Brother's Pizza & Restaurant

$ • Pizza, Italian, Diner

144 S High St, Cortland
(330) 638-6555


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Recent Reviews

Had to move to area from NY for about a month or so. My landlord suggested I check out brothers pizza for a "NY Slice". I gotta say, theirs is the best slice I've had out here! I got a pepperoni pie, it was a little greasy, but it's expected with that topping. I will be going again before I drive back home for sure. Very nice owner with some cool jerseys hung up on the wall. Unfortunately I couldn't sit and chat longer due to COVID restrictions but I'm sure it's also a great full review

Almost our entire order was wrong. Ordered sub without mayo. Lots of mayo, oil and vinegar on sub. Ordered calzone with the sauce on the side instead of inside. Sauce all through the calzone and dough was very wet. Neopolitan pizza was so wet it literally stuck to the paper in the pizza box. Very disappointing. Waste of $44

Had a large Neapolitan pizza with pepperoni and green peppers and it was excellent! The toppings and sauce were great and the crust was delicious and crunchy. I'll be stopping back in to Brother's Pizza for this every time I come to Cortland.

More Reviews(90)


Monday 11AM - 9PM
Tuesday 11AM - 9PM
Wednesday 11AM - 9PM
Thursday 11AM - 9PM
Friday 11AM - 9PM
Saturday 11AM - 9PM
Sunday 4 - 9PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.