We were dazzled and impressed with TWO custom cakes by this amazing bakery. They were done for my husband’s retirement event celebrating his long medical-related career. It featured iconic items all edible showcasing his innovations and more. A computer with code on the screen, slide of embryonic heart devpt, bottle of Scotch…lol, textbooks, tech innovations, palm trees, beach….complete with coconuts and more! See photos. Truly incredible! And, of course, the cake itself was sooooo delicious, moist chocolate with ganache in between the layers. Still enjoying it and sharing with friends. Bakery offers many flavors. Perfect place to order an amazing cake or cupcakes for people you love and want to impress. Thank you sooooo much Cakeateria!
Jase Gillespie
I am amazed with how short of notice this bakery was able to whip up a cake for my son’s birthday! Awesome Fortnite cake!
Jessica Phillips
Beth and the Caketeria created the most perfect wedding cake for us! She was so sweet and patient during our tasting, answering any questions and letting us take our time. We ended up picking the vanilla cake with a layer of cannoli filling and a layer of chocolate ganache! Our guests said it was the best wedding cake they ever had. Beth also followed my inspiration picture and made my dream wedding cake come to life! I am so excited to use the Caketeria for future cakes.
Lynne Moser
this is my new go-to when it comes to decorative cakes. Beth and her staff are communicative, helpful, and uber talented. Ordered a sprinkle covered piñata cake for my son's 12th birthday celebration and he said it was his favorite ever. Will return for Our next September birthday boy. Thank you!
Christine Foy
Sweet envirploment inside but limited parking. Staff was helpful & friendly...
Lin Sims
I ordered a specialty cake from Caketeria for my daughter's birthday and the cake turned out beautiful and more importantly delicious. Thank you to Sara for helping me with the order. With so many choices of cakes, topping and fillings it was hard to choose. I highly recommend this bakery in Newtown.
Simona Averbukh
I used the caketeria for my daughter’s birthday party and the cake was delicious and beautiful! The cake pops and cupcakes were also designed to match the butterfly / roses theme. The staff is very kind, understanding and created my vision perfectly and there details on the cake is beautiful. The cupcakes had raspberry preserves inside too which was a great additional touch. Lilya and her team of bakers did everything professionally, tasteful and made the process smooth. I would highly recommend them for any event.
Rachana Awatramani
I ordered a cake for my daughter’s birthday, and I’m so glad I chose this place! The lady was incredibly helpful and gave me some wonderful suggestions that really made a difference. The cake not only looked beautiful but also tasted amazing moist, flavorful, and a big hit with everyone at the party. Highly recommend!
tommyandgingerr
Very beautiful professional service and most importantly the most delicious birthday cake me and my party has ever had… AAA ++++ Would definitely recommend … cupcakes were even better
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vanessa Baird
I ordered a birthday cake for my son’s first birthday. The taste was delicious and everyone who called or emailed me with answers to my questions were truly helpful! I will definitely be back. Thank you!
Amazing bakery! They made a cake for my daughter’s second birthday and it was gorgeous AND delicious. We got so many compliments! Will definitely use this bakery again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cupcakes
K J
Seriously such a kind and sociable owner/person working behind the counter! Cupcakes were also delicious, we tried the peanut butter cup cupcake and the biscoff cupcake, will definitely come back to try more
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcakes
Stefanie Paige
Beth and Sara were awesome to work with for my sister’s baby shower cake. I sent my inspo pics and they were quick to respond. The cake came out better than I could have asked for. Great cake and great service.
Food: 5
Nicholas Matt
Beth is a great baker. She is super nice and always makes delicious confections for our family gatherings.
I have given this place a chance too many times. My husband went in for a birthday cake and was told the pound cake was the most moist. Not the case. The cake was stale, tasteless and dry. It had strawberry filling that tasted like cheap strawberry jam. When I cut the cake it literally fell apart, it was a mess. The icing was the worst buttercream I ever tasted. Was thick and greasy with little taste. Gave this place enough chances. They are lucky they are the only bakery in town or they wouldn’t be in business! Super disappointed!
We were dazzled and impressed with TWO custom cakes by this amazing bakery. They were done for my husband’s retirement event celebrating his long medical-related career. It featured iconic items all edible showcasing his innovations and more. A computer with code on the screen, slide of embryonic heart devpt, bottle of Scotch…lol, textbooks, tech innovations, palm trees, beach….complete with coconuts and more! See photos. Truly incredible! And, of course, the cake itself was sooooo delicious, moist chocolate with ganache in between the layers. Still enjoying it and sharing with friends. Bakery offers many flavors. Perfect place to order an amazing cake or cupcakes for people you love and want to impress. Thank you sooooo much Cakeateria!
I am amazed with how short of notice this bakery was able to whip up a cake for my son’s birthday! Awesome Fortnite cake!
Beth and the Caketeria created the most perfect wedding cake for us! She was so sweet and patient during our tasting, answering any questions and letting us take our time. We ended up picking the vanilla cake with a layer of cannoli filling and a layer of chocolate ganache! Our guests said it was the best wedding cake they ever had. Beth also followed my inspiration picture and made my dream wedding cake come to life! I am so excited to use the Caketeria for future cakes.
this is my new go-to when it comes to decorative cakes. Beth and her staff are communicative, helpful, and uber talented. Ordered a sprinkle covered piñata cake for my son's 12th birthday celebration and he said it was his favorite ever. Will return for Our next September birthday boy. Thank you!
Sweet envirploment inside but limited parking. Staff was helpful & friendly...
I ordered a specialty cake from Caketeria for my daughter's birthday and the cake turned out beautiful and more importantly delicious. Thank you to Sara for helping me with the order. With so many choices of cakes, topping and fillings it was hard to choose. I highly recommend this bakery in Newtown.
I used the caketeria for my daughter’s birthday party and the cake was delicious and beautiful! The cake pops and cupcakes were also designed to match the butterfly / roses theme. The staff is very kind, understanding and created my vision perfectly and there details on the cake is beautiful. The cupcakes had raspberry preserves inside too which was a great additional touch. Lilya and her team of bakers did everything professionally, tasteful and made the process smooth. I would highly recommend them for any event.
I ordered a cake for my daughter’s birthday, and I’m so glad I chose this place! The lady was incredibly helpful and gave me some wonderful suggestions that really made a difference. The cake not only looked beautiful but also tasted amazing moist, flavorful, and a big hit with everyone at the party. Highly recommend!
Very beautiful professional service and most importantly the most delicious birthday cake me and my party has ever had… AAA ++++ Would definitely recommend … cupcakes were even better
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered a birthday cake for my son’s first birthday. The taste was delicious and everyone who called or emailed me with answers to my questions were truly helpful! I will definitely be back. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Amazing bakery! They made a cake for my daughter’s second birthday and it was gorgeous AND delicious. We got so many compliments! Will definitely use this bakery again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cupcakes
Seriously such a kind and sociable owner/person working behind the counter! Cupcakes were also delicious, we tried the peanut butter cup cupcake and the biscoff cupcake, will definitely come back to try more
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcakes
Beth and Sara were awesome to work with for my sister’s baby shower cake. I sent my inspo pics and they were quick to respond. The cake came out better than I could have asked for. Great cake and great service.
Food: 5
Beth is a great baker. She is super nice and always makes delicious confections for our family gatherings.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Birthday Cake, Cupcakes
I have given this place a chance too many times. My husband went in for a birthday cake and was told the pound cake was the most moist. Not the case. The cake was stale, tasteless and dry. It had strawberry filling that tasted like cheap strawberry jam. When I cut the cake it literally fell apart, it was a mess. The icing was the worst buttercream I ever tasted. Was thick and greasy with little taste. Gave this place enough chances. They are lucky they are the only bakery in town or they wouldn’t be in business! Super disappointed!
Food: 1
Loading...