This eatery is a PRIME example of how a restaurant can serve the community & brighten the area up both literally & metaphorically speaking! The food was exceptional & fairly priced! I came in later in the evening & one can see how the staff hustles around to keep the place clean!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
D
As the other guy mentioned, the people running this place are helpless. Such an awful customer service experience, they take forever because they are lazy and don't do anything. Oh Brother Pizza is newish and FANTASTIC, get pizza there, run by experts.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Lena L Fowler
Always great food and I'm remember by name and order!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
JPtravel us
Great pizza ???
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Neil P McGuinness
This is a good pizza place. The staff was very friendly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Hailey McGhee
I had never tried this place before but I saw it on doordash and decided I’d give it a try, it was ordered around a half hour before they close and let me just say this food is AMAZING! Would definitely recommend and it was so fresh and hot!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball Parmigiana Sandwich
Josh L.
There is an advertised special, two slices of any pie and a drink for $10. The only thing special about it is nothing. That seems like a regular price for this pizza. Everything about it is best defined as, nothing special. The specialty pie was pretty good, almost four stars, but the vegetable slice right next to BBQ Chicken, and there was spillover that spoiled it. I can't fathom who thought that was a good idea. The restaurant is not overall well kept, but you won't starve is my best summary. Apparently, you shouldn't confuse this is Old City Pizza as there is some drama surrounding it.
Christine W
Old city Pizza is a great place. It is warm, cozy, and homey inside. The owners are very sincere and sweet and greeted me when I walked in. I got a Philly cheesesteak and the service was very quick. The cheesesteak was 10 out of 10 will definitely go back :)
Zach Moon
No idea what that dork who left the 1 star review is talking about. I walked in not too long before their closing time, ordered 2 slices and a drink and was given a 3rd slice for free as well (girl working the register said it was buy 2 get 1 free which she didn’t have to since I only ordered 2 anyways). It was solid albeit pretty standard football style pizza. Good taste, good crisp. 10$ for 3 slices and a drink doesn’t happen at most places these days.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Jed Krivisky
STOP! If I can save one person from wasting their time and money on this place, it will be enough. Run by idiots and plenty of better pizza options less than a block away.I called them looking to place an order and they specifically recommended I order on Slice or another service. I go down there during my pick-up window and they say they never even got the order.They claim that there was an error in their system and never received the order. So they have to start making it after I already would've started eating.The guy tells me it will be 7 minutes...I'm not an idiot and I know it will take more then that to heat a pizza up, let alone make it from scratch. Finally, 20 minutes later, I get my order: pizza that tasted like cardboard even fresh out of the oven, soggy and bland french fries. I never got an apology or even a coupon.
We stopped here because it was close to a lot of the tourist sites. The pizza was fine but nothing to write home about. We will likely try somewhere else next time.
Connie C
This place has so many options for food! Sandwiches, Greek dishes, deli sandwiches, pasta dishes, soups and salads for a few! Not knowing this we went in to see what they had and were greeted by a lady who I think is the owner, very gregarious and enthusiastic about their offerings. We stayed to eat! My husband had an egg salad with bacon sandwich and fries. The sandwich was overflowing with eggs salad and bacon and the fries were crispy on the outside and creamy on the inside. I had a cheesesteak wrap that was very tasty and I enjoyed the fries too. Overall a great experience and very good food!
Nova V
Damn! The slice of cheese pizza was massive and so yummy! I have to definitely go back. This place would be heavy competition for insisting pizza restaurants in New York. I lived in New York for a decade and had some great pizzas there.
You can see them throwing the dough in the back. We each had the mega slice, which was almost too much and it was only $4.25! This is a quick and tasty stop if you want to try east coast pizza.
This eatery is a PRIME example of how a restaurant can serve the community & brighten the area up both literally & metaphorically speaking! The food was exceptional & fairly priced! I came in later in the evening & one can see how the staff hustles around to keep the place clean!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
As the other guy mentioned, the people running this place are helpless. Such an awful customer service experience, they take forever because they are lazy and don't do anything. Oh Brother Pizza is newish and FANTASTIC, get pizza there, run by experts.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Always great food and I'm remember by name and order!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza ???
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
This is a good pizza place. The staff was very friendly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
I had never tried this place before but I saw it on doordash and decided I’d give it a try, it was ordered around a half hour before they close and let me just say this food is AMAZING! Would definitely recommend and it was so fresh and hot!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball Parmigiana Sandwich
There is an advertised special, two slices of any pie and a drink for $10. The only thing special about it is nothing. That seems like a regular price for this pizza. Everything about it is best defined as, nothing special. The specialty pie was pretty good, almost four stars, but the vegetable slice right next to BBQ Chicken, and there was spillover that spoiled it. I can't fathom who thought that was a good idea. The restaurant is not overall well kept, but you won't starve is my best summary. Apparently, you shouldn't confuse this is Old City Pizza as there is some drama surrounding it.
Old city Pizza is a great place. It is warm, cozy, and homey inside. The owners are very sincere and sweet and greeted me when I walked in. I got a Philly cheesesteak and the service was very quick. The cheesesteak was 10 out of 10 will definitely go back :)
No idea what that dork who left the 1 star review is talking about. I walked in not too long before their closing time, ordered 2 slices and a drink and was given a 3rd slice for free as well (girl working the register said it was buy 2 get 1 free which she didn’t have to since I only ordered 2 anyways). It was solid albeit pretty standard football style pizza. Good taste, good crisp. 10$ for 3 slices and a drink doesn’t happen at most places these days.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
STOP! If I can save one person from wasting their time and money on this place, it will be enough. Run by idiots and plenty of better pizza options less than a block away.I called them looking to place an order and they specifically recommended I order on Slice or another service. I go down there during my pick-up window and they say they never even got the order.They claim that there was an error in their system and never received the order. So they have to start making it after I already would've started eating.The guy tells me it will be 7 minutes...I'm not an idiot and I know it will take more then that to heat a pizza up, let alone make it from scratch. Finally, 20 minutes later, I get my order: pizza that tasted like cardboard even fresh out of the oven, soggy and bland french fries. I never got an apology or even a coupon.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
We stopped here because it was close to a lot of the tourist sites. The pizza was fine but nothing to write home about. We will likely try somewhere else next time.
This place has so many options for food! Sandwiches, Greek dishes, deli sandwiches, pasta dishes, soups and salads for a few! Not knowing this we went in to see what they had and were greeted by a lady who I think is the owner, very gregarious and enthusiastic about their offerings. We stayed to eat! My husband had an egg salad with bacon sandwich and fries. The sandwich was overflowing with eggs salad and bacon and the fries were crispy on the outside and creamy on the inside. I had a cheesesteak wrap that was very tasty and I enjoyed the fries too. Overall a great experience and very good food!
Damn! The slice of cheese pizza was massive and so yummy! I have to definitely go back. This place would be heavy competition for insisting pizza restaurants in New York. I lived in New York for a decade and had some great pizzas there.
One of the best pizza and slices in old City.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball Parmigiana Sandwich, Quesadilla, Philly Deluxe Cheeseburger
You can see them throwing the dough in the back. We each had the mega slice, which was almost too much and it was only $4.25! This is a quick and tasty stop if you want to try east coast pizza.