Sir D's Catering
149 Geary Ave, New Cumberland
(717) 441-1494
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
I used Sir D’s to cater my October 5th wedding and I would not recommend them to anyone else.
I signed a contract that said there would be two certified bartenders, which was broken down to an hourly bartender fee for 8 hours x 2 bartenders. There was only one bartender at the wedding so I asked afterwards if I would receive a refund for the second one I paid for. I was told that they covered the bar with other staff members such as an extra bar-back yet there was never anyone else assisting the bartender behind the bar. Plus, these were not certified bartenders. The guests ended up having to wait longer and were unable to get drinks when the bartender left the bar. When I asked again for a refund because of this, my email was never answered.
The caterers were late on wedding day and had to be called by the venue staff to see where they were.
I am one of the four vegetarians that were at the wedding. I told Brittney, our coordinator at Sir D’s, a month before the wedding that I did not like mushrooms and I was looking for a meal that did not contain mushrooms. I asked a couple times over the month leading up to the wedding what the vegetarian dish would be and Brittney kept telling me she would let me know. The day before the wedding I texted her to ask what it would be and she told me that she did not like the answer she just got from the chef and she would get back to me. She got back to me a little while later and told me that the meal would be a meatless chicken. When I received my meal on my wedding day it was littered with pieces of mushrooms. I was very disappointed that the only item I said I did not want was a large part of the main dish.
I was also told by guests that the food was cold and running empty for the last few tables. Brittney had promised me they would not run out of food as it would make them look bad yet I was told that this did in fact happen.
The lack of transparency and communication made me very uncomfortable in addition to not receiving the services I paid for. I wish I had chosen a different caterer for our wedding.
We love working with Sir D’s Catering! They are punctual, friendly, professional, affordable, cleanly, and make delicious food! Brittney & Scott are simply the best!
Sir D's catered my daughter's bridal shower. Communication with Britany was great and she was able to take my ideas an turn them into a fabulous brunch for 30 people. Guest raved not only about the food, but also about the servers and the set up team. We will certainly use them again for our future catering needs.
Sir D's has catered many events at the Carlisle Ribbon Mill. They are always on time, always make a beautiful display of the food tables and serve excellent food. Brittany & her husband are amazing. We are always happy to hear that one of our clients has booked with them!
We used Sir D's to provide breakfast and lunch for a two-day event in Harrisburg and had a fabulous experience. They were on time, communicative, and efficient. The food was REALLY good and we got lots of positive feedback from attendees about the quality. We would use them again in a heartbeat for any event in Harrisburg!
We are so thankful to Sir D’s for catering our wedding. Their entire team especially Kaitlyn our manager, did a spectacular job. And the food would absolutely delicious. Our guests are still commenting how good it was. We highly recommend them!
We had an amazing experience with Sir D’s! They went above and beyond with service, including bailing me out for not renting enough colored linens from another vendor. The food and service was incredible and so easy to work with! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!!! Five stars!!!
We had an amazing experience with Sir D’s! They went above and beyond with service, including bailing me out for not renting enough colored linens from another vendor. The food and service was incredible and so easy to work with! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!!! Five stars!!!
Amazing food, great prices, and stellar service. Cannot ask for a better caterer!
Alexia was organized and helpful in our initial meeting and communication regarding a proposal. Calla was very friendly and moved the planning process along nicely. The food tasted good and presented well at the wedding.Unfortunately, several major disappointments left a bad taste in our mouths and we regret having them cater our wedding.Calla disappeared two days before our wedding and we were surprised with Brittney on the day of the wedding without any communication from Sir D's. Hors d'oeuvres were served to us one time without our full selection present while we were taking photographs during cocktail hour. Our dinners were not packed up as leftovers for our pleasure as agreed upon.Worst of all, was the final invoice disagreement following the wedding. We were charged our initial quoted price and not the amended proposal price. We were charged for 6 vendor meals instead of 4. We were charged for an additional hour of time which was not agreed upon. We were charged for centerpiece and cake/cupcake setup, which was painstakingly done by family and relatives, not the caterer. I respectfully pointed out the discrepancies line by line in an e-mail. The e-mail was acknowledged, and a check was sent to us.The total difference in amount paid and corrected final invoice was over $1,000. The check we received was for just over $500. I e-mailed. I called. Eventually, I received my only response from the owner, Don Noss, that he personally reviewed the necessary information and could explain the additional charges at my convenience. I called the number provided and left multiple voicemails. We followed up with an out-of-the-way in-person visit only to be refused any time to discuss the disputed amounts. Our only remedy that remained was civil court... which we declined to pursue and incurred the loss of over $500.Save yourself the hassle and find another caterer.
Restaurantji Recommends
Our wedding was on 9/17/21 and...All I've heard since our wedding was how great the food was! They did a beautiful job setting up. The servers were great, the bar tender was fun, and Katelyn and Brittany were great to work with. I'll recommend them to anyone.
Sir D's catered for my companies mid- year picnic and they were fantastic. Kaitlyn, the employee (doing the catering all by herself), went above and beyond to make sure our employees were taken care of. Kaitlin was timely, attentive and made the set up look fun yet professional. The food was fresh, came out warm and tasted great. Many of our employees came up to us after saying how much they enjoyed it. Would recommend Sir D's to anyone for the future!
Talk about fantastic food, awesome servers, and two wonderful bartenders! Sir D's was wonderful and we appreciated all that they did for us for our wedding! Between having wonderful ideas when it came to table set-ups and table serving, to having all our guests raving about how delicious the food was (even the picky eaters), to having bartenders who remembered everyone's orders, we can't speak highly enough about Sir D's. If you are looking for top-notch service, Katelyn and Brittney are the best!
Sir D's Catering was absolutely AMAZING. My (now) husband and I are very picky when it comes to food. We had our wedding with a served dinner style and when I say it couldn't have gone better, I LITERALLY mean it COULD NOT HAVE GONE BETTER. Sir D's did such an amazing job. They checked every box. The food was served hot (super tasty), fast and the presentation was great. I am so happy with their service. Super friendly, wonderful food and great staff. Again, thank you!
They were supposed to cater my best friends wedding later in this month and Brittany decided she just would stop communicating with them. No reason, the bride, groom and myself all called NUMEROUS times with no answer. The last communication was them changing an item on the hors d'oeuvres, and that was it....nothing since. How can you just stop community with a bride and groom 4-5 weeks before the wedding?! I would NEVER recommend their services. Terrible business practice. And BTW....since there was no notice that they couldn't or wouldn't cater the event, it has caused UNDO stress on a bride who already has enough to deal with by planning a wedding to now have no one catering the reception. Absolutely awful!!! Brittany, whoever you are...you're the worst. I hope karma comes back to you tenfold.
Loading...