Best bakery in Fayette County in my opinion. Fantastic product line. I keep going back and back and back and back! Keep up the great work that you do so well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Phelony James
Everything here is always fresh and yummy! You can tell these nice folks love what they do 💖💖💖
Melissa Ciotti
Katie’s Cookie Jar is our #1 go to place for cookies and cakes! Her cakes are AMAZING! They are fresh and taste delicious! Katie is a true artist when it comes to designs on her cookies, cakes and cupcakes! Every time I get an order I am in awe of how attention to detail the designs are. I highly recommend Katie’s Cookie Jar. The staff is very friendly, Katie responds very fast to messages and items are reasonably priced. Thankfully to have a bakery like this in our community.
Bree Ritz
I’ve ordered multiple times from Katie’s Cookie Jar. It always tastes so good. It looks beautiful every single time. Very reasonable. Definitely recommend.
Megan Johnson
Ordered Paw Patrol cookies and they were absolutely perfect. My 4 year old was in awe. Not only did they look cute, they were delicious. My new go to for sweet custom treats.
Michele Cramer
Their brownies were fresh and the sugar cookies were warm go here workers were easy to deal with and super nice
Kid-friendliness: They have cute sugar cookie designs for children
Wheelchair accessibility: It is for everyone even weelchairers
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Birthday Cake, Custom Sugar Cookies
Margo Rita
All I can say is everything is delicious and fresh.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kaitlin Smith
I will NEVER go anywhere else for cookies!!! She brings your ideas to life and does even better than the inspo pics❤️❤️
Keith Frankenfield
Great service and the best cookies and doughnuts around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tracy Rudzinski
I drove an hour away just for the amazing sugar cookies made here! Beautiful desserts, but the best part is the TASTE. Affordable, adorable desserts. Don't miss out on the sugar cookies!!!
Wheelchair accessibility: No stairs- seems to me to be wheelchair accessible.
Katie’s Cookie Jar did an amazing job on the cookies for my son’s 1st birthday! Not only were they decorated beautifully, they tasted fantastic!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cookies
Jessica Campbell
Absolutely delicious!! Sugar cookies for my baby shower were delicious and looked adorable! Can’t wait for an excuse to order more :)
Dewane Shultz
She did an amazing job on the cookies we ordered for a baby shower. They went above and beyond, also made the whole thing super simple. We got so many compliments on how beautiful and tasty they were.
Caraline Reinecker
My favorite bakery!! Katie is so sweet along with her family. Her cakes are amazing and you can tell she put a lot of love into them!
Kara Nahar
We have used Katie’s Cookie Jar for many of our events and I wouldn’t want anyone else to make our cakes, they make a the whole event! ❤️
Best bakery in Fayette County in my opinion. Fantastic product line. I keep going back and back and back and back! Keep up the great work that you do so well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everything here is always fresh and yummy! You can tell these nice folks love what they do 💖💖💖
Katie’s Cookie Jar is our #1 go to place for cookies and cakes! Her cakes are AMAZING! They are fresh and taste delicious! Katie is a true artist when it comes to designs on her cookies, cakes and cupcakes! Every time I get an order I am in awe of how attention to detail the designs are. I highly recommend Katie’s Cookie Jar. The staff is very friendly, Katie responds very fast to messages and items are reasonably priced. Thankfully to have a bakery like this in our community.
I’ve ordered multiple times from Katie’s Cookie Jar. It always tastes so good. It looks beautiful every single time. Very reasonable. Definitely recommend.
Ordered Paw Patrol cookies and they were absolutely perfect. My 4 year old was in awe. Not only did they look cute, they were delicious. My new go to for sweet custom treats.
Their brownies were fresh and the sugar cookies were warm go here workers were easy to deal with and super nice
Kid-friendliness: They have cute sugar cookie designs for children
Wheelchair accessibility: It is for everyone even weelchairers
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Birthday Cake, Custom Sugar Cookies
All I can say is everything is delicious and fresh.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I will NEVER go anywhere else for cookies!!! She brings your ideas to life and does even better than the inspo pics❤️❤️
Great service and the best cookies and doughnuts around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I drove an hour away just for the amazing sugar cookies made here! Beautiful desserts, but the best part is the TASTE. Affordable, adorable desserts. Don't miss out on the sugar cookies!!!
Wheelchair accessibility: No stairs- seems to me to be wheelchair accessible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cookies
Restaurantji Recommends
Katie’s Cookie Jar did an amazing job on the cookies for my son’s 1st birthday! Not only were they decorated beautifully, they tasted fantastic!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cookies
Absolutely delicious!! Sugar cookies for my baby shower were delicious and looked adorable! Can’t wait for an excuse to order more :)
She did an amazing job on the cookies we ordered for a baby shower. They went above and beyond, also made the whole thing super simple. We got so many compliments on how beautiful and tasty they were.
My favorite bakery!! Katie is so sweet along with her family. Her cakes are amazing and you can tell she put a lot of love into them!
We have used Katie’s Cookie Jar for many of our events and I wouldn’t want anyone else to make our cakes, they make a the whole event! ❤️
Loading...