23 Best Italian Restaurants near Cortland

“Amazing food and good prices I am thankful to have stumbled upon this wonderful restaurant“

“Just left Brothers's Pizza and let me tell you how awesome these guys were. I was pushing closing time and didn't want to be that dude. But the crew there was insistent on keeping the oven open and made fresh Stromboli's for me to bring home to the fam after an awesome night of basketball. I remember my dad always bring home calzones and Stromboli's from Brother's back when we were kids. I've been back a couple times since as an adult and it's always impressed. The quality is amazing and the people are genuine and fantastic. Thank you, Brother's for saving me from resorting to McDonald's. I highly recommend anybody who loves supporting local to support these guys-the food is excellent. Just don't push 9 o'clock like this guy. Thanks again, Brother's!“

“We got the chicken Siciliano dinner and honestly was the best tasting dinner I may have ever had. Just fantastic.“

“Everything was amazing, especially the cinnamon rolls. I can’t wait to order again👍😍“

“We picked Enzo's based on a dessert picture we saw on Google. we were not disappointed. the food was fantastic and our server Chase was amazing. He answered every question we had, was very polite and took great care of us.“

“Just had a Summer Salad with strawberry dressing.!!! It was wonderful and packed with fresh veggies!!! Love it💕“

“From the start to the finish so amazing. Staff is amazing. Food is fantastic, reasonable pricing, great portion sizes. I love this place.“

“Their Detroit style chicken, bacon, ranch pizza is absolutely amazing! Probably the best I've ever had.

The staff is friendly and efficient.

One time, for some reason, I was told my pizza would be ready in 35 min and it ended up take an hour and 20 minutes. They automatically apologized and issued a generous gift card. Mistakes are going to happen, but how a business handles them says a lot.

We're glad to have Red Plum Pizza in Kinsman.“

“Food was delicious and excellent service! We will definitely be back.“

“Always had a great meal at Loo’s. 43 years ago , my wife and I ate an entire white pizza at the old restaurant on Parkman Rd. Just tonight, my wife, daughter and I had the same meal. The pizza is exactly the same. Great place, great food, nice people.“

“I have been going here since I was young, the food is SO good! The staff is so nice and the whole atmosphere is so welcoming. The pizza is amazing as well as the pasta! Yum😋 My family of 5 usually spend around $80 all together which is not bad at all for 2 adults and 3 teenagers. Mauro is so friendly and welcoming and always greets us when we arrive. Such a wonderful guy! Jessica is the best waitress, you can’t tell me otherwise! My mom and dad chose to do their wedding here, my mom said,” I trusted them to make it stress free”. The sauce is soooo good we get it all the time for pasta nights! Joe deserves a round of applause, he’s so nice and makes the best food! Love you Joe🫶“

“The best part is the breadsticks. I eat about 7 every visit. They are best paired with an alfredo sauce boat. The best part is they are both never ending. The pasta is always very good and comes in pretty decent portions. Free refills on certain drinks is a nice bonus. The place can be a little pricey, but is fair for what you get. This location is never too busy when we go and the service is always fast and attentive. It is clean and well staffed. Aswith most locations, they rely on the tabletop kiosk too much, as they put the apps in using it and make you use it to use gift cards and rarely take your card and run it yourself, but that complaint is at all locations.“

“We had my daughter’s surprise, 5th birthday party dinner on the patio! They were able to accommodate a very large party last minute. The food and drinks were delicious and the service was excellent!“

“Came through while visiting family in the area. Even though they were closing, the staff was friendly and did a perfect job reheating food. The pizza was delicious and I highly recommend it. I had broccoli, tomato, ranch and my husband had chicken, bacon,ranch.“

“Antones is always a great choice when looking for a tasty meal. Today we had the loaded fried cheese Monday special and the Romano crusted chicken Alfredo. Our meals came with monkey salad (which barely made the picture as it was too good to not eat quickly) and bread with dipping oil. All items were great and I’d recommend just about everything on the menu. Aside from the fabulous food, the family memorabilia on the walls truly adds to the overall experience along with the quick and friendly service. This place is worth a trip and a great go to if you live in town.“

“Incredible food, nice service. Wedding Soup Pizza is the best. Fish "Fry" today was definitely top notch, loved it. Thank you.“

“Best pizza I’ve ever had!!!!“

“Yesterday was the first time I had been to CharBenay's, it was also my aunt's and sister's first time. We were all impressed by the winery itself but even more impressed by the gentleman, Greg, that served us at the bar. We had a great time because of him and we will definitely be back.“

“Tried ordering last night put on hold several times for long periods of time and was treated rudely, if that busy just don’t answer your phone, I love the food but that behavior will force me elsewhere. I do u derstand being busy but it literally takes a minute to take an order . Thx for the ear!.“

“I sang karaoke, ate delicious ribs, and drank wine.“

“Absolutely the best pizza!!“

“Food was amazing best place to eat Italian, visited from Massachusetts and we loved it!“

“I normally love the pizza but last night I ordered more and they went so light on the cheese/ sauce the cheese seemed like mostly dough I didn't order it that way this happens a decent amount when I go there please fix the problem it was a good amount of money spent to be disappointed“