Restaurants near New Milford

“Great food! Best pizza around! Fair prices!”

“Really good food! Priced affordability! fast friendly service!”

“Absolutely amazing owners always have a great time when I go there the wings are so amazing if I can give them 20+stars I would !!!!!”

“Was visiting a friend and they recommended this place. Had an amazing chocolate/vanilla swirl with sprinkles. Ice cream was great after a hot summers day by the water! Thank you kindly for the great service and greater ice cream! :)”

“We stopped by Hot Pies during a road trip through PA. I can’t emphasize enough how great this place was! Local pizzeria with fantastic pricing, and the foods to die for. I ordered a cheesesteak with mushrooms and onions, and no exaggeration it was one of the best cheesesteaks I’ve ever eaten in my life, and I eat a lot of cheesesteaks. My girlfriend got two slices of pizza (Sausage & Pepperoni) & the employee ensured to ask if she wanted a middle or corner slice - the slices were great too.

Food is 10/10, people are friendly and it’s clear the community loves this local spot. If you’re coming through the area I’d highly recommend stopping.”

“I can honestly say, I don’t think I’ve ever had a better fried haddock sandwich, a better drink, or better service than today. The food was amazing (this sandwich was massive! It filled both Adam and I!), and the bartender (Jared) was not only super friendly and social, but he also gave amazing recommendations on drinks, and was super attentive and overall one of the best bartenders I’ve ever been around! I will definitely be returning to Green Gables again.”

“Amazing breakfasts. Omelets are great, I usually get, I think it's called a breakfast bowl. Home fries, eggs, sausage and cheese all cooked together. Speaking of home fries, these are the best around and second place isn't even close. Slow cooked on the griddle I could make a meal out of them alone.
As far as there being no wifi, there is very good cellular service there. Use your phone as a Hotspot, it's 2026 man! Sounds like somebody just wanted Starbucks and wanted to trash the small town feel.”

“Recently moved up here from philadelphia. The land of Fantastic Pizza. But I have to say that I ordered a pizza from here last week and it was one of the best pizzas I'd ever had. So thrilled to have such a great pizza place 5 minutes down the road. Well done.”

“Love the service I come her often the Staff is quick and efficient”

“Went in on a Saturday morning. Was greeted and sat as soon as I walked thru the entryway. Was a little busy, but my my drink order was taken right away and brought back. My food was served hot fresh and quickly. Even tho the waitress was the only one there and was busy, she was still able to check on me and make sure I had my coffee refilled and asked if I wanted or needed anything else. Felt very welcomed! Would definitely go back! Thank you!”

“Food and drinks are mediocre at best but that’s not unusual for Dunkin. But the workers are the reason this place is a success. Specifically Krystal, Sabrina, Jamie and Chelsea”

“We stop for a quick lunch and bio break. One of the kiosks was out of order so there was a long line waiting for the kiosk. I tried ordering from my phone but I couldn’t authorize my credit card. The kiosks opened up and I placed our orders and grabbed a table near the back. We waited about 10 minutes and our food was brought out. I was happy the apple pie is back to the original crispy shell. The others has Chicken McNuggets, fries, bacon quarter pounder, chocolate milk shake, and frozen raspberry drink. The place was relatively clean. Some people were trading happy meal toys with each other. They had the bts and fifa toys. This location is convenient to get to from I-81.”

“Best donut I’ve ever had!”

“Great bar b q and beers. Best beef brisket ever!!”

“feels very welcoming. very friendly and helpful staff. plus delicious ice cream 🍦 😋”

“Went in for breakfast today with my partner. It was small, cute and definitely a small town vibe. Food took extra time but it was well worth the wait and the staff was so kind. We didn’t mind the wait at all. We actually didn’t even notice because we were enjoying our time out. Thanks for the great meal!”

“Soups are amazing, great coffee, delicious sandwiches. Great people!”

“cute little place to eat. The waitress is wonderfully nice and very attentive. they also gave my wife a flower on mother's day. I would definitely recommend.”

“Best ice cream and service around! Will accommodate any request big or small!”

“Food is phenomenal. Real home cooking, best pancakes on the planet, and the half rack of ribs is a must when they have them on special. Attentive and friendly staff.”

“I ordered online from them couple of times already. And it is so so good! I’m Russian but the rest of my family is American. And everyone loves pelmeni and vareniki. They are the closest I’ve ever had to what my grandmother used to make when I was little. And shipping is very fast and convenient. Once ups didn’t deliver at the right day and the next day I’ve got the box everything was thawed and had to throw it all away. I emailed the store and they ship me the same order the same day for free!
Amazing quality, organic and great customer service!”

“Place is exactly what you want when getting fast, reasonably priced, good food. We order frequently and they've never let us down.

Parking: Next to a bank, gas station and grocery store, plenty of parking.”

“THIS place was the best food I have eaten out in a very long time. Almost 4 hours later and my mouth still is salivating over the roast beef and mash potatoes and gravy and the price was cheaper then McDonald's. $30 bucks for 2 excellent meals. Perfect portions with no left overs. My friend has the Salisbury steak and it looked amazing and she said it was incredible. Thank you to our excellent waitress as well. So friendly and attentive. We may stop back in for breakfast on the way home. A must stop at for a bite.”

“I brought a group of 20 cyclists here yesterday after doing the D&H Trail. Everyone was happy with the food and service. It was an integral part of the whole D&H Trail experience.”

“My husband and I had lunch there on March 19. The food was fantastic. I had a Ceaser salad with chicken that was HUGE. Real grilled chicken, fresh romaine, lots of shredded parm on top and a small loaf of fresh warm bread that was included. Absolutely delicious. Enough for two meals. Hubby got wings that were jumbo and actually got 12 and not 10 like some other places. Crispy and not too hot. We got a pizza to go and that was great as well. Highly recommend.”

“Has great chicken & biscuits on 1sy Thursday of the month...it's served home-style and all you can eay for $8.50...not a trendy plsce...just good home cooking!!!”

“An unexpected hidden treat this place was. We got lucky when the place we had planned to go to was closed. After a quick Google search, we found Hilltop and was very pleased with the food and service. The long drive there was worth it.

The prices beat any fast food joint, even with all the add-ons to this giant burger. My husband ordered a cheese steak and couldn't stop raving about it. The only thing I regret is not taking pictures of this huge burger which I was not able to finish, but happy that I got to enjoy the rest the next day.

I'm happy to have supported this local business.”

“I am beyond impressed with how amazing this place is. From the service to the food, this place has changed in the best way possible! Kelsey was the best waitress!”

“This place is in an awesome area. It mostly sells beer, ice, etc.

Say Hello to George, he has been here almost 50yrs. He knows the area and the history.

This is a vanishing part of the greatness of America.”