“My family has been getting pizza there since 1964. I have been picking it up since 1979 when i got me driver's license lol. My kid are now getting it to. We live 40 mins away , only once in all these yrs have we gotten a bad pie and it was replaced with no problems. Quite possibly the next pizzas out there in my opinion with exception of home made.“
“I got take out for lunch. I ordered online. Food is usually ready when you arrive. It is a good plan it you don't have a lot of time. The food is delicious. The service is always good & friendly. I have always been met with a smile & greeting. The atmosphere is good. Other things: Parking is limited out front, handicapped accessible, and they have many options on the menu. A good choice.“
“Two friends and myself were in today (3-14-24)we each order pizzas. We had about a 25 minute drive home. Rachel gave us an insulated bag to put the pizzas in. She wrote our names in the pizza boxes. Rachel was very friendly, told us the specials and explained the toppings. She deserves a raise, she has great customer service, something we don’t see these days. Pizzas are delicious“
“The website does not give option for extra BBQ to be added to the chicken so I have to call and ask. This time they added it and it was perfect for me. The BBQ bacon chicken is the best. It's all I get but sometimes it is a little dry. But not this “
“Fantastic pizza! I got the poormans style pizza and i don't think a pizza could be made better. And the dining room is reminiscent of pizza shops in the 90s which I love. Very clean too. I didn't expect it to be this good, I may have to stop back again tomorrow for more.“
“Nickys Pizzeria in Youngstown, Ohio, is a local treasure that consistently delivers on the promise of mouthwatering pizzas and Italian delights. The menu boasts a tempting array of pizza options, all crafted with fresh ingredients and a perfect balance of flavors. Whether you prefer a classic Margherita or a specialty creation, Nickys excels in taste and quality. What sets this pizzeria apart is the friendly and welcoming atmosphere, making it a go-to spot for families, friends, and pizza enthusiasts. The attentive staff enhances the dining experience, ensuring guests feel right at home. Nickys Pizzeria is a must-visit in Youngstown, offering a slice of Italian culinary excellence that will leave you craving for more.“
“Great pizza, great service and the true Italian pizza maker made the experience well worth the stop. I had the New York style pizza and it couldn't have been any better. I am from out of town but make it there a couple times a year and I will be sure to stop again. Thanks "Now that's a pizza"“
“Iconic staple of Farrell and the Shenango Valley. Formerly known as Basilone's but now back to the original name "Farrell Hilltop Tavern." Food is second to none. Owners are wonderful. Can't go wrong with a pizza or the iconic Margie Dog.“
“Me and my Fiancé came here for a date night away from the kids and the atmosphere, drinks and food was absolutely amazing ! My eyes grew so big when I entered the barn. The man at the bar was very welcoming when we came in so confused what to do he greeted us with a smile and helped us along the way! We are strongly thinking about having our wedding here In2025 #Killeenit2025“
“We had the angel hair with meatballs. It was excellent. The food is so good and you can't beat the prices! One of my favorite restaurants. Mike even visited every table. He is the owner and recovering from an accident. One of the best family owned small businesses around.“
“I enjoyed this restaurant immensely. I had the Chicken Fettucine Alfredo with a salad and a large bread roll I also had an unsweetened iced tea. The server was very attentive and the food was very good. The Chicken Fettucine was good with just about the right amount of white alfredo sauce, not too much or too little. I ordered unsweetened iced tea and when I mentioned I would sweeten it to my taste she asked which sweetener I preferred and provide that to me. She also kept the iced tea topped off for most of the meal. The bread is a well made white bread boule.It is a very nice and cozy restaurant. I was on travel visiting my son who lives in a group home nearby and went in without a reservation and was seated immediately. I have favorite restaurants in cities across the country, to include Washington, DC, Philadelphia, New York, Boston, San Diego, Denver, Los Angeles, Berkeley, San Jose, San Francisco, Phoenix and many other cities. Although, this may not be the most trendy restaurant in any of those cities, the service and the food would place it well within the standard of restaurants in most of those cities.It is an Italian restaurant. They may want to expand their menu to include some non-Italian food choices and include food allergy free food choices such as gluten free and a selection of vegetarian and other food types. This doesn't have to be an extremely large part of the menu. The salad was good but I prefer my lettuce to not be as cut up as it was. The dressing was put on the side which permitted me to put on how much dressing as I desired. I am getting older and eat smaller portions so the server provide me with everything I needed to save the left over Chicken Fettucine Alfredo and the bread.This is likely the best restaurant in the Sharon, Hermitage and Farrell area.“
“The best authentic NY style pizza ? I ever tasted. I should know I lived in New York for 69 years. Not even little Italy in Cleveland can make NY style pizza the way Francesco's does. The the owner & workers are all professional courteous and kind. Sincerely, “
“Best pizza in Hubbard Ohio very good service and can hold party's thereVegetarian options: You can get a plain or and veggie pizzaKid-friendliness: There staff is very friendly to kidsParking: There all on the front of side of the building and they have about 20 spots to park“
“Now this is old school pizza!!!! It tasted like Angela T's pizza from Sharpsville back in the day.Staff was polite, crust was perfect, crisp with a little pull. Ratio of toppings was exactly right. This was our first time here but we will definitely be back.“
“We love Marchelloni'sThe pizzas are awesome, the toppings are generous. The Buffalo Chicken & Taco pizzas are 2 of our favorites. Their wings, stromboli, and subs are also delicious.They do not have any indoor seating but there is a table outside. You best bet is either pick up or delivery.“
“Let me tell you about the history with me in this pizza shop, which a lot of you can relate. I played for sharpsville and Hermitage baseball from t-ball up to senior division, at least that's what it was called back then, and every time we had a game my mom and dad or Grandma and grandad would go get plaza Pizza and I thought that was better than ice cream and cake lol. I'm 49 years old and I still think that place is better than ice cream and cake LOL“
“Traveling through the area and called ahead for a pizza to go on our way through.Absolutely delicious pizza. The traditional pizzas are perfect, handmade to order.I love the option to add on a slice or two when you get there based on what they have available on the counter. They had an extra thick pizza come out when we were there so we added on a slice and what a treat! The crust was light and crispy. We also added breadsticks and sauce. Seating is only available outside right now, which didn’t matter to us too much, as we took it to go.“