“Great selection. The amount of candy molds, cookie cutters and LorAnn flavor oils alone is a dream come true. Definitely coming back for more. Only small downside some items were not labeled/priced, but not that big of a deal staff are helpful and can tell you pricing.“
“We have decided to try different donut places in the area and added May's to list a few weeks ago. Thankfully their New Castle location is near a relatives house. My parents were driving past today so stopped to get me a dozen. I can't speak of the actual bakery, but the donuts that they brought me had a great variety and tasted like homemade. Not bakery homemade, but like in a home kitchen, made with lots of love homemade. I loved that they were generous with their filling, icing and other toppings. I also like that they have been around for so many years and are a staple of the community!“
“Ordered a birthday cake for my dad, had it done in 1 day. Most delicious banana cake I've ever had. Buttercream icing is perfect. We have for sure found our new cake place. My dad was incredibly happy with it. Can't wait to try more stuff!!“
“Their prices are not any higher than anyone else's and atleast the points for gas and groceries help to off the prices and the employees are always friendly and helpful. The store is clean and I think they did a very good job during Covid.“
“I shop here all the time and have for many years and have never had a problem with anything or anyone, everyone's always been nice. It's always clean. It's nice to go to a smaller store that's close by as opposed to a huge store with super long lines that takes forever to shop in and is farther away from where I live. I've compared WM prices to this store and it's sometimes a couple cents difference. Overall I'm happy with this store.“
“Beth is honestly the sweetest lady I've ever met. She made me a vanilla icecream cake for my boyfriends birthday and it was absolutely beautiful. It tasted as good as it looked. Her prices are fair and I highly recommend her. Its absolutely worth it.“
“Love this place! They are friendly, and helpful. The food is good. Love everything I have tried. I went in one day on my way home and just wanted a 2 pieces of pizza for lunch. I stood there waiting for help and this lady came in and came right in front of me and took the rest of the pizza. They felt so bad and made me a pizza. Love the meatball sandwich and their bread. If you're ever in New Castle and see Two Fat Guys and an oven stop in, you won't be sorry. Just heads up there a busy place but well worth it!“