19 Best Pizza Restaurants near Cortland

“Just left Brothers's Pizza and let me tell you how awesome these guys were. I was pushing closing time and didn't want to be that dude. But the crew there was insistent on keeping the oven open and made fresh Stromboli's for me to bring home to the fam after an awesome night of basketball. I remember my dad always bring home calzones and Stromboli's from Brother's back when we were kids. I've been back a couple times since as an adult and it's always impressed. The quality is amazing and the people are genuine and fantastic. Thank you, Brother's for saving me from resorting to McDonald's. I highly recommend anybody who loves supporting local to support these guys-the food is excellent. Just don't push 9 o'clock like this guy. Thanks again, Brother's!“

“This is definitely a MUST visit winery!! I can’t say enough about the place! Their customer service was phenomenal (which is hard to find these days), their wines were delicious (I couldn’t choose a favorite because they were all so good) and their food (pizza and cheese plates) was superb!!!! And a huge added bonus was that they were very kid friendly, they interacted with my son and my friend’s son which made us all feel very welcomed!!! This place will be added to our frequent flier winery list!!!“

“We have lived in Cortland for 3 years and haven't bought from Cocca,so. No reason. We just haven't. Today we wanted white pizza and our usual pizzeria was closed. So we called them up and ordered pizza and chicken wings for take out.
I took the 5 min drive to pick up.they said 15-20 min and my order was ready in 15 min..
The folks were friendly and helpful. There were a few tables and a bar next to the pizza counter.
I took the food home. We thought the white pizza crust was very good. The sauce was a bit thin. The cheese was good but there was no peppers or olives and capers. The wings were large but hardly jumbo. They had a nice crunch. The BBQ sauce was very good.
We will definitely give them another shot with other items. The service and product are solid.
Also, Cocca's is definitely engaged in the community and that is important.“

“Amazing food and good prices I am thankful to have stumbled upon this wonderful restaurant“

“The best pizza in town - or anywhere for that matter“

“We got the chicken Siciliano dinner and honestly was the best tasting dinner I may have ever had. Just fantastic.“

“Tried ordering last night put on hold several times for long periods of time and was treated rudely, if that busy just don’t answer your phone, I love the food but that behavior will force me elsewhere. I do u derstand being busy but it literally takes a minute to take an order . Thx for the ear!.“

“sausage sauce cheese pepperoni peppers onions sour Dole n lot's of extra sauce“

“I've been working in the area for a few months now, and I make it a point to stop here for lunch or dinner as often as I can—it's become my go-to spot!
I've tried their wings almost every time, and by now I've sampled all the sauces. Hands down, Parmageddon is my absolute favorite—it's got that perfect cheesy, garlicky kick that keeps me coming back. The wings themselves are crispy, juicy, and always cooked just right.
The waitress is super personable and friendly every visit, which makes the experience even better. The atmosphere is lively and welcoming—somehow the place is packed every time I go, but I never have to wait for a seat. Service is quick and efficient without feeling rushed.
You really can't go wrong here. If you're in the mood for great wings (especially that Parmageddon!), solid food, and a fun vibe, this is the place. Highly recommend—it's earned a loyal fan in me!“

“The best Italian food ever!!“

“I am 52. Then I have been going to this sub shop since I was in my 20s. They are amazingly nice. Their food is wonderful.I recommend it to anybody“

“We had pizza from Wedgewood at a party and we liked it. Ordered it today for our dinner. White pizza was awesome and red was very good too. We tried a small Wedding Soup Pizza, it was good if you want something different. We will definitely order again!
Thank you ?“

“Great staff! Yummy Pizza!“

“Our pizza was delicious! We had a chicken bacon ranch pizza and everything was perfect. The crust toppings and price! It was late and they were ready to close but our pizza was of the highest quality. I don't know how the guy working does it all by himself! Amazing!“

“Absolutely the best pizza!!“

“Always great food and drinks at BV. Everyone is friendly and nice. I've never ever had a bad meal there. I've been going there for years. Their chicken is the best in town! When we have company from out of town, this is where we take them for lunch or dinner.“

“We had my wife’s 50th birthday party here and it was awesome! There was a huge rat that came out of the back just as we were about to eat but it didn’t damper our spirit.“

“Always had a great meal at Loo’s. 43 years ago , my wife and I ate an entire white pizza at the old restaurant on Parkman Rd. Just tonight, my wife, daughter and I had the same meal. The pizza is exactly the same. Great place, great food, nice people.“

“Usually don't have an issue with Papa John's but I don't recommend getting their PapaBowls because there was barely anything in the container, not even carbs. It's way overpriced for what it actually is and also unnecessarily double boxed. Save some trees!“