Italian Restaurants near Columbiana

Paul's Italian Grille Cafe • $
36 S Main St, Columbiana

Customers` Favorites

Angel Hair and Sausage
Mediterranean Chicken
Chicken Parmesan
Cavatelli Dinner
Stuffed Cabbage
Chicken Tenders
Sausage Diablo
Chicken Diablo
Veal Parmesan
Fried Cheese

“We went here for my birthday yesterday because we were referred here by relatives and wanted to try it. The food was excellent- generous portions, served hot, and a ton of variety on the menu. I like the option of either butter or herbed olive oil for the bread- a true authentic Italian way of doing it. They may do a bit more business if they offered alcohol. The server was pleasant, although we felt a bit rushed by her and she seemed as though she did not want to be there, but the food and atmosphere make up for it. Perhaps she was just out of her element that day or was having an off day- we all do. It is said this place used to be an Antone's restaurant back in the day, however I was not reminded of it when I stepped inside. I had the Sausage Diablo and it was wonderful. We each ended up taking half our orders home. They were not busy that day, however we put in a reservation just to be safe. I am glad we tried Paul's and look forward to returning!“

4.5 Superb31 Reviews
Belleria Pizza & Italian Restaurant Columbiana Pizza • $
8465 258, OH-14, Columbiana

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Salad Lunch Special Salad
Grilled Chicken Salad
Chicken Parmesan
Specialty Fries
Chicken Alfredo
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Sticks
Cheese Pizza
Greek Salad
Deep Fried

“First time ever being here. Love that they are open a little later in the evenings. We got there around 8:30pm. The restaurant smelled amazing. Very clean, food was in big portions, and it tasted great! Server was very polite. Good prices. Family friendly. Will definitely be back.“

3.8 Good67 Reviews
Antone's Kitchen Columbiana Italian •
901 Columbiana-Canfield Rd, Columbiana

Customers` Favorites

Spicy Italian Sausage
Chicken Parmigiana
Hot Peppers in Oil
Chicken Annabelle
The Purgatory
Rolls

“The chicken parm seemed to have been made with the skin on. I assume this was not the case, but somehow there was a thin layer of something between the chicken and the crust. I will try again in the future as the other items were fine and the service was very good.“

3.3 Good60 Reviews
Aqua Pazzo Italian • $$$
492 McClurg Rd, Boardman - 7.85 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fire Grilled Icelandic Lamb Lollipop
Housemade Meatballs & Mozzarella
Seafood Spaghetti Cherry Tomato
Rigatoni with Fennel Sausage
Butter Cake and Ice Cream
Dark Chocolate Cheesecake
Sicilian Orange Salmon
Pappardelle Bolognese
Spaghetti Carbonara
Spaghetti Pomodoro

“Looking for a hidden gem of a scratch made Italian restaurant please run to Aqua Pazzo. The dishes we had were delicious and great portions! They have an extensive wine list and a room of wine I believe you can reserve for a large party. 2 distinct dining rooms that were both beautiful. Please try them, you won't be disappointed!“

4.4 Superb408 Reviews
Mary's Pizza Pizza • $
301 N Beaver St, Lisbon - 8.81 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sausage Pepperoni and Mushroom Thin Crust Frozen
It's Called a Everything Pizza

“Tried this place for the 1st time. I wanted to try it the original way first. I got the meat sauce. Tons of meat in it and its the sweetest sauce Ive ever had on a pizza. It wasnt bad sauce, it tasted good but if you dont like sweet sauce dont get this sauce they have a non sweet sauce which Ill try next. I was not a fan of how they do the cheese. Its not melted when you get it but if you keep it in the box long enough it eventually melts. They do put alot of cheese on it so that was nice. Overall its a good pizza and Id order again when I get a chance.“

4.8 Superb50 Reviews
Steamers Stonewall Tavern Seafood • $$
10078 Market St, North Lima - 6.02 miles

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp Scampi with Noodles
Sweet Potato Scallops
Asiago Chicken Pasta
Blackened Tuna Bites
Sweet Potato Wedges
Crab Dip Bread Bowl
Bairdi Crab Legs
Peanut Butter Pie
Chicken Parmesan
Shrimp Rice Bowl

“Was near our hotel. Good Buffalo Trace Manhattan, a beer I hadn't seen before (Birdfish Too Hip To Sip), and a whiskey I hadn't seen (Burning Chair). All good. Langostinos, mussels, and shrimp scampi hit the spot after a long day of driving.“

4.4 Superb79 Reviews
Carmella's Café Italian • $
850 E Western Reserve Rd #6, Youngstown - 7.54 miles

Customers` Favorites

Italian Sausage Sandwich- Hot or Mild
Chicken Alfredo with Italian Greens
Chicken Parmigiano Sandwich
Breaded Eggplant Sandwich
Stuffed Banana Peppers
Grilled Chicken Wrap
Chicken Carmella
Your Choice Of
Eggplant Fries
Caesar Salad

“1st visit was 4/15! Nice decor and quaint! Server was SUPERB ...between being attentive and friendly she was the only server there and she just rocked! Food was excellent only reason why I gave 4 stars is because the stuffed hot peppers had spaghetti sauce all over it and apparently I missed that in the menu...hot sausage sandwich was huge also!! Will be back again!“

4.5 Superb55 Reviews
Bella Napoli Pizza & Pasta Pizza • $
419 E Main St, Canfield - 9.78 miles

Customers` Favorites

Make Your Own Pizza Creation
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Order of Garlic Rolls
White Pizza NY Style
New York Pizza Ever
Pizza Italiana

“Just tried Bella Napoli for the first time and it certainly won’t be my last. To say we were treated as family is an understatement. Five stars all the way around! Our daughter Amelia says thank you for all the bananas and thank you for some delicious food! We will be back!“

4.5 Superb49 Reviews
Giangelo's Pizzeria Italian Restaurant & Bar Pizza • $
1315 Boardman-Canfield Rd, Youngstown - 9.38 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pizza with Pepperoni Sausage and Peppers
Eggplant Parmigiana
Stuffed Rigatoni
Italian Eggrolls
Calamari Marinara
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Alfredo
Italian Fries
Fried Greens
Bocce Balls

“The restaurant was very warm and inviting and cozy with soft lighting and Christmas lights. It wasn't overcrowded and there was plenty of room to move about. The food was delicious. We had the Bocce balla (fried meatballs) and potato pizza. Truly a good “

4.3 Superb44 Reviews
Nicolinni's Chophouse Italian • $$
6580 Ironwood Blvd, Canfield - 9.53 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken
Chicken and Greens
Caesar Salad
Pasta Giada
Lamb Chops

“I ordered takeout Saturday night. The girl said 40 mins. It ended up being 1:25 hrs. I was upset, finally got my food and left in a huff. I got home complaining to my wife that I was done with the place. It wasn’t till I took the first bite that my mood abruptly changed. It was as delicious as the food at the old Nicolinni’s near I-680 used to be. The greens were perfect and the Nicolinni’s salad dressing is second to none. I ordered the chicken with Procuitto and greens. It was perfectly cooked, tender, juicy and delicious. I just finished my wife’s lasagna Bolognese.It was spectacular. It came to mind later that it was a Saturday night & the place was packed. Next time we’ll dine in.“

4.2 Good67 Reviews
Caffe Capri Italian Bar & Grille Italian • $$
8000 Market St, Boardman - 8.31 miles

Customers` Favorites

Calamari Fritti and Pepper Jack Fried Cheese
Ravioli with Marinara or Mama Q's Sauce
Penne Pasta with Meatballs
Build Your Own Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Homemade Gnocchi
Homemade Lasagna
Italian Platter
Italian Greens
Chicken Marsala

“Cafe Capri makes the best eggplant Parmesan I have ever had. I get it at many restaurants… Sometimes it’s like there’s all breading one tiny skinny piece of eggplant somewhere… I’m not sure if it’s even in there. At Cafe Capri it’s sliced nicely, it is fried to golden crispy brown, and the sauce… Mama Q’s sauce is the best!! It is very rare that I order anything except eggplant Parmesan when I go to Cafe Capri,. PS: the pasta is always perfect!!“

4.2 Good66 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $
853 Boardman Poland Rd, Boardman - 9.82 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Marsala Fettuccine
Chicken & Shrimp Carbonara
Five Cheese Ziti Al Forno
Chocolate Brownie Lasagna
Chicken and Gnocchi Soup
Giant Chicken Parmigiana
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Crispy Chicken Fritta
Pumpkin Cheesecake
Stuffed Mushrooms

“Me and my 7yr old granddaughter went and had a good time. And I bet the server was surprised I left her a $20 tip. That's all the money I had on me and I said I'll just give her the whole thing because not only did she deserve it but I remember when I use to wait tables and be soooo thankful and grateful that someone tipped me 20 because sometimes people don't tip at all. But I do and especially at buffets too“

4.1 Good106 Reviews
PaPa GeGe's Italian Villa Italian • $
440 Boardman Poland Rd, Youngstown - 9.75 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pizza with Sausage & Pepperocini
Alfredo Pasta with Chicken
Pepperoni-Sausage Rolls
New York Style Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
Gnocchi Bolognese
Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Roll
Veal Parmesan
Steak Calzone

“Amazing food and service tonight at the boardman location! I usually order a NY style pizza, cause it’s my favorite pizza around, but today i got Alfredo and red sauce for the kids and the sauce didn’t disappoint! Even the salad was fresh and had lots of veggies. We love this place!“

4.1 Good62 Reviews
Lavanty’s Italian Eatery Pizza Takeaway • $
270 Boardman-Canfield Rd, Boardman - 9.49 miles

Customers` Favorites

Potato and Greens Pizza
Chicken and Greens
Briar Hill Pizza
Famous Strouss
Pizza Toppings
White Pizza

“Nick and Linda, thank you for perfection! We order the potatoes and greens pizza, the briar hill pizza, and the pepperoni pizza every time and you deliver flavor and quality with each bite! Thank you for sharing with us and blessing us with your delicious recipes!“

4.4 Superb14 Reviews
Cafe 422 Cafe • $$
8586 South Ave, Youngstown - 7.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Crabmeat Stuff Mushrooms
Almond Crusted Chicken
Chicken Parmigiana
Gnocchi Sorrentina
Chicken Française
Hot Peppers in Oil
Seafood Linguine
Peppers and Oil
Pizza Margarita
Veal Parmigiani

“Delicious! The chicken francaise and chicken marsala were both so good. Crispy calamari was okay- breading was a little underwhelming but we loved the thai chili sauce. Mashed potatoes were very yummy but the rice pilaf could use some work. The homemade cheesecake was the perfect ending and we each had leftovers!! Staff was friendly and very attentive. We enjoyed our dinner very much and will definitely be back!“

4 Good71 Reviews

16
Sbarro

Sbarro Pizza • $
7401 Market St, Boardman - 9.36 miles

“I love Sbarro the crew is always really nice, they are always clean washing hands and being safe, food is amazing if I want pizza I get sbarro! Pizza Hut or Domino’s could never! Mike is usually running this location he’s so kind he knows his customers by name tell him Monica sent you?“

4.3 Superb7 Reviews
Blue Wolf Tavern American • $$
1295 Boardman-Canfield Rd, Boardman - 9.39 miles

Customers` Favorites

Blackened Chicken Alfredo
Chicken Francaise
Chicken Allouette
Chicken Carbonara
Chicken Marsala
Fish Sandwich
Chicken Parm
Wedding Soup
Veal Parm
Peppers

“Servers always great you with a “smile & hello”, food served in an appealing way and delicious! One of my good-to’s regularly. Pricing fair for quantity you get, and daily specials too. 50cent jumbo wing night Monday is a favorite of mine, and they are huge….“

3.9 Good86 Reviews
LaRoccas Pizza & Pasta Italian • $
6505 Clingan Rd, Poland - 10.77 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cavatelli and Meatballs
Cavatelli Dinner
Tiramisu

“From Florida to Ohio, this is the best Italian Restaurant hands down! Authentic and reminds me of my mother’s sauce. Always have to argue with myself over whether to have braciola or cavatelli. Usually the braciola wins out and it’s fantastic. Plus very few restaurants even make it. You can’t go wrong and will not be disappointed. if you’re craving good Italian food this is the place to go!“

3.9 Good32 Reviews
Belleria Pizza & Italian Pizza • $$
8485 Market St, Youngstown - 7.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sausage Sandwich
Chicken Parmesan
Fresh Cut Fries
Pepperoni Pizza
Grilled Chicken
Steak Salad
White Pizza
A Sandwich
Veal Parm
Roll

“Typical Italian place, common for this area. The food was good but nothing to brag about. Prices are in line with other area restaurants BUT they have an excellent lunch menu, reasonably priced and very filling.Not a bad visit, just nothing to write home about food wise. Our server, a very nice, smiling young lady got a $10 tip due to her very friendly and positive attitude. Sorry I did not get her name.Parking: When busy, there aren't a lot of spaces available.“

3.8 Good53 Reviews
Gionino's Pizzeria Pizza • $
375 E Main St, Canfield - 9.83 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Fried Chicken
Deluxe Pizza

“I'm not the biggest fan of their pizza but that is nothing against them. Just not my style. I've gotten subs, salad and sides there and have loved all of it. Their service is great and they offer pizza by the slice during lunch which is very convenient.“

3.7 Good23 Reviews
Antone's Kitchen Italian • $
1419 Boardman-Canfield Rd, Boardman - 9.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

Angle Hair Past with Alfredo Sauce on Cheese Bread Bowl
Cheesy Bread Bowl with Gnocchi
Eggplant & Chicken Parmesan
The Cavatelli & Meatballs
The Rigatoni & Meatballs
Loaded Fried Cheese
The Antone's Salad
Chicken Alfredo
Antones Salad
Wedding Soup

“Great service and awesome food. The Italian greens are by far the best in the area. Antones salad is always fresh and delicious. You can pick up a jar of Sunday sauce or antones salad dressing. A great addition to every home I highly recommend.“

3.7 Good59 Reviews
Combine Brothers Italian • $
7412 Market St, Boardman - 9.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Pizza with Peppers and Onions and Bacon
Ziti with Pink Pepper Chicken and Mushrooms
Lunch Bowtie Pasta with Crumpled Sausage
Angel Hair Pasta with Marinara Sauce
Pasta Alfredo Bowl Lunch Special
Muscles over a Bed of Spaghetti
Side Salad & Pink Pepper Pasta
House Salad with Vinagrete
Chicken Parmesan Dinner
Homemade Hot Rolls

“Always love the food here and THE ROLLS!!! Tried their pizza for the first time today and enjoyed it very much! Will certainly order that again. Love all the pasta dishes and the salad here as well. This is really a can't go wrong place for a filling and delicious meal!“

3.7 Good99 Reviews
De Chellis Italian Cafe Cafe • $
11092 Main St, New Middletown - 8.73 miles

Customers` Favorites

All You Can Eat Fish
Seafood Primavera
Salad
Sauce

“The Fish Dinner here is really good one of the Best I've ever had tried the Beer battered Haddock and the Next time I went the Parmesan crusted it's a toss up both were amazing. Next time I went I got the stuffed Italian meatloaf stuffed with Italian greens and ricotta cheese it was delicious the only thing about here is you wait awhile for your meal because they are understaffed but it's worth the wait in my opinion really good food.“

3.5 Good21 Reviews
Inner Circle Pizza Canfield Italian • $
6579 Ironwood Blvd, Canfield - 9.53 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheese Fries
Boneless Wings
Fried Pickles
Italian Fries
Circle Salad
Hot Chips
Pizza

“Overall: Tasty pizza, huge menu, and solid drinks. We would visit again.Pros:*Extensive menu with unique items.*Reasonably priced, including drinks*Everything was hot/cold, as needed*Waitress was attentive and experienced*We ordered pizza and BBQ wings. We also ordered some beers and a couple cocktails (Marilyn Monroe Martini & Old Fashioned) - everything was tasty, especially the drinks.*Food service was fast.Cons:*We waited 20 minutes for a table on a Sunday night.*Drink service was slow.*We tried to order carrot and ranch with our wings, but they were out of carrots.*Pizza was extremely cheesy but the toppings were sparse. They charged $2.00 per topping, and we got about .25 cents worth.*We would have preferred the pizza to be cooked just a bit more; it was just past done.Kid-friendliness: They had a kids menu. We were seated in the bar with our 11-year-old. The language from some of the bar/service staff was not appropriate for kids. Not a huge deal for our pre-teen, but it may be something to be aware of for others.“

3.6 Good47 Reviews
Loading...
map Map