fries, hotdog, etc.

Wheelchair accessibility: There's a slight ramp. Doors are not automatic. Might have some slight difficulty.”

“I have been here many times in my life and I love the service and the welcoming atmosphere also.

The spaghetti is 10/10 and it reminds me of places like home, that provide wonderful blessings to me.”

“Just had the Grilled Chicken sandwich and might be the best chicken sandwich that I have ever had. Great job Bills.”

“Pizza is goodService is adequate, but they are young AND working so some slack and much respect given to the young ladies there.Atmosphere is a Pizza shopThis is New Castle's favorite pizza though.”

“highly recommend coming in sitting down and checking out the menu good burgers good food good people and let me not forget stop by and get yourself some chili sometime for the hot dogs and hamburgers at your barbecue this is a new one in town and it's good.”

“So glad we finally decided to stop in and try your chili dogs!! My goodness they were awesome. Such a great flavor. We also had milkshakes and they were very good too. Hubby had a chili dog and chili fries and couldn’t say enough good things about them. We are very happy that we stopped by and will definitely be coming back!!”

“We tried the jerk chicken, curry chicken and snapper and loved it all. Everything is cooked fresh and the rice and cabbage is seasoned with your meat or fish. Portions are very generous; my daughter and I ate well and had about half left over. I saw they also have a salad option; I think smaller portions for lunch, seniors and children is a good idea. Food, service and music were all great. 10/10”

“The food here is excellent, however, my issue is with the rude employee. while I was standing inside ordering my food, a woman walked in to pick up a door dash. instead of the man just telling her it wasn't quite ready, he got smart and asked her "what is the pick up time" she told him and he said "exactly, it's not time to pick it up". she was only a couple minutes early. the employee then proceeded to tell her to wait outside. I don't know if this man is racist or sexist but it was beyond uncalled for. why was I allowed to stand inside as a black man with a black employee when my food wouldn't be ready for at least 10 mins yet the white woman was told wait outside for a 2 minute wait?. I will NEVER order food from this place again, despite how good the food may be.”

“Got lunch here today. Steak hoagie was so good. Fries were the best around! Will make this a regular spot to drop by!”

“favorite place for wings !”

“A wonderful homestyle restaurant. Delicious, reasonably priced and generous portions. Friendly staff, too! This will definitely be on our list to visit more often!”

“Delicious and good Specials!”

“The cannoli’s are amazing! Spoiled me against the rest!”

“Had a very bad experience at this store thinking about posting experience on Facebook, My daughter and I visited the location above on the date and time shown on receipt above. I specially asked the cashier names Alex that I wanted my order made fresh I didn’t care how long it would take I just wanted all my food cooked hot and fresh. 1 minute after I placed my order they are calling my name. I spoke to the manager Betty and explained there is no way that this could be my order I wanted my food made fresh, she tries to tell me that it was made fresh which was insulting because I am very intelligent not to mention I used to manage Wendy’s in Cleveland Ohio before so I know it takes 10-12 minutes to cook something fresh. So after the replaced the order I asked the manager Betty if I could have a word with her when I finished my meal, upon completion I went to talk to the manager Betty to explain that only the chicken sandwich was hot and the burger wasn’t satisfactory my intention was to request half my money back being I wasn’t satisfied. It was at that point I was asked to leave and I was still eating a frosty and my daughter was still eating at this point because it wasn’t resolved at the store level I do not ever plan to visit Wendy’s again and now requesting a full refund. I do not want and gift certificate or any thing like that , you can keep your apologies because the manager Betty should have been the one to provide it. Please send a check for the full balance of my order to.”

“Food was good ,service was amazing,very friendly. Was Greeted when walked in. The place was cleaned. The girl that was there Shelby she made 4 subs and did a very good job she is very friendly and a nice girl.

Vegetarian options: Vegetables was frash”

“Oceans was part of our bar crawl yesterday, such a great little place that welcomed us (we can be a bit much ) with open arms. Service was on point, we had fun schooling ppl on pool 😆 JK . super ppl all around. Thanks for being part of our fun.
PS......hope you like the duck 🤗”

“Great place come from out of town to see bartender Johna sweetest person in the world great bartender. And customers , regulars make you feel at home.”

“The food and the service was great! The atmosphere was very nice, also. However, wasn't a fan of the chopped chicken in place of the whole chicken slices for the grilled chicken subs.”

“Very good food! Everything I’ve ever gotten was super fresh and delicious. Great portion sizes for the price, fast service, and kind staff. One of my favorite places to eat!”

“The two employees had just received a large online order and were understandably a little overwhelmed. They worked quickly and efficiently to make sure we got our subs- which were great! Awesome demonstration of time management and customer service.”

“I'd most recommend the subs, especially the tuna, nice that it comes with a drink included in a really good price, daily specials!”

“Food is great and so is service,inside nice and clean and looks new wish they would use tht big blank wall they hv outside and put some art ? on it thr would be cool ?”

“Service was amazing!!!! I really enjoyed the pierogi pizza”

“been here for a few years and I never tried it till today I highly recommend it so good”

“nice place awsome staff will return again”

“Nice place great food. Good service”

“Mark was a great server… food was amazing! Great dinner with mom on a Friday!!”

“Great selection of pizza.... Helpful n Cheerful staff... real quick n easy location to come n go... return customer fosure... return visit yesterday, again, fantastic!!! Forgot to mention...cash customers save money, vs card users.....”

“I would recommend Four, but to the chef who assembled my burger…please do not put a tomato on a burger that is the size of a quarter. There is no point. You know who you are”

“Best food you will find for the price. It an amazing deal and the pizza is spot on. Can't go wrong with there cheese I order one everytime I can even if I'm just passing through on my way home.”

“Food is always fresh! If you do have to wait a little bit it’s because they are making it fresh for you. Also, every time I’ve ever had an even slightly above average wait time, I’ve been given a frosty or drink for my inconvenience. That is customer service. Great place.”

“First time at this McDonalds and got breakfast for myself and two others and this New Castle Location was by far the best McDonalds I have ever been too! Service was so efficient while staff were still being pleasant! The food was even the best and most tasteful along with the coffees! By time I got the food home it was still decently warm and didn’t need reheated!”

“Order for takeout. This is a combo location with KFC. There are accessible parking places near the door, the entrance is accessible, and seating is, as well. Pleasant, efficient service right away, as soon as we were ready to order. The very nice girl who took our order was easily able to tell us what all was on the different items and compare between choices. We each got one KFC and one Taco Bell item for dinner. Restaurant was not crowded, and the drive-through appeared to be efficient as well. Our order was right the first time - which is highly unusual for this location; we usually get shorted at least one item, and often have individual orders wrong at pickup (we get food from here at least once every 2 weeks). Crispy strips were yummy, as always, but I wish KFC would bring back its old Sweet & Sour dipping sauce; the current sauces are less-than-yummy. Original 3-piece white meal had one good chicken breast, one tiny, greasy chicken breast, and one really greasy wing. The Mexican pizza was very good, and the Supreme Burritos were excellent, also. Our order was complete quickly and efficiently, and service with a smile.”

“We recently had breakfast at the New Castle site. Even though the waitress was the only server there she was pleasant and friendly. Thank you Denise for making our experience a good one. You deserve a raise.”

“Kid-friendliness: The cashier that was working tonight was the nicest man ever to my basketball team he took a picture and is putting it up on the wall i’m glad i made his night with 5 bucks to himself and he was the nicest person i probably would’ve ever met. hope to go back and see him sometime. great place to eat. ?% will be going back”

“No, I would not recommend. I waited before writing this review hoping that I would get a call back from the manager. I left 2 requests for him to call me and haven't heard anything back. My husband and I were there on a Saturday for lunch. Our food was ok and service was fine. I ordered takeover for my mom, a hamburger with nothing but raw onion on it. We finished our lunch and waited a long time for the takeout. My mom called the next day to thank me. She said they remembered the raw onion, unfortunately there was no hamburger, just the bun and raw onion. We love to support local businesses, however we will not be going back to The Crane Room. I didn't expect a free meal or even credit. However an apology would have gone a long way.”