Bourbon Mill

4797 York Rd, New Oxford
(717) 624-8987

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Paulette Berube

Great bands, good food, great, caring servers.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jeff Tate

Stopped in for lunch today and we were able to sit outside. It's a really nice spot. We missed seeing the live music that will be later in the evening.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Michael Saunders

Was there to hear a live band. Food and service were great.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Derick Rudolph

Bad service, waited for 2 to 3 minutes before someone came to seat us plenty of tables not that busy. Has to teAck down the waitress. The wings were good but the pit beef was basically steamed that was burnt smothered in some sauce serve with a bag of chips. It is obvious no training or systems in place for the wait staff to be successful and understand customer service 101. Good luck for you try the food but if going to drink should be no pry.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jill Walker

Worst experience I’ve had in a long time. Ranks with about the worst service ever honestly. Wings are decent, gyro meh. Terrible so-called bbq. Stay away unless you want a beer and wings. Waitstaff, rude and acted like they didn’t know what they’re doing, very slow.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 1

Thomas Bowers

The kitchen is absolutely not cut out for the events they host. Twice I've been there and they have a very limited menu, and the food took almost 2 hours

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Linda England

Hubby and I stopped by on a whim for a little date night. It happened to be KARAOKE NIGHT!! We had so much fun! The indoor staff was great, and the regulars were super nice! We will be back!

Lisa Carbaugh Kauffman

Waited 45 minutes for food. Ordered the salad with shrimp chicken and steak. Expected a nice salad for $18. Came out on a super small plastic bowl. Half the lettuce was brown. My husband got a quesadilla that was half empty, no salsa no sour cream. We like the deck, but the food has always been lacking. Not planning on coming back.

Amanda Dutton

We camp a lot in Gettysburg and this is always one of our stops before heading into town. Inside is nicely updated and the outdoor area provides ample amount of space for eating, drinking and activities. Highly recommend this place. Side note, our truck broke down hauling our camper this past weekend, luckily if shut off while coming up to the bourbon mill, we had to leave the camper in their parking lot while our truck got towed. The owner was super nice and understanding. We appreciate you and will continue to always stop in on our travels to Gettysburg .

Kristie Butler

We had awesome food and the best old fashion from the bartender Jen. Highly recommend this place !!! We will be back !!!

Kathy Hoff Naylor

Placed order online and when we went to pickup it was closed due to liquor violation. Never got our wings and know having to work with credit card company to get money back.

Emily Ann

How often is there line dancing?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michael K

Food was real good. Service was bad due to short staffing. Shouldn't take 20+ minutes for drink refills. Only 1 waitress and 1 bartender. Would have been higher review, better staffed=better service= more customers

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 2

Diane Moats

I absolutely loved this place! They have live bands here in the evenings and the music is great. The service is friendly, and you are served quickly. What I liked the most was that your food was served piping hot! Most restaurants will give you luke- warm food and it's cold by the time you try to finish it. I usually take home half of my food and heat it up to finish eating it. But not this place! It was piping hot when the server brought it out and it was still hot when I finished it. That's a big PLUS in my book! I definitely will go back there and I'd recommend this place for the excellent food and relaxing atmosphere! The prices are great too for the amount you get!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Steven Fox

Great place for dinner and live bands

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...