8 Best Italian Restaurants in New Castle

“food is homemade and delicious“

“We always have a great meal & dessert at Soni’s! Love their red sauce - my favorite dinner is the Italian Platter! We had Brian as our server tonight- he is fantastic- he always has a great demeanor!!!“

“My son gets us a take out every week! Never disappointed. Sauce, chicken marsala, tortellini... plus many more dinners are de!!“

“I came here for my Granddaughtes birthday. My husband was a chef for a hotel in Pittsburgh so I eat good food. Well I loved the food here. The servers were great too. I recommend this place to everyone. Thank you I will be back.“

“good food and good service nice atmosphere“

“Mark was a great server… food was amazing! Great dinner with mom on a Friday!!“

“If you are looking for a good slice of pizza in a non-descript setting for a reasonable price and served by a friendly staff, go to Mr. Pizza. As you can see they are generous with their toppings. Their sauce is delicious and flavorful with a just-perfect, crispy crust.“

“I was just passing through town and honestly didn’t expect to find a spot like this. Seeing a big Southern Italian last name on the sign immediately caught my attention, so I had to stop in, and I’m glad I did.
This is a genuinely authentic Italian-American place with that warm feel that makes you feel at home the moment you walk in. I ordered a capocollo-ham sandwich with provolone, lettuce, tomato, and Italian dressing. Fresh ingredients, well made, and very satisfying. I also tried the garlic knots, something I always judge Italian places by, and they were very good. Fresh, soft, and flavorful. If I had one tiny suggestion, I’d say a little extra garlic wouldn’t hurt, but that’s just personal preference.
The spinach stromboli was excellent. Fresh, clearly house made dough, and exactly what you hope for. I finished with cannoli, and they were absolutely on point. Small, authentic, and delicious.
I also loved that they had all the little extras that make a place feel real. Cookies, jars of pickled garlic and peppers. specialty items, packaged pasta to take home. The whole atmosphere just felt welcoming and genuine.
A really pleasant surprise in a town where I wasn’t expecting much. Definitely worth stopping if you appreciate authentic Italian-American food.

One fun suggestion: add a Nutella stromboli to the menu. If you do, naming it “The Stefano” would only be fair. 😄“