25 Best Italian Restaurants in Youngstown

YOSTERIA Italian • $$
252 Valley St, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Caciocavallo & Honey and Meatballs
Margherita After the Hill
Pizza Packaged to Go
Insalata Di Rucola
Quattro Femaggi
Caprese Salad
Pizza Rossa
Bresaola
Zeppole
Pizzas

“Greeted by Mcallam with a friendly smile and a positive attitude. Alex(owner) came out to greet us as well. He had some amazing menu recommendations. Home made wine and the food was excellent. Coming from a food snob, this is a must stop!!“

4.8 Superb61 Reviews
Cassese's MVR Italian • $
410 N Walnut St, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Spicy Bowties with Blackened Chicken
Shrimp and Cheese Tortellini
Cavatelli and Meatballs
Spaghetti and Meatballs
The Smokey Hollow Pizza
Ragin Cajun Ravioli
Hot Peppers in Oil
Veal Parmigiana
Stuffed Shells
Italian Greens

“First place I ever recommend to anyone new to, or visiting, the area! Fantastic atmosphere, food & service.“

4.4 Superb98 Reviews
Carmella's Café Italian • $
850 E Western Reserve Rd #6, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Italian Sausage Sandwich- Hot or Mild
Chicken Alfredo with Italian Greens
Chicken Parmigiano Sandwich
Breaded Eggplant Sandwich
Stuffed Banana Peppers
Grilled Chicken Wrap
Chicken Carmella
Your Choice Of
Eggplant Fries
Caesar Salad

“Had Dr. appointment up the road this morning, asked for decent place to eat near by; boy, did we get one! Kathy, our waitress was extremely sociable, efficient, and Johnny on the spot! My only regret, I forgot my leftovers that were going to be my supper! Would not only recommend, but will return when next in area.“

4.4 Superb64 Reviews
Uptown Pizza Italian • $
6041 Market St, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Small Order with Salad & Garlic Bread
Chicken Parmesan with Ravioli
White Pizza with Hot Peppers
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Grilled Chicken Salad
Hot Sausage Sandwich
Small Chicken Salad
Cajun Chicken Salad
Chicken Parmesan
Wedding Soup

“With Boardman being a location with innumerable, wonderful eateries, I must take a moment to expound upon Uptown Pizza being in a league of their own. I fervently believe Uptown is truly delicious. �“

4.3 Superb101 Reviews
Prima Cucina Italiana Italian • $$$
103 W Federal St, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Lemon Cake with Pistachio and Vanilla Gelato
Warm Marinated Olives and Affettati Misti
Tonnarelli Alla Carbonara Copy
Pollo Alla Parmigiana
Spaghetti Carbonara
Brussels Sprouts
Roasted Chicken
Mussels Marinara
Fried Artichoke
Eggplant Parm

“We dined here first time last night for our anniversary. The Rome style theme of the restaurant did not dissapoint! We ordered the Lamb lollypops and Polpo ( octopus) for appetizers, and both were outstanding! We followed with Prima, our choices were one of the nights special of a pork ragu over pasta and the other entree was the papparadelle ragu. Both very delicious and quite filling! Ending our dinner with the Tiramisu ( best i have ever had!) and gelato were the perfect way to celebrate our day! Please understand that in the style of food service in Italy, you are expected to sit and savor your meal, so this restaurant follows suite. Loved it and will definitely return!“

4.3 Superb86 Reviews
La Piazza Italian • $
3230 Belmont Ave, Youngstown
4.6 Superb20 Reviews
Bistro 1907 by Mark CANZONETTA American • $$
44 Federal Plaza E, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Bourbon Brown Sugar BBQ Salmon and Sweet Potato Hash
Crispy Fried Chicken & Buttermilk Cheddar Waffle
Pistachio and Parmigiano Caesar Salad
Spiced Pecan & Goat Cheese Salad
Brown Butter Filet Mignon
Chocolate Buttercake
Seasonal Cheesecake
Corn Crab Cake
Bistro Burger
Onion Soup

“Had a soup n crab cake. Yummy on A cold night, Hit the spot. Hard to believe I was in the Yo- so good, great service too.“

4.2 Good106 Reviews
Scarsella's Restaurant Italian • $
4151 Market St, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Homemade Italian Wedding Soup
Fried Portobello Mushroom
Chicken Parmesan Sandwich
Cavatelli and Meatballs
Breaded Calamari Rings
Ravioli and Meatballs
Eggplant Parmesan
Shrimp Capellini
Tiramisu Dessert
Homemade Lasagna

“For many years, the best. Ever since I spun records at Gouch's Jambar, they've been the best, highly recommended!“

4.2 Good71 Reviews
Station Square Italian • $$
4250 Belmont Ave, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Lamb Lollipops over Roasted Vegetables
Cheese Ravioli with Marinara Sauce
Station Square Special Crab Bisque
Chicken Parmigiana with Angel Hair
Vegetarian Salad with Salmon
Broiled Stuffed Shrimp
In-House Smoked Salmon
Italian Wedding Soup
Blackened Prime Rib
Chicken Parmigiana

“Group of 18 golfers dined here on Saturday night. We couldn’t be happier. They confirmed our reservation the day before. We arrived at 7pm and they were ready for us. Two servers for our table really hustled, but were outstanding.
The pasta and seafood dishes were outstanding. .

Some people did not care for the blackened ribeye. But I think that’s a balance of how do you cook it mid-rare but blackened.“

4.1 Good154 Reviews
Nicolinni's Italian • $$
1912 S Raccoon Rd, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Calabrese with Penne Pasta
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Whitefish Francese
Mozzarella Marinara
Fettuccine Alfredo
Chicken Francese
Brier Hill Pizza
Potato and Greens
Mussels Posillipo
House Side Salad

“Nicolinii’s is a hidden gem. The ambiance is warm and inviting. It is suitable for a family gathering or a romantic dinner. The bread and oil are delicious. The first couple times we visited our oil was sprinkled with freshly grated Parmesan cheese. This last time we visited it was not sprinkled with freshly grated cheese. We were given a Parmesan cheese shaker which does not mesh well with the vibe this place gives off. I’m not sure what happened but they need to bring back the freshly grated Parmesan cheese. The salad was fresh and I always enjoy their homemade dressing. My meals have always been delicious. I enjoyed the chicken francaise my first couple times eating at the restaurant. This last time I tried a special and it was delicious. I do not remember the name but it had blue cheese, chicken and portabella mushrooms. The portions are huge! I would rather have less pasta and real grated Parmesan cheese.

This last time we ate at the restaurant I was disappointed we were not able to sit at a booth because they were closed off, the patio was a mess and there is a bunch of stuff stacked in a corner leading to the patio. Also, our waitress was really abrasive. So abrasive I felt uncomfortable. Overall, our meal was delicious and we will return.

Dietary restrictions: They do not have a gluten free menu.

Parking: They have a parking lot in the front and back of the restaurant.“

4.1 Good84 Reviews
Belleria Pizza & Italian Italian • $
3460 S. Meridian Rd., Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Luncheon Crispy Chicken Salad
Homemade Wedding Soup
Steak Salad with Ranch
Italian Melt w Fries
Cavatelli Dinner
Meatball Splash
Grilled Cheese
Pepperoni Roll
French Fries
Cheese Pizza

“I'm a former Ytown resident who came back to town for a visit. Hadn't been here in years. The updates they've made are nice, the service was good, and the food was just as amazing as it always has been. Those dinner rolls are incredible! Chicken parm was on point.“

4 Good59 Reviews
Belleria Boardman Pizza • $
8485 Market St, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Salad
Banana Pepper Pizza
Sausage Sandwich
Chicken Parmesan
Fresh Cut Fries
Pepperoni Pizza
Pasta Dinner
White Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Meat Lovers

“The food is delicious!. The establishment was clean and service was great! Their sauce is to die for:.Much better then some of your more expensive Restaurants. We will be back soon! P.S. You should advertise that your under new ownership!?“

4 Good69 Reviews
Salvatore's Italian Grill Italian • $
4831 Mahoning Ave, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Portobella Steak Salad
Salvatore's Chef Salad
Fried Italian Greens
Monte Cristo Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
Fettuccine Alfredo
Chicken Cacciatore
Chicken Francaise
Chicken Salvatore
BBQ Chicken Pizza

“My family has gone to the Austintown restaurant for years, and are rarely disappointed, except for interactions with the owner, whose behavior is deplorable. Try the Four Seasons pizza, the Capellini Mille Fiore or the Mussels and Clams Linguine. Casual and moderately priced, large portions. Howland location is better.“

4 Good153 Reviews
PaPa GeGe's Italian Villa Italian • $
440 Boardman Poland Rd, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Pizza with Sausage & Pepperocini
Alfredo Pasta with Chicken
Pepperoni-Sausage Rolls
New York Style Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
Gnocchi Bolognese
Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Roll
Veal Parmesan
Steak Calzone

“We love Papa GeGe’s and the staff AND the food. The food is AMAZING. We love that it’s a BYOB. I think the veal Parmesan is the best I have ever had. I ordered it twice. The soup is amazing. We really enjoyed the cannoli. Beast Italian food around, hands down!!!“

3.9 Good94 Reviews
Marino's Italian Cafe Italian • $
5423 Mahoning Ave A, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Italian Combo Lasagna Ravoli and Manicotti Dinner
Linguine with White Clam Sauce
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Fettuccine Ala Alfredo
Penne Pasta and Sauce
Alfredo with Chicken
Philly Cheese Steak
Side of Spaghetti
Hot Peppers in Oil
Chicken Francaise

“Always great service for the best Italian dishes. Food comes out steaming hot the way I like it. Have only had fabulous tasting meals. Can never finish all the meal and get to take home for next day. Small place but can not go wrong with this place.“

3.8 Good68 Reviews
Jimmy's Italian Specialties Deli • $$
3230 Belmont Ave, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan with Cavatelli
Homemade Wedding Soup
Breaded Eggplant Deli
Traditional Cannoli
Pizza & Roll Tray
Portabello Brick
Pepperoni Roll
Spinach Brick
Wedding Cake
Birthday Cake

“It’s just always wonderful“

4.5 Superb47 Reviews
Tavola Catering Caterers • $$
7098 Mahoning Ave, Youngstown

“Tavola Catering catered Youngstown City Schools annual awards recognition event - Youngstown Honors. Tammy was amazing to work with! Staff were friendly and professional.The food was excellent and the presentation didn’t disappoint. I look forward to working with her again in the future.“

4.8 Superb23 Reviews
Cornersburg Pizza Pizza • $
3518 Canfield Rd #4, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Large Pepperoni Pizza with Half Mushroom and We'll Take the Green Peppers
12 Buffalo Chicken Pizza
12 Traditoinal Pizza
12 Brier Hill Pizza
Traditional Wings
Mozzarella Sticks
12 Some-Of-Eachy
Sumavecci Pizza
Boneless Wings
Cheesy Dipper

“5 STARS ⭐️ best pizza and wings I have ever had.“

4.5 Superb36 Reviews
Cornersburg Italian Specialties Deli • $$
3381 Canfield Rd, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Scalloped Potatoes
Vegetable Lasagna
Soup Potato Soup
Stuffed Cabbage
Pepperoni Roll
Baked Chicken
Beef Stew

“They are an amazing Italian speciality store offering many different foods to satisfy anyone! The staff is friendly, helpful and courteous. You cannot go wrong!“

4.4 Superb39 Reviews
Giangelo's Pizzeria Italian Restaurant & Bar Pizza • $
1315 Boardman-Canfield Rd, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Pizza with Pepperoni Sausage and Peppers
Eggplant Parmigiana
Calamari Marinara
Chicken Parmesan
Stuffed Eggplant
Italian Eggrolls
Stuffed Rigatoni
Brier Hill Pie
Chicken Alfredo
Fish Sandwich

“They squeezed us in super last minute and took great care of us! Appetizers and pizzas were great! Thanks guys!“

4.2 Good58 Reviews
Blue Wolf Tavern American • $$
1295 Boardman-Canfield Rd, Boardman

Customers` Favorites

Blackened Chicken Alfredo
Chicken Allouette
Chicken Carbonara
Chicken Francaise
Blue Wolf Burger
Zucchini Parmesan
Chicken Marsala
Lobster Ravioli
Fish Sandwich
Wedding Soup

“Ate there for the first time today. Celebrating my wife’s birthday. The food was excellent. We will be back for sure. I highly recommend.“

4.1 Good136 Reviews
Golden Dawn Restaurant American • $
1245 Logan Ave, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

City Chicken with Mashed Potatoes Corn Salad and Bread
Pizza with Extra Cheese Green Peppers and Pepperoni
Chopped Sirloin Steak Sandwich
Our Famous Jumbo with Fries
Fish Sandwich with Fries
Beer Batter Fish Dinner
Grilled Chicken Salad
Hot Meatball Splash
Chicken Sandwich
Italian Greens

“Had lunch there today it was absolutely delicious wood recommend this place for lunch“

4.1 Good108 Reviews
Cafe 422 Cafe • $$
8586 South Ave, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Crabmeat Stuff Mushrooms
Almond Crusted Chicken
Chicken Parmigiana
Gnocchi Sorrentina
Chicken Française
Hot Peppers in Oil
Seafood Linguine
Peppers and Oil
Pizza Margarita
Veal Parmigiani

“I would say get there early 4ish...food & service was wonderful...more than we could eat...extra food for daughter who worked late...our server Davidson was awesome,attentive, took very good care of us...Mgr walked over & asked how things were...everything was perfect...highly recommend...I had peppers in oil, salad, eggplant w/spaghetti...hubby had salad,pork chops w/baked potato & cheese cake...“

4.1 Good80 Reviews
Trax Lounge Lounges • $
4250 New Rd, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Fried Bologna on Italian Bread Sandwich
Bacon Cheeseburger and Fries
Steak Hoagie with Everything
Chicken Salad with Fries
Spaghetti Meatballs
Sandwich with Fries
Eggplant Parmesan
Chicken Marsala
Fish and Chips
City Chicken

“Moved to Eastside of Youngstown two plus years ago. Decided to search for the best marinara sauce in an italian restaurant on the west side. Just found it at Trax! The restaurant isn't stylin' on the exterior but the food served there is DELICIOUS ! Don't know how many times I drove by there and never noticed it. Make it a point to search out it's location ,you'll be glad you did. . ( The marinara is the best I've ever had in a restarant, in fact it's all GOOD eating.)“

4.1 Good62 Reviews
Emmanuel's Pizza & Restaurant Pizza Delivery • $$
4930 Mahoning Ave, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Hand Tossed New York Style

“ABSOLUTELY KILLER DEEP DISH PIZZA. YOU GUYS NAILED IT.“

4.1 Good17 Reviews

You May Also Like