Fat Jimmy's LLC

2612 New Butler Rd, New Castle
(724) 598-3500

Recent Reviews

David

Food was good. Service was good. Don't hesitate to stop and try

Dan B

The owner is the cook now and her cooking sucks can never get anything right over cooked bacon, food no good any more it was way better when she was never around and had a cook that knows how to cook, it comes down to if she's drunk or not when she cooking and let me tell you she sick a lot too I bet there alot of code violations there too, was there eating and the female bathroom backed up and went all in the dining room could not eat she never try to give our money back or a discount for it. She treats her employees like slavery wonder why she's short staffed do not go there there alot better places go down the street three minutes to Kelley's way better food

Trisha Thomas

One of the best bbq places I have ever been! Small little whole in the wall place, family oriented, and the employees were really friendly! We will be going back!

John B (Johnb380)

Went for breakfast and the food was amazing. Staff was polite and helpful. Overall a great experience. They have buckwheat pancakes and they're very tasty! Have to return for the BBQ or Saturdays they have steak night but great breakfast food and service!

Benjamin Rankin

Food is good, you just never know when the place will be

Kara Rubaker

We stopped in for a quick bite and were very satisfied! Great service and great fries and they even take care to use excellent local coffee! We will be back!

Karl Moore

The foods Great. It's like a truck stop type of food. severs are very nice.

brandon l

I've been wanting to try this place for a long time. They were the absolute worst ribs I've ever had. They were super dry and tough. I just ended up eating the sides and not eating the rest of the ribs. I gave them 3 stars because the waitress was so nice.

Allison Reynolds

Wow!!! Talk about the best little hole in the wall. Every single thing we ate was home cooked and absolutely delicious with decent prices and great portions! Between the four of us we had brisket sandwiches fries onion rings baked beans Mac and cheese and fresh steaks (made fresh on the grill out back - perfectly cooked to our asking). The sweetest waitress working her butt off serving everyone in the restaurant. Very small place but the seating in the back was made completely of wood with an adorable fire place to boot. Will be returning frequently as possible. Fresh brewed sweet tea was great too!!!

Nani “Novi” Noverita

OMG my most favorite dish is the homemade corn beef hash!!! I mean homemade…so good! Best corn beef hash ever!

Alan Seachrist

Make sure you go on a Saturday for thier delicious steaks. Big fire grilled steaks for a great price.

Alan Feldman

Great food and value. Excellent service.

Inda Akenhead

Fat Jimmy's has tantalizing flavors that bring out the best in their food. Everything I have tried is delicious. Frog legs, Gator tail, and Pig Wings are my favorite next to their amazing baked beans. You can buy them by the quart also and it's always worth it. I definitely recommend going. The staff is always friendly, helpful, and go out of their way to make your meal perfect.

Dean Ruscitti

This place is a Hidden Gem great food great everything

AdakC

It starts out by being told what they don't have, and went down from there. We did have 8 people. There was only one other couple in the place. Service was very slow. The food was warm at best. One of the steaks was over cooked. The ribs had so much sauce and cover up the taste of the meat. When paying the woman at the counter was rude to all of us. She couldn't figure out who had what. When you tried to help she got mad. Will never go back.

Load More