Greatest pizza place in New Castle. They're poor man pizza is one of the best in town. There's nothing on this menu that has ever tasted terrible and the service is always been phenomenal The owners are great people and make sure that their values, respect for customers, and an amazing products come out to each person
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Roberta Bertram McGowan
The young man Jude who was my server was awesome. So very polite and attentive to my needs. My steak salad was huge full of fresh lettuce, peppers and tomatos..wish there was a hard boiled egg. The restrooms were immaculate and nicely decorated.
Kelly Millis
Lunch Special Tuesday 8.12.25. Two NY slices and fountain drink ( w/ refills) $6.50.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lona Schuster
Spent 33.00 on pizza tonight worst pizza of my life had no sauce at all and was burnt
C C
My experience has always been great except for yesterday and on the toilet this morning. I came in and picked up some chicken and green sandwiches (one of my favs) Got back to the shop and WOW were they hot!!!! So much red pepper flakes in the greens I was sweating and my nose was running. I’ll definitely be coming back, the food is great. Maybe tone that down a bit. If this would happen again, at least I know to keep a roll of toilet paper in the freezer for the next day.
Ps: yes, I still finished my sandwich 🤣 🥵 😎 Thanks guys you rock!!!
Zack Johnson
I eat here a few times a year. Food is always very good. My favorite is the meatball sandwich.
Bretta Ann
Nice home town type pizza shop.
Adam Shields
Being the pizza was delivered to my house, I can't rank the atmosphere.
Mary Ann
I appreciate Pizza Man, pizza was good. I highly recommend. I had a very bad experience at Johnny Pizza, they took $25,got the order wrong and wouldn't make it right but Pizza Man will always make it right, just read the reviews. Johnny Pizza was the worse and place was filthy. Pizza Man is my Pizza place for pizza. Great business fairness. They know the customer comes first.
Max Milano
Went in hoping they sold t-shirts, which they did not. pizza definitely eased the disappointment:D crust is super good, but on the thin side. Sauce and cheese were en pointe tho, probably second best regular pizza I've ever tried.
The food was delicious, the service top notch and the private meeting room the nicest in New Castle!
This my group's new go-to restaraunt for monthly meetings!
Jill McAlister
Clean and comfy atmosphere. Our server, Joseph, was super friendly and made some great recommendations. The chips, which are made in house, were AMAZING! The soup, sandwiches, wings, and pizza were all really hot, fresh,and delicious. Highly recommend!
Karen Hastings
Best pizza in town! Everything is delicious; never had a bad meal.
Dwayne Quimby
Good pizza once they opened I stopped going to pizza Joe's hands down better pizza for the price
Ronald Memo
Our family had four different soups, all were home made and tasted great. Fried Zucchini also top shelf, sliced thin with a very tasty marinara dipping sauce. For the main event we had New York style cheese and pepperoni. Once again, authentic and great tasting. Try the fried dough as well, it won't disappoint you either.
Greatest pizza place in New Castle. They're poor man pizza is one of the best in town. There's nothing on this menu that has ever tasted terrible and the service is always been phenomenal The owners are great people and make sure that their values, respect for customers, and an amazing products come out to each person
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The young man Jude who was my server was awesome. So very polite and attentive to my needs. My steak salad was huge full of fresh lettuce, peppers and tomatos..wish there was a hard boiled egg. The restrooms were immaculate and nicely decorated.
Lunch Special Tuesday 8.12.25. Two NY slices and fountain drink ( w/ refills) $6.50.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Spent 33.00 on pizza tonight worst pizza of my life had no sauce at all and was burnt
My experience has always been great except for yesterday and on the toilet this morning. I came in and picked up some chicken and green sandwiches (one of my favs)
Got back to the shop and WOW were they hot!!!!
So much red pepper flakes in the greens I was sweating and my nose was running. I’ll definitely be coming back, the food is great. Maybe tone that down a bit. If this would happen again, at least I know to keep a roll of toilet paper in the freezer for the next day.
Ps: yes, I still finished my sandwich 🤣 🥵 😎
Thanks guys you rock!!!
I eat here a few times a year. Food is always very good. My favorite is the meatball sandwich.
Nice home town type pizza shop.
Being the pizza was delivered to my house, I can't rank the atmosphere.
I appreciate Pizza Man, pizza was good. I highly recommend. I had a very bad experience at Johnny Pizza, they took $25,got the order wrong and wouldn't make it right but Pizza Man will always make it right, just read the reviews. Johnny Pizza was the worse and place was filthy. Pizza Man is my Pizza place for pizza. Great business fairness. They know the customer comes first.
Went in hoping they sold t-shirts, which they did not. pizza definitely eased the disappointment:D crust is super good, but on the thin side. Sauce and cheese were en pointe tho, probably second best regular pizza I've ever tried.
Restaurantji Recommends
The food was delicious, the service top notch and the private meeting room the nicest in New Castle!
This my group's new go-to restaraunt for monthly meetings!
Clean and comfy atmosphere. Our server, Joseph, was super friendly and made some great recommendations. The chips, which are made in house, were AMAZING! The soup, sandwiches, wings, and pizza were all really hot, fresh,and delicious. Highly recommend!
Best pizza in town! Everything is delicious; never had a bad meal.
Good pizza once they opened I stopped going to pizza Joe's hands down better pizza for the price
Our family had four different soups, all were home made and tasted great. Fried Zucchini also top shelf, sliced thin with a very tasty marinara dipping sauce. For the main event we had New York style cheese and pepperoni. Once again, authentic and great tasting. Try the fried dough as well, it won't disappoint you either.
Loading...