“Being from out of town, we were looking for a good place for dinner & The Elmton was referred to us by a friend. We couldn't find anything bad about the place. Some of the best pizzas we ever had, Both styles of pizza were very good, but the thicker one edged out the thinner version for us. Both were almost equally amazing. I usually have photos, but unfortunately, on this trip, I took them on snapchat & forgot to save them. I don't think you can go wrong with any of the food served here. Everything we saw coming out to the other tables looked amazing!“
“We are beyond happy that they opened this location! It is hands down the best pizza in the area. I love that you can stop in and they have a large selection for you to choose from if you don't want a whole pie. The service is stellar and fast! atmosphere is inviting and immaculate.“
“Decided to order a variety of items for the family on a Saturday. They do not deliver unless you order through Doordash. One of the items we wanted was a taco pizza. The taco pizza is not available on Doordash? Not sure what the reasoning for that is but it was an inconvenience as we did not want to go anywhere. Then I tried to order wings, and I was informed they do not have wings. So we had to order pizza from here and wings from elsewhere. Food was good and the service was fast. So aside from a few hiccups we still had a satisfying experience.“
“I ordered Tangiers on Doordash, got the sampler platter and it was delicious like a plate straight from your Italian grandmother's kitchen! Wonderful combo of flavors, the heat from the stuffed pepper, the garlic in the meatballs, the Italian greens were perfection! Will order again!!“
“Very unique & awesome venue; a must-see place for anyone visiting the Youngstown area. Bowl a game or two while listening to live music, enjoying fantastic pizza and a wide selection of beer- including local & craft beers on tap. The sound quality & production for the live shows is top-notch. There's a separate bar/restaurant area connected to the main stage/bowling area and also a great little arcade. Something for everyone here!“
“Nickys Pizzeria in Youngstown, Ohio, is a local treasure that consistently delivers on the promise of mouthwatering pizzas and Italian delights. The menu boasts a tempting array of pizza options, all crafted with fresh ingredients and a perfect balance of flavors. Whether you prefer a classic Margherita or a specialty creation, Nickys excels in taste and quality. What sets this pizzeria apart is the friendly and welcoming atmosphere, making it a go-to spot for families, friends, and pizza enthusiasts. The attentive staff enhances the dining experience, ensuring guests feel right at home. Nickys Pizzeria is a must-visit in Youngstown, offering a slice of Italian culinary excellence that will leave you craving for more.“
“I had the special Friday fish with coleslaw and perogies.Wife had Fish and haluski. The haluski was very good, Fish was very good, maybe the best I've had since moving here, we both had fried, maybe a lemon half would have made it perfect. Our waitress was very nice and the kitchen was very busy. Great place for a weeknight dinner.“
“We’ve been loyal fans of this pizza for years and can’t praise it enough! Today, we decided to try something new and ordered a classic Italian sandwich along with some pepperoni rolls. To say we were impressed would be an understatement. The sandwich had perfectly fresh bread with just the right amount of crunch, paired with high-quality ingredients. As for the pepperoni roll, it’s now my absolute favorite – hands down the best I’ve ever had! There’s simply no competition for pizza in Youngstown.“
“We were in town for our son's wrestling tournament. He requested pizza after a long day of wrestling. This place had good reviews so we gave it a shot. So glad we did! Everything was excellent..Super friendly staff, reasonable prices, and delicious pizza LOADED with cheese and toppings. Don't let the 12" size of their largest pie fool you. This pizza is more filling than most. We had plenty to take home to feed the family another meal or 2. We will definitely be back whenever we are in town. We love finding gems like this!“
“I ordered chicken parm with penna the noodles were overcooked. The place was overloaded with way too much sauce..I should of ordered the sauce on side. They give you two extra small slices of garlic bread like they took one slice cut it in half. The serving should of been bigger or gave you four small slices. The chicken melted cheese was delicious!Parking: Small lot shared by quick stop store“