23 Best Italian Restaurants near Columbiana

“food is always delicious. Great prices and a large menu selection. highly recommend.“

“I love this place, the waitress serving us was very nice and had great customer service. I got the chicken broccolini and it was amazing. the chicken was delicious and one of the best chicken i’ve had from an italian restaurant. would very much recommend.“

“Usually friendly service, I'm not sure if the waitress was having an off day but I sat for 15 minutes before I was even asked if I was waiting on anyone or wanted a drink. I ordered an appetizer and it took 20 minutes. 3 couples who came in after me have already been served. I told her I wanted to order and she disappeared. I asked on the status of my appetizer when she reappeared and she said that takes 10 minutes. I said okay, it was at least 15 minutes ago. So far I've been here at least 35 minutes and have just ordered my pizza at 2:08pm. My pizza didn't arrive until 2:32 . The food is good but the service certainly doesn't match. I think in the future we will frequent another location.“

“One of the worst dining experience I ever had. The noise from the kitchen was so loud we couldn't even talk. My wife's fish was way over cooked my pork chop was tough that I did not take it home. The price was way to high. I eat out 3or4 times a week and always at finer restaurants I would not ever go back.“

“Had Dr. appointment up the road this morning, asked for decent place to eat near by; boy, did we get one! Kathy, our waitress was extremely sociable, efficient, and Johnny on the spot! My only regret, I forgot my leftovers that were going to be my supper! Would not only recommend, but will return when next in area.“

“The first time we went was Valentine's day. things were a little chaotic at the entrance with people checking in, getting take out or waiting for a table. However, the food was delicious! Our service was great as well. We will definitely return!“

“We love Papa GeGe’s and the staff AND the food. The food is AMAZING. We love that it’s a BYOB. I think the veal Parmesan is the best I have ever had. I ordered it twice. The soup is amazing. We really enjoyed the cannoli. Beast Italian food around, hands down!!!“

“We have been coming here for a number of years and have never had anything that was not delicious. The salad is fresh, the dressing is so good it requires bread to dunk in and eat.. The vodka sauce was something I tried last time we ate there and it was so good, it made my eyes roll. For such a small space there is always room enough to have a quiet meal and enjoy the best dining around.“

“I’ve been coming to this location in Boardman for the last few years. I absolutely loved it until the food started to change recently. What I noticed quickly was that they weren’t using the homemade noodles. I was quickly disappointed because that was the main reason why I went there. The food doesn’t have the same authentic taste, especially now that it feels like I’m eating less expensive store-bought pasta.“

“Marys Pizza is one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had, I have tried pizzas all over and I still go back to Marys Pizza. It’s the best! I live in Youngstown Ohio but grew up in Lisbon and I still cannot find a pizza in Youngstown area as good as Mary’s!“

“Party of 8 as a walk in and was treated amazingly! Food and Service was outstanding.“

“Went to the one in Boardman OH. The carpet smelled terrible. I was disappointed that they dont allow you to take home a soup. I dont go as often as I used to. The waitress was nice but never brought me my second bowl of soup or salad, then made a fuss when she allowed me to have one to take home. I added the all-you-can-eat can eat salad to my meal and took the lasagne home for my husband.“

“Combine Brothers in Boardman is amazing! The place feels cozy and inviting. The menu has lots of choices, and the pasta is the best! The Alfredo is so creamy and delicious. The staff is super friendly and helpful. If you want great food and service, you have to try Combine Brothers!“

“Great food and an excellent server. Thanks Ashlee!“

“. I got the half sheet and it was delicious! The service was great also! Definitely will be back!“

“I had two styles of pizza. The Youngstown and I don’t know what the other was but they were amazing!! The sauce is delicious and the dough was perfect!“

“Looks like it is a fancy dress place from the outside but once you go in, it is inviting, relaxing, and casual. It us a seafood steakhouse but offer so many other items. Staff were friendly. The food. OMGEEE!!!! Soo good!! I wasn't that hungry so I got the stuffed mushroom off the starter menu. It was big and stuffed with the best crabmeat stuffing, and the sauce it is served in was tasty and fresh bread(good to sop up sauce from mushroom). Other guest had pasta with mussels. Waitress suggested the wet version and it did not disappoint. I did not wait long for food but while I was waiting I was looking around and all the servers were having a great time at their tables. I am in the area at least 4 times a year and I will keep going there because I want to try so many things on the menu. I think the next time I'm gonna start with the dessert and pack a meal to go. North Lima OH. You have to go there!!“

“LOVE LOVE LOVE this place! My girl and I order it every time we are in the Boardman Area! You HAVE to try the Stuffed Eggplant & the chicken parm!! It’s delicious! And for dessert a MUST HAVE is the peanut butter pie! YUM YUM YUM!!! If you’re thinking about trying it DO IT! You will not be disappointed!!!“

“Thank you for hosting our wedding reception! The food was amazing! The space was lovely and your staff were pros! So accommodating, flexible and had great ideas! Thank you for helping to decorate, serve our guests and tear down! I highly recommend this restaurant and staff for your large party needs♥️“

“Best pizza in town!✅😃😃😃👍🏼💕“

“I actually don’t recommend. What pizza place stops delivering at 8 pm and doesnt deliver at all on other days. Cocas always delivers. Guess they get my business.“

“Ate there for the first time today. Celebrating my wife’s birthday. The food was excellent. We will be back for sure. I highly recommend.“

“Seems new and improved! It had been a while since our last visit. The young man working drove through was clean cut, polite, & professional. The food was excellent and the prices are affordable. Thanks for being a quick and convenient place to pick up dinner in Poland!“