Oteri's Italian Bakery

4919 N 5th St, Philadelphia
(215) 457-4958

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Janice

Two years ago went and got two slices of red velvet, slices was stale and hard. Maybe that was a one time issue. Pick up a slice of red velvet yesterday (7/10/2025) . Cake was stale or either old. Oteri if you have something 2-3 days please do not serve for paying customers. I'm going to stick with Bjs for fresh cake or muffins.

Cdream._

Amazing

m wilkinson

Got everything but the jelly doughnut the staff forgot to put in my bag.

Launita Turpin

Cake was very good.

Trina Robinson

This was perfect she looked it

charlene williams

Welcoming into building and helpful

Yolanda Upshaw

Brought 6 red velvet cupcakes for a gift for one of my scouts, they were hard, dry and even the frosting was crusted over like they had been sitting for days. I called in to inform the bakery and the lady on the other end of the phone didn’t seem to care. Will never buy from them again. Shame that the single slices were fresher than the cupcakes in the case.

Dana

Oteri’s is the only bakery I go to for any occasion! Their cake is always good!

jasmine edwards

i bought a star Cake from you guys yall did yall big one , excellent job my friend loved her cake and the cake was delicious and the icing thank you again Oteris

Safety Boss

Excellent service with a great selection 👍

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Aries Empress

Worse cheesecake I ever had. In fact, it wasn't a cheesecake it was just a lump of cream cheese, no bottom crust, or nothing literally threw away $40. The kids didn't even like it, which said a lot smfh.

Food: 1

Kim Steptoe

The best bakery this side of the city.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Strawberry Shortcake

Kareema Black

Don not order from this bakery i asked her for a army fatigue cake even sent pics and they literally did the total
Opposite, cake i hard and nasty

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Dominique Payne

10/10 we love your cakes thank you so much for making my weed cake

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Yellow Cake

gibbsthunder1964

Great customer service Great price Delicious product Will definitely go back

Loading...