Bakeries near New Castle

Two Fat Guys and an Oven Bakery • $
811 Moravia St, New Castle

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie
Cinnamon Rolls and Danish
Lady Locks Cannoli Pastry
Banana Chocolate Chip
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Fried Fish Sandwich
The Italian Sandwich
Wedding Cookies
Italian Bread
Cake

“2Fg&aO has been a weekly work staple. Offering a great variety of options and the best sweet treats in town. Highly recommend!!“

4.7 Superb205 Reviews
Mays Classic Donut Shop Donut Shops • $
Rigotti's Plaza, 1214 Butler Ave, New Castle

Customers` Favorites

Powdered Blueberry Doughnut

“Really should come down and talk to Peggy she worked at the May‘s donuts for many years downtown New Castle it was on E. Washington St. she made me a fresh pot of coffee asked me if I had the time to wait for a fresh pot of coffee and I did so we chatted a while did not get a donut because I’m not really much of a donut eater The coffee was good“

4.6 Superb59 Reviews
Mary Mac Bakehouse Bakery • $
227 Cleland Mill Rd, New Castle

“OMG, y'all! If you have never tried Miss Mary's goodies, you need to get your butt to her site and order some! I just finished making the chocolate chip cookie muffins and my husband already ate three of them and I had two and want another! Her food is AMAZING!! 😍😍😍❤️❤️❤️“

5 Superb3 Reviews
Auntie Anne's Pretzel Store • $
2501 W State St, New Castle
2.1 Poor7 Reviews
Beth's Cakes & Candy Bakery • $
817 Harmony Baptist Rd, New Castle

“Beth’s Cake & Candy is truly the best!“

0 Na0 Reviews
sprites delights Bakery •
E Edgewood Ave, New Castle
0 Na0 Reviews
Cookies and Candies by Christy Bakery • $
West Pittsburg

“Christy went above and beyond to make sure I was well taken care of. My Christmas shipping order was last minute and she was still very sweet about accommodating. Everything looks and tastes AMAZING!!! I even accidentally dropped the box myself, so I can only imagine what transpired during shipping… but not 1 cookie was damaged! 5 stars aren’t enough!!!“

5 Superb1 Reviews

Find More Tastes In New Castle