Little Johnny's II

130 E Washington St, New Castle
(724) 657-2210

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Meghan Jasmine Morrissey

The best mozzarella sticks I’ve ever had. The service is amazing and helpful 10/10

Michael McKinnis

they will take your order charge your card then after that they will send you an email 10 minutes later saying they canceled your order and have to wait for them to send your money back that they already took

Josh Ottaviani

You cannot go wrong with anything on their menu. From the wings, to the pizza, to the appetizers, everything is top-notch! One of the few places that deliver to my address, so I am a frequent customer. You won’t be disappointed.

Allie Sullivan

We just ordered $60 worth of food that showed up cold. They charged $2.50 for an extra topping, and there was a total of 7 pieces on the entire large pizza. Oh, and then they don't answer the phone so that you can't inform them that their service and food is garbage. So, I'll wait for my half-assed 'we're sorry you had a bad experience' reply and hopefully this touches enough people that your business feels the effects. Because I can't get refunded like I should. Boo!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Maximillian Kincaid

The first time I went in one of the employees moms was there talking my ear off and I couldn't sit back and relax I had my service dog with me and she decided she wanted to pet it I had to tell her no The second time I went in a DoorDash delivery driver decided she wanted to pet my service Doberman I told her no she called me a psychopath and then called the police on me because I'm a black man with a dog in a restaurant The third time I went in I sat for 49 minutes for chicken sandwich and a burger I left at the 50th minute The burgers were overcooked the first two visits and the third visit they had to eat it themselves

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Cassie Lynnie

At this point if I could give zero stars I would. What was once a great place has gone completely down hill. Today was the second time I ordered and received nothing. Last time I ordered ,30 minutes later they called to tell me they didn’t have enough wings to fulfill the order and cancelled. Ok, so be it. It was irritating to find out 30 minutes after the order was placed but whatever. Today I ordered and my delivery was scheduled for 4:45 (order was placed at 3:45). 5:05 rolls around and I call to check on my order they say it’s on the way. ( I live probably less than 2 miles from the shop). 5:35 rolls around still no food. I attempt to cancel since I have to be at work shortly and it becomes a whole process. So here we are 5:48pm, finally got confirmation of the order being cancelled, no food, and rushing to get dinner on the road to work. They say it’s under new management and sadly that’s when most businesses go to crap.

Xenox Legend

Always love supporting the small businesses of America! This one is a gem! Open on Sundays unlike a lot of these other lazy pizza shops. They’re making pizza great again!

Catherine Airgood

Ordered over $100 of food through door dash tipped $20 for the Italian sandwich to have barely any meat on it and my buffalo chicken salad to not be buffalo chicken. I called and very politely told them my issue but all the manager said was I could come pick up some hott sauce... If I'm driving 20 minutes to your restaurant you can remake my salad!!!!! Completely refused to remake it! A buffalo chicken bread bowl salad is almost $20 the least you can do is get it right

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

2solidPrez

Wings was not crispy French fries super soggy

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

Robert Barkley

Ordered Italian flatbread with no tomato came with tomato on It. didn’t want to remake my order an the bottom of the flatbread is so soggy. Order 7/6/2024 Never go here again

Latoya Glenel

I just ordered today I asked for strawberry hot I got my food and they talking but he dusted them in it I said what happened to the cup we get buttom line is these new folks need to gone head cause they were dry af them people is cheap and I will never eat from them again not to mention it took them a whole hr and my food was cold

Pittsburgh Pirates Hat

The pizza was one of the worst pizzas I’ve ever had in my life. It was disgusting. Weird taste and texture and it smelled like a cardboard box. They use immensely cheap ingredients and the taste makes it painfully obvious yet they charge over 15 dollars for an 8 cut pizza.

There is exposed wiring, flickering lights, holes and chipping and missing paint in the walls, and the seats are dingy and disgusting.

However, the service was great the lady behind the counter was very friendly and polite. It’s a shame the food was so nasty.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 5

Jessica Sizer

Pricey for delivery, but it was fast and hot when we got it. The ranch dressing is to die for!

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Zucchini Strips, Traditional 4 Cut, Onion Rings

Josh Ottaviani

Just came across this place within the last month. Where I am located near 422/Sheetz, we are very limited on delivery options. Received a menu in the mail one day and realized Little Johnnys delivers in my area. I have been ordering from here ever since and I have not had one bad meal. The wings are great, the pizza is great (homestyle and Pierogi so far), the appetizers were great, the french fries were great and the salads were great! I would highly recommend trying them out…this is definitely my new “go-to.”

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Homestyle Pizza, Zucchini Strips, Pierogi Pizza, 12 Cut - 10 Wings & 2l

Montana Myers

I love the pizza. It has a sweet sauce. I consider Little Johnny's to be the best in town.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Homestyle Pizza, Johnny Fingers, Pop

Loading...