Mary Lou’s Pizza

209 Dunn Ave, Old Forge
(570) 562-2700

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Breadsticks and Marinara
Old Forge Pizza
Potato Gnocchi
Special Pizza
Sausage Rings
Spinach Pizza
White Pizza
Red Pizza

Menu

Pizza
Red Cheese Pizza
Classic old forge-style pizza with homemade sauce and our secret blend of cheeses.
Fresh Tomato Pizza
Freshly sliced tomatoes marinated in garlic, olive oil, and basil topped with our secret house blend of cheeses and pecorino Romano cheese.
Hot Pizza
Red pizza prepared with extra onion, crushed red pepper, black pepper, a drizzle of olive oil, and anchovies.
Veggie Pizza
Red pizza topped with our seasoned broccoli and spinach, fried mushrooms, and peppers.
Shrimp and Peppers Pizza
Red pizza topped with shrimp and hot or sweet peppers.
Meatball Pizza
Red pizza topped with our homemade meatballs.

Round Pizza
Red Cheese Pizza
Spinach Pizza

Double Crust Pizza
Double Crust White Pizza
A double crust tray of pizza stuffed with our secret house blend of cheeses topped with salt, pepper, rosemary, and sliced onions.
Double Crust Spinach Pizza
A double crust tray of pizza stuffed with seasoned spinach topped with our secret house blend of cheeses, pecorino Romano cheese, salt, and pepper.
Double Crust Broccoli Pizza
A double crust tray of pizza stuffed with seasoned broccoli topped with our secret house blend of cheeses, pecorino Romano cheese, salt, and pepper.

Appetizers
Breadsticks with Marinara
Freshly made breadsticks seasoned with pecorino Romano cheese, oregano, and garlic. Served with a side of our robust marinara sauce.
Sausage Rings
Murray's hot Italian sausage and pecorino Romano cheese rolled in our fresh dough and topped with our secret house blend of cheeses.

Stromboli
Stromboli
Filled with ham, salami, capicola, sweet pepper, pepper Jack cheese, and our secret house blend of cheese. Served with a side of marinara sauce.

Pasta
Pasta with Marinara Sauce
The sauce simmered with onions and garlic.
Potato Gnocchi Pasta
Manicotti Pasta
Pasta with Regular Sauce
The sauce simmered with pork and sausage then strained.
Meat Ravioli Pasta
Cheese Ravioli Pasta
Ricotta Gnocchi Pasta
Pasta with Meatballs

Photos

Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+43 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+42 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

Really good pizza! The place has a nice atmosphere and it’s cool that the kitchen is open so you can actually see the chefs baking the pizzas. My daughter is super picky and usually scrapes the cheese and sauce off at other places, but she actually loved this one. The crust was soft, buttery, and still had a crisp bite. We’ll definitely be coming back.
September 2025
We had a wonderful time dining at Mary Lou's tonight! The staff was so welcoming, kind, and pleasant! The restaurant is so clean and decorated so beautifully! I love the string lights! The pizza was the best! We ordered white pizza with spinach and garlic, and it was phenomenal! Best white pizza I've ever had! We will definitely be back!
August 2025
First time trying Old Forge pizza and Mary Lou's did not disappoint. The sausage rings were a standout, like savory meaty donuts. We also loved the white stuffed pizza with rosemary and onions. Some of the best dough I’ve ever had.
June 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Augustine's Club 17 - 518 N Main St
Italian, Pizza, Caterers, American, Vegan
Dunkin' - 103 N Main St
Coffee Shops, Donuts, Coffee & Tea, Coffee
Lucca Restaurant - 802 S Main St
Italian, Vegetarian

Mary Lou’s Pizza

209 Dunn Ave, Old Forge, PA 18518
(570) 562-2700