12 Best Sandwich Shops in New Castle

“Incredibly polite people. Service is very fast too. I got the lamb gyro. It was very filling. Flavor wise it was good but it didnt taste like the traditional gyros that i'm used to. I couldn't taste any tatziki (yogurt) sauce and they could've added more tomato and cut the meat into thinner slices (the meat tasted good just not like gyro meat that im used to - it was more like a fluffy meat loaf that your mom might make then the tightly packed thin slices you'd typically get.) My order total was around 15 dollars after adding a small drink and a substantial side of pita chips and a dressing cup of hummus, which i regret getting. If you just get the gyro its 10 dollars which I would say is a fair value as the ingredients were fresh and it was a sizable wrap. However in hind sight the chips and hummus weren't worth the extra money as they both were a little bland. If i come back im going to try the fries instead. All in all it's worth stopping in though. Its a small shop but the seating area is attractive. I could see it being a good place for a casual first date.“

“Great food and friendly staff. Our family go to for hot dogs and sandwiches.“

“We eat here a few times a month. Great food. The girl's are always friendly. The owner is very friendly. This is the West State Street shop. Since he bought the business it's so much better. To all the worker's and owner Thank you for great service and food.“

“Bill‘s hotdog are the best hotdog around. They are better than Coney Island..“

“The two employees had just received a large online order and were understandably a little overwhelmed. They worked quickly and efficiently to make sure we got our subs- which were great! Awesome demonstration of time management and customer service.“

“My local subway always does it right! The workers have changed over the years but whoever is working always gets it right. The prices are somewhat expensive but if you have the app or the coupons that come in the mail it is affordable. I don’t think I have ever been disappointed with this subway!“

“1st time here. Ordered the #13 The Original Italian Mike's Way. EXCELLENT. The 3 employees on today's shift 05/27/26 1:09 pm did a fantastic job of making everything fresh & delicious and as quickly as possible because it was a busy afternoon! The choices of sandwiches to choose from are a nice selection, looking forward to going back. This Jersey Mike's Sub shop is CLEAN. When departing, the employee who sliced the meat for our subs Thanked us for eating in & told us our business was appreciated. Class Act employees. KUDOS Jersey Mike's Subs 8104“

“This Subway in the plaza across from Shanango schools is clean, friendly, and gets enough business so the food is always fresh.

I got the spicy Italian sub, and they made it to my specs exactly.

I recommend this Subway as a very good place to get a well made and tasty sub.“

“Overall, a five! Because the service was great and they made my sub, large spicy Italian, one ea. exactly to spec.

I hadn't eaten at a subway in a few years, just because I like Philly steaks, and only get those from a restaurant.

But, for a good lunch, and a great sub sandwich, the subway in Shenango across from the high school is really waaay better than I expected.

So, five stars, based on service and the Spicy Italian sub being actually good.“