Two fat guys is great. Whether it's fresh baked good like pastry or breads or their pizza which is amazing, you can't go wrong
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cake, Pizza
Dwight Heminger
Amazing cookies, bread & pizza. Can't wait to try more items on the menu!
Rochelle Kroesen
Went there for lunch and left with tons of extra goodies. Their cookies and breads are AMAZING!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Janet O.
Excellent baked goods. The cinnamon sticks with maple icing are absolutely our favorite.
Marcie J.
Love this place! They are friendly, and helpful. The food is good. Love everything I have tried. I went in one day on my way home and just wanted a 2 pieces of pizza for lunch. I stood there waiting for help and this lady came in and came right in front of me and took the rest of the pizza. They felt so bad and made me a pizza. Love the meatball sandwich and their bread. If you're ever in New Castle and see Two Fat Guys and an oven stop in, you won't be sorry. Just heads up there a busy place but well worth it!
Shari Zook
Excellent pastries at a fun little bakery with an Italian flair.
Davie S
Nice pastries and breads. Pizza by the slice looks great (haven't had the opportunity to try it yet).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Heather Campoli
Everything I’ve ever had from Two Fat Guys has been delicious. Highly recommend it—friendly service and fantastic bread and desserts.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gina Vernino
Love the Asiago cheese bread! Available on Friday and Sunday. Also have incredible broccoli cheese pastry. Always have to get a container of biscotti while I'm there so I can have it with my coffee. Favorite is cranberry walnut
I’ve never been here before but I’ve been told they have amazing food. So I ordered 3 dozen cupcakes for my daughter’s 1st birthday. EVERYONE there said they were the best cupcakes they’ve ever had! And I agree!! So delicious! My husband, who is not a big sweet person requested them again next week! We will be returning very soon! I don’t submit many reviews but they were sooo good I just had to!
L H
I bought biscotti there and they were stale. I was going to get several dozen for a bridal shower in a few weeks but not going to risk them being stale also. I only wanted a few to try because I have never been to your bakery before. Was told I had to buy them by the dozen. You got $14.84 from me for stale cookies. I sent them a message first before posting in hopes that they would make it right by refunding my money. I got no response from them.
Etta Miller
This was our first visit to the bakery. We had heard a lot of good things about the bakery and they were all true.We bought Asiago bread, giant peanut butter and chocolate cookie, raspberry and white chocolate scone, Sfogliatella and buns.The breads were so soft and tasty.The scones was very soft as well. Not dry at allSfogliatella was so different. I had never had one and I loved it.Great place to shop at. The people there were very friendly and helpful. You can also get breakfast sandwiches there.
Krista Knox
Sourdough bread is not very good. Taste like stale white bread. Disappointed in pastries. Prices have gone up slightly. Peanut butter cookies where delicious.
Two fat guys is great. Whether it's fresh baked good like pastry or breads or their pizza which is amazing, you can't go wrong
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cake, Pizza
Amazing cookies, bread & pizza. Can't wait to try more items on the menu!
Went there for lunch and left with tons of extra goodies. Their cookies and breads are AMAZING!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent baked goods. The cinnamon sticks with maple icing are absolutely our favorite.
Love this place! They are friendly, and helpful. The food is good. Love everything I have tried. I went in one day on my way home and just wanted a 2 pieces of pizza for lunch. I stood there waiting for help and this lady came in and came right in front of me and took the rest of the pizza. They felt so bad and made me a pizza. Love the meatball sandwich and their bread. If you're ever in New Castle and see Two Fat Guys and an oven stop in, you won't be sorry. Just heads up there a busy place but well worth it!
Excellent pastries at a fun little bakery with an Italian flair.
Nice pastries and breads. Pizza by the slice looks great (haven't had the opportunity to try it yet).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everything I’ve ever had from Two Fat Guys has been delicious. Highly recommend it—friendly service and fantastic bread and desserts.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love the Asiago cheese bread! Available on Friday and Sunday. Also have incredible broccoli cheese pastry. Always have to get a container of biscotti while I'm there so I can have it with my coffee. Favorite is cranberry walnut
Love their bakery items!
Restaurantji Recommends
S x m l3²k w is ft 879 by ads ɛ.
I’ve never been here before but I’ve been told they have amazing food. So I ordered 3 dozen cupcakes for my daughter’s 1st birthday. EVERYONE there said they were the best cupcakes they’ve ever had! And I agree!! So delicious! My husband, who is not a big sweet person requested them again next week! We will be returning very soon! I don’t submit many reviews but they were sooo good I just had to!
I bought biscotti there and they were stale. I was going to get several dozen for a bridal shower in a few weeks but not going to risk them being stale also. I only wanted a few to try because I have never been to your bakery before. Was told I had to buy them by the dozen. You got $14.84 from me for stale cookies. I sent them a message first before posting in hopes that they would make it right by refunding my money. I got no response from them.
This was our first visit to the bakery. We had heard a lot of good things about the bakery and they were all true.We bought Asiago bread, giant peanut butter and chocolate cookie, raspberry and white chocolate scone, Sfogliatella and buns.The breads were so soft and tasty.The scones was very soft as well. Not dry at allSfogliatella was so different. I had never had one and I loved it.Great place to shop at. The people there were very friendly and helpful. You can also get breakfast sandwiches there.
Sourdough bread is not very good. Taste like stale white bread. Disappointed in pastries. Prices have gone up slightly. Peanut butter cookies where delicious.