The food was deserving of 3 stars but the service ruined the experience.
Pittsburgh Pirates Hat
14 dollars for 5 hot dogs, 4 mozzarella sticks, and a Pepsi is a great deal. The hot dogs were good far from the best hot dogs I ever had but definitely better than anywhere else I’ve gotten hot dogs at in Lawrence county and at very affordable prices too. Definitely recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lynn Kushinski
Great deal. Cash only. Hamburger, fries and drink is $6.95. Good portions and tasty food. Fries were hot and crispy. Indoor dining. Glad we stopped.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lynn Foltz
Best Friday fish meal ever! The fish is consistently good. The Cole slaw is yummy and the fries are perfect!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
ErikB329
Cash only only reason for a 3 on service. But I understand credit card processing fees are ridiculous.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Aunt Nessie
$25 for 4 people, large chili/cheese fries, 5 hotdogs, roast beef melt (on Texas toast), and 4 waters. I dont think the price was bad. It’s 5 hotdogs for $7.50. They served us with a smile when the cashier took our order and when another woman gave us our tray, so then I watched the customers after us (even 10 -20 mins later) and each worker was serving them with a smile. So great service, they all seemed hard at work. Food tasted great, just the way it should be I like that they warm the buns for the hotdogs, food tasted perfect. I think they’re the only ones that have those lemon packets to put in water which I love! Restaurant was clean. The fries were medium thick size and tasted fresh! They weren’t too thin, just perfect. Restrooms weee clean also. I loved the melted roast beef on Texas toast, amazing. Defiantly will return.
If you can find a bad review about Jimmy’s in New Castle, it’s fake. This place gets some serious love for just serving chili dogs. And I am seriously kidding. They serve fish dinners, gyros, and, the best in the area, souvlaki.Souvlaki is marinated cubed lean pork that is marinated before it is cooked on the flat grill and served on the pita that has ALSO been heated up on the flat top. I’m not a fan of places that just pull the pita out the bag and assemble it into a gyro or whatever. Jimmy’s does a good job heating the pita up. And that is a big thing to me. It’s a walk in joint with plenty of parking and a nice steady crowd. It’s my favorite dog shop from New Castle to Youngstown and Sharon, just because the owner is almost always there. Taking orders, shouting back to the cook the orders and any variation the customers want. Another spot where I have NEVER had anything that wasn’t perfect. Oh, and my favorite chili sauce of all the other spots. Not runny, and the best taste. Not spicy, not mild. Just right. Jimmy’s, great hot dogs, and everything else on the menu too!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hotdog Burger Chilli Cheese Fries, Two Chili Dog w Fries Special, Fish Sandwich
The absolute BEST chili in the tri state, heck probably nationaly! The dogs are always HOT and fresh not tough and burnt like a lot of the so called competition. If chili and dogs aren't your thing it's okay because they have a menu full of absolutely delicious and AFFORDABLE food. Been going here since 2010 and literally never left upset!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chris Barletta
Always was good, reccently barely any chili on fries, hardly any chili on chili cheeseburgers, threw it out,
Food: 1
Barbara Hemphill
Love this place!!!!@
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Two Chili Dog w Fries Special
David Mayo
Chili dogs were the best I had in a long time! Great service, nice crowd, definitely coming back
pcampbell74
Stopped in Jimmy’s in New Castle, PA on Friday to grab dinner. I was told that they had great subs and sandwiches. I was greeted warmly at the counter by the owner, very personable. He happily took my order and rang me out. Jimmys is CASH only, so remember to hit the ATM before you come here. If you do happen to forget, there is a ATM in the store. I ordered the Turkey, salami & cheese sub, giant size with an order of onion rings. I only had to wait a few minutes before my order was up. A big, beautiful sub sandwich & hot onion rings were awaiting me. I got home, sat down and absolutely enjoyed my sandwich, I may have put too much mayonnaise on it, but man was it good. Nice soft bread, quality deli meat & fresh veggies, the onion rings were hot, nice and crisp. I will definitely be returning to Jimmy’s to get more of his awesome sub sandwich’s. If you’re a fan of good deli subs & sandwich’s, Jimmy’s is the place for you.
The food was deserving of 3 stars but the service ruined the experience.
14 dollars for 5 hot dogs, 4 mozzarella sticks, and a Pepsi is a great deal. The hot dogs were good far from the best hot dogs I ever had but definitely better than anywhere else I’ve gotten hot dogs at in Lawrence county and at very affordable prices too. Definitely recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great deal. Cash only. Hamburger, fries and drink is $6.95. Good portions and tasty food. Fries were hot and crispy. Indoor dining. Glad we stopped.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best Friday fish meal ever! The fish is consistently good. The Cole slaw is yummy and the fries are perfect!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cash only only reason for a 3 on service. But I understand credit card processing fees are ridiculous.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
$25 for 4 people, large chili/cheese fries, 5 hotdogs, roast beef melt (on Texas toast), and 4 waters. I dont think the price was bad. It’s 5 hotdogs for $7.50. They served us with a smile when the cashier took our order and when another woman gave us our tray, so then I watched the customers after us (even 10 -20 mins later) and each worker was serving them with a smile. So great service, they all seemed hard at work. Food tasted great, just the way it should be I like that they warm the buns for the hotdogs, food tasted perfect. I think they’re the only ones that have those lemon packets to put in water which I love! Restaurant was clean. The fries were medium thick size and tasted fresh! They weren’t too thin, just perfect. Restrooms weee clean also. I loved the melted roast beef on Texas toast, amazing. Defiantly will return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hotdog Burger Chilli Cheese Fries
Awesome chili dogs. Great prices!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Two Chili Dog w Fries Special
Best fish around on Fridays.
Souvlaki..great, fresh. Followed by rice pudding.
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you can find a bad review about Jimmy’s in New Castle, it’s fake. This place gets some serious love for just serving chili dogs. And I am seriously kidding. They serve fish dinners, gyros, and, the best in the area, souvlaki.Souvlaki is marinated cubed lean pork that is marinated before it is cooked on the flat grill and served on the pita that has ALSO been heated up on the flat top. I’m not a fan of places that just pull the pita out the bag and assemble it into a gyro or whatever. Jimmy’s does a good job heating the pita up. And that is a big thing to me. It’s a walk in joint with plenty of parking and a nice steady crowd. It’s my favorite dog shop from New Castle to Youngstown and Sharon, just because the owner is almost always there. Taking orders, shouting back to the cook the orders and any variation the customers want. Another spot where I have NEVER had anything that wasn’t perfect. Oh, and my favorite chili sauce of all the other spots. Not runny, and the best taste. Not spicy, not mild. Just right. Jimmy’s, great hot dogs, and everything else on the menu too!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hotdog Burger Chilli Cheese Fries, Two Chili Dog w Fries Special, Fish Sandwich
Restaurantji Recommends
The absolute BEST chili in the tri state, heck probably nationaly! The dogs are always HOT and fresh not tough and burnt like a lot of the so called competition. If chili and dogs aren't your thing it's okay because they have a menu full of absolutely delicious and AFFORDABLE food. Been going here since 2010 and literally never left upset!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always was good, reccently barely any chili on fries, hardly any chili on chili cheeseburgers, threw it out,
Food: 1
Love this place!!!!@
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Two Chili Dog w Fries Special
Chili dogs were the best I had in a long time! Great service, nice crowd, definitely coming back
Stopped in Jimmy’s in New Castle, PA on Friday to grab dinner. I was told that they had great subs and sandwiches. I was greeted warmly at the counter by the owner, very personable. He happily took my order and rang me out. Jimmys is CASH only, so remember to hit the ATM before you come here. If you do happen to forget, there is a ATM in the store. I ordered the Turkey, salami & cheese sub, giant size with an order of onion rings. I only had to wait a few minutes before my order was up. A big, beautiful sub sandwich & hot onion rings were awaiting me. I got home, sat down and absolutely enjoyed my sandwich, I may have put too much mayonnaise on it, but man was it good. Nice soft bread, quality deli meat & fresh veggies, the onion rings were hot, nice and crisp. I will definitely be returning to Jimmy’s to get more of his awesome sub sandwich’s. If you’re a fan of good deli subs & sandwich’s, Jimmy’s is the place for you.
Loading...