Uncle Charlie's Bella Pizza

914 Main St, New Milford
(570) 465-2660

Recent Reviews

Ben Koch

Great food, great prices, great service, great people!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Robert Dos Santos

Stop getting your pizza any where else .All other places are a step down...

Autumn Brown

Amazing

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza, Wings, White Pizza

Michael Frost

Great pizza! Best around! Also one of the most affordable pizza places in the area! Staff is always very friendly!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

john kaminsky

Pizza was bland very little sauce on it. Pizza at pump pantry is

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

carol h

One pizza was great, white pizza was burnt

Anthony Feliciano

Prices couldn't be any better and the food is phenomenal extra for you to go but it's worth it

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Diane Manley

No in-store service. Staff will come out and take your order, and bring it out when done. As usual the pizza was great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Eva Juarez

Prices are great even in this economy !The chicken bacon salad is my favorite

Sam the Finishing Man

Had their gluten free pizza and it was great! Thanks for having it available, couldn't find one anywhere else.

Juan Miguez

A gem was found during our travel and it is Uncle Charlie's Bella Pizza! A family business oriented to make fresh, delicious food. Our experience entails as follows: called ahead of time and ordered four sandwiches. The phone attendant was courteous, patient, honest, and told us the time and cost of the food, very pleasant to talk. The place was easy to find without major directions. Upon arrival, the attention was superb and came out to greet us. We certainly didn't know this was a pickup only place. Got the food right away, paid a very fair price for the 4 twelve inch sandwiches ($37). Everything went very smooth and great. We picked 4 different sandwiches and every single one of us rated it a 5 star ⭐ for food, courtesy, pricing, and service. I had a delicious eggplant parmigiana, others had awesome cheese steak, special cheese steak, and Italian.The back draw: place is small and obviously cannot handle more so it will be like this for a while;however for improvement a couple of chairs and a table outside will make it a better appealing.

michael musso

Ate wings n pizza in many places for many years n this place is one of my favorites when I’m up in that area I make it a point to order out from there believe me u r never disappointed

J P.

The food is great!!! however they have the wrong hours in their site!! Not 11-8.. but 3-8!!! It takes us 1/2 hr to get there.. so a couple of wasted trips!! Just a heads up !

Bear Guy

Best quality and taste compared to any other pizza restaurants in the entire area! And believe me, I have tried all of the other pizzas and subs from all of the area restaurants and this is hands down THE best freshly made pizzas and subs! I've tried the rest and will ONLY order from Uncle Charlie's from now on. Don't regret the lack of quality and taste or waste your time or money using any other restaurants. All you have to do is just go to Uncle Charley's and enjoy a true New York City style and tasting, to the amazing thick crust Sicilian style pizzas and the large selection of both hot and cold subs!

emilia birtch

Great pizza! Reminds me of New Jersey pizza Ny style! Everything on the menu is very tasty! But their pizza is superb!?

Load More