Medure's Catering

2500 New Butler Rd, New Castle
(724) 654-5465

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Maria Gillen

We had Medure's Catering for our wedding reception this past June at the Shermichael Woods. Our guests continue to bring up how it was the best food they have ever had at a wedding! Everything was presented phenomenally and tasted amazing. We loved our taste testing experience, and they were very easy to work with for any needed changes. Our bartenders were hilarious while professional and added to the experience for our guests. We would reccomend Medure's over any other caterer!

Jay Fulvi (JaYBiRd)

Top notch. From a serve safe certified Chef with a culinary degree in culinary arts. I was impressed.

Marcie Johnson

Medure’s Catering was absolutely outstanding! Pete was incredibly helpful and accommodating throughout the entire process, always quick to respond to our last-minute questions and clarifications. Our guests couldn’t stop raving about the food, and we heard over and over again how amazing everything tasted. And here’s our best piece of advice: don’t even question it—always get the eggplant rollatini! Truly a flawless catering experience from start to finish.

Brianna Love

We couldn’t have been happier with the catering for our wedding! Medure's catered our December wedding at Iron's Mill Farmstead. The food was absolutely delicious, beautifully presented, and perfectly timed throughout the evening. Many of our guests complimented not only the taste but also the quality and variety of the dishes. The team was professional, attentive, and made sure everything ran smoothly, which allowed us to relax and truly enjoy the celebration. Their service and attention to detail made a huge difference in creating an unforgettable reception. Highly recommend!

Lauren Ferianc

Medure’s is the exclusive caterer at The Gathering Place at Darlington Lake, and we couldn’t have been happier with their professionalism and services! Samantha, the catering director, was so helpful leading up to the wedding, was always available to answer questions and was a great resource to give her expertise when we were unsure about things. On the day of our wedding, the staff was great - couldn’t have gone more seamlessly! On top of that, the food was INCREDIBLE!!! Our guests raved about the food and we enjoyed it too :)

Lauren Ferianc Sarnese

Medure’s is the exclusive caterer at The Gathering Place at Darlington Lake, and we couldn’t have been happier with their professionalism and services! Samantha, the catering director, was so helpful leading up to the wedding, was always available to answer questions and was a great resource to give her expertise when we were unsure about things. On the day of our wedding, the staff was great - couldn’t have gone more seamlessly! On top of that, the food was INCREDIBLE!!! Our guests raved about the food and we enjoyed it too :)

Tina Renjilian

We had our wedding at Succop Nature Park and Medure’s was our caterer! They were so easy to work and went above and beyond for us. Any questions we had Samantha got back to us right a way. The bartenders, servers and staff were amazing on the day of the wedding and made the day go so smoothly. The food was delicious and our guests were raving about it! We could not be happier with our experience with Medure’s Catering and we highly recommend them!

Sam Orlowski

We used them for our catering for our wedding on July 19, 2025 and it was MARVELOUS! Our guests were coming up to us all night talking about how good the food was!!!

In a world where it costs a first born child to feed people at a wedding for food that usually is very mid, Medure’s catering was a huge steal for us. I was very concerned during our initial search with venues that we were going to have to suffer and pay over $100 per plate for our guests, which to me isn’t worth it, so my fiancé and I were determined to find reasonably priced food that tasted amazing. We lucked out when we found Irons Mill that they partnered with Medure’s and that not only was their food EXCELLENT, but was priced so reasonably, that we took a huge sigh of relief. Their wait staff was kind, helpful, and efficient. Highly recommend the Irons Mill + Medure’s partnership!!

Sydney Taylor

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Medure’s Catering was absolutely perfect for our wedding! From the very beginning, everyone we worked with was incredibly sweet, helpful, and professional. The food was amazing...our guests are still raving about it! Every dish was so flavorful and the servers went above and beyond and it truly elevated the entire experience of our day.

A special thank you to Sam! She is an absolute gem! Her heart is so big, and she goes above and beyond in every way to make sure your day is everything you dreamed of and more. She made us feel so supported throughout the entire planning process, and I am so grateful our paths crossed. If you’re planning a wedding or event, I couldn’t recommend them more!

Claire Grant

Medure’s catered our wedding at the Harper in Meadville, PA and we couldn’t be more happy! Gabbey worked with us for almost a year perfecting our menu and wedding details. The food was delicious!! All our guests gushed to us after about how tasty everything was! We especially loved the Eggplant Rolatinni and Beef Kebabs! Also, Medure’s services throughout the day were greatly appreciated! They brought us the linens and dish ware, set up our cookie table, boxed up leftovers, and kept the party running smoothly. We 100% recommend using Medure’s as your wedding caterer!

Gwyn Wallace

Medure’s catered our wedding on May 31st and we couldn’t be happier with our decision to book with them. We had their food at a wedding we attended, and were very impressed, so when we reached out to them about catering our wedding, we were happy to hear they were available and included so much in their pricing. From providing linens, plate and glassware, to setting up our cookie table- it was so helpful to have them include all this in their rate. They were always upfront with the pricing which can be uncommon in the wedding world.

Gabbey helped us throughout the whole process. She always quickly replied to any emails, and all questions, no matter how frequent or how many. She was wonderful to work with.

Though all of the reasons above are great reasons to book with them for your next event- the main reason is because their food was truly amazing for our event. EVERYTHING was delicious. Multiple people during and weeks after our wedding commented on how delicious the food was. Multiple people said it was the best food they had ever had at a wedding. Many people went back up to the buffet for more food, and there was still some left. Medures was also willing to donate the leftover food as we didn’t have anywhere to put it for the night and knew we wouldn’t be able to eat it all. We really appreciated this instead of it going to waste. They packed two take out boxes for my husband and I so we could eat some later in the night or next day.

I would recommend Medure’s catering for all of your future event.

Hope Kemerer

Medure’s is the exclusive caterer at the White Barn where we recently got married and we got so many compliments on the food! It takes amazing and the staff that assisted were so kind and helpful. Gabbey was my point of contact throughout the planning process and she was so helpful and professional!

john frisco

Kudos to Gabbey and Medure’s catering. We just had a family get together at my house. Everyone raved about the food. My wife and I like especially how Gabbey made it so easy for us. Picked up food, packaged conveniently, clear instructions on how to warm it and then just enjoyed our party. The Eggplant rollatini , Parmesan crusted chicken, were exceptional.

Derek Young

We recently used Medure for our wedding last weekend and we couldn't have been more pleased with the food and overall experience. Samantha was our point of contact and she was very easy to communicate with all of our questions that we had, she was great to work with.

We consistently had guests come up to us either during the night, or the next morning saying how much they enjoyed the food at cocktail hour and dinner. We would recommend them for your next event.

Eric Oberg

Catering service. Wonderful food!

Loading...