Pizza Man's Pizza
9 S Jefferson St, New Castle
(724) 658-0333
Customers' Favorites
Philly Steak and Home Made Chips
Square Slice or Specialty Slice
Single Slice Pepperoni Pizza
Strawberry Hot Chicken Wings
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Pepperoni Calzone
Stuffed Shells
Slice of Pizza
Garlic Knots
Cheese Pizza
Menu
Photos
+46 photos
+45 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We've tried everything, and everything is absolutely delicious. So there's that. We usually get takeout when we order from Pizza Man's Pizza. And what's even more important (to me) than the great food is that they actually know HOW to wrap takeout properly. They line everything with paper and then foil to prevent the hot food from melting into the Styrofoam container. (Eating food that melted through Styrofoam is a health hazard.) So A+++ to Pizza Man's...
The only place prepared for the crowd at the fireworks last night.
That will get you in.
The Pizza and the service will get you back!
Their pizza is phenomenal, their wait staff is over the top, real! They were born nice! Happy kind, any one of them helping as they pass you . And your bill is $10, so not like they are buttering you up!
That will get you in.
The Pizza and the service will get you back!
Their pizza is phenomenal, their wait staff is over the top, real! They were born nice! Happy kind, any one of them helping as they pass you . And your bill is $10, so not like they are buttering you up!
Stopped here on a whim during the festival. This place was super busy, however it seemed like they didn't let that slow them down on their service. I was super impressed by how well we were helped, how fast the food came out, and how well everything tasted. I would also like to make a shout out to Amanda who ran in circles making sure everyone was taken care of. She also helped make sure I could eat around my gluten sensitivity
You May Also Like
Neshannock Creek Brewing - 20 S Mercer St
![]()
Brewery, Brewpubs, Cocktail Bar
Le Resto - 14 N Mercer St
![]()
Sushi Bar, Asian Fusion, Seafood
Burger King - 101 W Washington St
![]()
Burgers, Fast Food