Have always loved the hot dog chili. They need to back off on the salt in the dogs. Much too salty.
Mary Sholey
The chili was lacking any flavor that it had
Valerie Williamson Bonadio
M&P Coney Island has been a hometown restaurant in New Castle for 97 years now and still going strong. The family that owns it has also has been a big part of New Castle. They have the best chili sauce in the county. I love my Coney Island.
danieldC36TV
Delicious stuff!! Very simple the chili is essentially what they’re known for!! Cheese fries are with shredded cheese. Definitely different. Prices are dirt cheap! Line was pretty slow through drive through but food was good!
Tom Kelly
Never got a good meal there ever. Not recommended even if it is free.
Best chili dogs and chili cheese fries!
Great dogs!!
Good food and good service
Have always loved the hot dog chili. They need to back off on the salt in the dogs. Much too salty.
The chili was lacking any flavor that it had
M&P Coney Island has been a hometown restaurant in New Castle for 97 years now and still going strong. The family that owns it has also has been a big part of New Castle. They have the best chili sauce in the county. I love my Coney Island.
Delicious stuff!! Very simple the chili is essentially what they’re known for!! Cheese fries are with shredded cheese. Definitely different. Prices are dirt cheap! Line was pretty slow through drive through but food was good!
Never got a good meal there ever. Not recommended even if it is free.
Great food. Reasonable prices.
Awesome filling food, great prices!
Restaurantji Recommends
Very good food...i would tell anyone,,,, go too M & P. CONEY ISLAND,,, GREAT FOOD.....???????
Kinda dirty on the inside..the hotdogs seem to be made well in advance of any order..poor taste and terrible buns...i just ate 4 hotdogs just chili...
Love the chili cheese fries
wonderful chili for hot dogs
The foods ok, pricing is good, pretty dated interior.
Loading...