21 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Castle

“One of the best pizzas I have ever eaten! Love the buffalo chicken and Cane Lady pizza! Never disappointed!“

“Wonderful wine, food and atmosphere!“

“had ali's for the first time today. not only was it the best pizza ive had in a long time, if not ever. but it was a delight to talk to ali. truly a great place!“

“Best pizza in New Castle!!“

“KING OF SWEET SAUCE. I am working in Mahoning Town and have been on a pizza tour of New Castle. Pizza Man in my opinion has the best Homestyle pizza which is a pizza with only a sprinkle of parm and oregano. New castle is all about sweet sauce which now I love. I would say that Pizza Man is the “king of sauce”. It tastes the best and they give you lots of it. You have to eat their pizza with a napkin or even better a washcloth. Delicious. Also the service at Pizza Man was really good. A warm hometown feel. If you want speed metal and tasty grease go to Turcos. But if you want grammas kitchen and sauce red cheeks go to Pizza Man.“

“I was just passing through town and honestly didn’t expect to find a spot like this. Seeing a big Southern Italian last name on the sign immediately caught my attention, so I had to stop in, and I’m glad I did.
This is a genuinely authentic Italian-American place with that warm feel that makes you feel at home the moment you walk in. I ordered a capocollo-ham sandwich with provolone, lettuce, tomato, and Italian dressing. Fresh ingredients, well made, and very satisfying. I also tried the garlic knots, something I always judge Italian places by, and they were very good. Fresh, soft, and flavorful. If I had one tiny suggestion, I’d say a little extra garlic wouldn’t hurt, but that’s just personal preference.
The spinach stromboli was excellent. Fresh, clearly house made dough, and exactly what you hope for. I finished with cannoli, and they were absolutely on point. Small, authentic, and delicious.
I also loved that they had all the little extras that make a place feel real. Cookies, jars of pickled garlic and peppers. specialty items, packaged pasta to take home. The whole atmosphere just felt welcoming and genuine.
A really pleasant surprise in a town where I wasn’t expecting much. Definitely worth stopping if you appreciate authentic Italian-American food.

One fun suggestion: add a Nutella stromboli to the menu. If you do, naming it “The Stefano” would only be fair. 😄“

“we love out pizza joes, best pizza in grove city, good menu selection and have had their pizza for decades and it never disappoints.“

“Delicious every time and quick delivery for our hungry employees!“

“I love Fox's, have been ordering since the 1970s in the original shop. Best pizza anywhere!“

“Service was amazing!!!! I really enjoyed the pierogi pizza“

“we love out pizza joes, best pizza in grove city, good menu selection and have had their pizza for decades and it never disappoints.“

“I'd most recommend the subs, especially the tuna, nice that it comes with a drink included in a really good price, daily specials!“

“Delicious and good Specials!“

“Farone Brothers Catering did my son's wedding this past weekend. Fred and Anthony made sure everything was absolutely perfect! The guests just raved about all the wonderful food - and the catering staff and bartenders went above and beyond to make sure it was a perfect day! I thank them all so much for everything. If you want a beautiful wedding give Faraone Brothers Catering a call for a five-star event!!“

“We love this place and it never disappoints.....the Florentine Pizza is absolutely amazing! The staff is very friendly and Stacie is an awesome waitress!“

“I do really like their pizza, they have a very good menu of salads, sandwiches and much more!! And Joe, the owner, he is a very good guy!! Always willing to help our schools with a fund raiser!! Thanks, Joe!!“

“Pizza Joe's has the best pepperoni rolls you can find in town. Mangino's has a good pepperoni roll, but pizza Joe's is far better. I don't prefer the pizza though. They use high quality ingredients, but I just don't enjoy the sauce. It tastes over-seasoned to me. Give their pizza a shot though. The veggie pizza is noteworthy.“

“We usually get our ceasers pizza in. Boardman. We happened to be in the NewCastle area and stopped in to get a pizza here. KALEB andJOE could nothave been any nicer and the pizza was just the best. Thankyou guys your just the GREATEST. The company is really lucky to have you both as their employees. Tc“

“Nice place great food. Good service“

“Mr. Pizza will not convice you to end it all because you've had the best pizza ever. It's real pizza, in the middle of a residential neighborhood, and is about the best you can hope for. Ive never had an exceptional customer experience there. They act just how you would expect them to act. Support mr. Pizza, and friendly competitors.“