Cosimo's Pizza Cafe

So disappointed!!! I walked in, ordered two strombolis to go. Wait time was sufficient. At home we cut both strombolis in half. One half of the steak stromboli had almost no steak in it. For the chicken one, I very specifically ordered 3 ingredients: chicken, broccoli, and mozzarella cheese. The one we got had almost no chicken, lots of ham, some kind of smoky bacon, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses--couldn't eat it. Both strombolis were black (overcooked) on the bottom. For all this, I gave a 20% tip when I picked them up.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 2

Great place yo eat

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Not too bad!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

The food is good, but there is always an issue of time and respect.
I've stood in line and have people walk away from the counter for minutes at a time when it was time for ME to order.
I've placed simple orders and seen the entire restaurant have an entire new batch of patrons inside even though I ordered before most of the people who left.
Placed orders had them be wrong and had to wait, again, for everyone else to get their order before mine was fixed.
Last time I was in a hurry to get somewhere, so I CALLED AHEAD FOR 4 SLICES IN 2 BOXES,,,,,,,, HOW WERE THEY NOT DONE WHEN I GOT THERE 12 MINUTES TO LATER???..??.?
I just walked out.
Side note, I don't look like the staff of this establishment....
I'm not saying that is the reason for my poor experience of customer service, if that isn't the reason, 8 don't know how people go back enough to keep them in business

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Makes every trip to Chestnut Hill worth it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The quality of the food is outstanding. Best pizza place around! Will make the drive just to get my favs!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

White pizza is wonderful!

The food is delicious.

We ordered a few items from the Cosimos catering menu for a small party. The Grandma/Nonna pizzas red and white are always delicious! We also ordered their meatballs and eggplant rollatini. Both were great, stayed hot and were enjoyed by everyone. The eggplant especially got rave reviews from our very Italian family. We will definitely be ordering from Cosimos catering again!

Get the Penne pasta!

Great Italian and American food and selection. Made to order items like the Philly Cheesesteak rolls are delicious and unforgettable. Two thumbs up

Enjoyed their plain pizza on my lunch break, and they have more yummy looking selections. See pics.

I'm seeking and reviewing the best local businesses in every geography, for Localverse (from Bethlehem, PA). Now adding Cosimo's Pizza Cafe to the list!

You may freely reuse all photos and text in reviews contributed by Localverse, and make them better.

License: CC-BY

This place never disappoints. Great restaurant to get a solid slice of their salads are also great. The staff is very friendly, and they have TVs to watch games while you eat. Also must add that the French fries are incredible! Definitely try the honey mustard for dipping.

It’s good pizza

Cozy and warm in winter, well air conditioned in summer, but sometimes a little noisy.