Oteri's Italian Bakery

4919 N 5th St, Philadelphia
(215) 457-4958

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Irish Potato 1 2 Pound Average 10 to 12 Pieces
Chocolate Covered Strawberries Large Box
Chocolate Covered Pretzels
Wedding Cake of the Day
St Joseph Day Zeppoles
Cannoli Mini Chocolate
Chocolate Covered Oreo
9 Strawberry Shortcake
Pikachu Birthday Cake
Half Sheet Layer Cake

Menu

Featured items
Quarter Sheet Layer Cake
Feeds twelve to fifteen.
Pound Cake Slices with Icing
Pound cake slices with icing.
Ny Cheese Cake Slices
Please choose each flavor: Cherry, Pineapple, Plain or Strawberry. Sold as each
Cinnamon Buns 6pk
Freshly baked daily.
Pineapple Upsidedown Cake Small
Butter Cake
Each.
9" Strawberry Shortcake
Feeds up to fifteen.
Bread Pudding Slices
Each.
10" Ny Cheese Cake
Feeds twelve to sixteen.
9" Pound Cake
Feeds twelve to fifteen.
7" NY Cheesecake with Topping
Please choose one topping: Blueberry, Cherry, Pineapple or Strawberry
Pies 10"
Please choose one flavor: Pumpkin or Sweet Potato
Cinnamon Buns 12pk
Baked fresh daily.
9" Layer Cake
Feeds twelve to fifteen.
Parfait Cups
Cookies
Pound.

Mains
9" Layer Cake
Feeds twelve to fifteen.
9" Pound Cake
Feeds twelve to fifteen.
Quarter Sheet Layer Cake
Feeds twelve to fifteen.
Half Sheet Layer Cake
Feeds up to thirty.
9" Strawberry Shortcake
Feeds up to fifteen.
12" Strawberry Shortcake
Feeds up to twenty five.
Pound Cake Slices without icing
Each.
Ny Cheese Cake Slices
Please choose each flavor: Cherry, Pineapple, Plain or Strawberry. Sold as each
7" Ny Cheese Cake
Feeds six to eight.
Flan Slices
Each.
Guava Powder Slices
Each.
Bread Pudding Slices
Each.
10" Ny Cheese Cake
Feeds twelve to sixteen.
Cupcakes
Each.
Cannoli Large Ricotta
Each.
Cannoli Large Vanilla
Each.
Cannoli Large Chocolate
Each.
Butter Cake
Each.
Pops
Choose Flavor: Cheesecake, Cannoli and Brownie. Sold as Each
Cookies
Pound.
Pizelle Cookies
Bag.
Sugar Free Cookies
Pound.
Chocolate Covered Pretzels
Each.
Chocolate Covered Oreo
Each.
Parfait Cups
Pineapple Upsidedown Cake Small
Eclairs Large
Chocolate or whip cream.
Pound Cake Slices with Icing
Pound cake slices with icing.
Guava Cheese Turnovers
Guava cheese turnovers.
Donuts
Fresh donuts daily.
Danish Large
Assorted Danish.
Cinnamon Buns 6pk
Freshly baked daily.
Cinnamon Buns 12pk
Baked fresh daily.
Tembleque
Coconut creame custard.
Pie 10"
Please choose one: Apple, Blueberry, Cherry and Peach
Pies Crumb 10"
Please choose one flavor: Apple, Blueberry, Cherry and Peach
Pies 10"
Please choose one flavor: Pumpkin or Sweet Potato
7" NY Cheesecake with Topping
Please choose one topping: Blueberry, Cherry, Pineapple or Strawberry
German Cheese Square Pie Plain
Character Cupcake
Please Choose which Character: Yellow Bird, Blue Monster w/Cookie and Red Monster
3" Cakes
Please choose one: Black Forest, Carrot, Chocolate Carmel, Chocolate Wine, German Chocolate, Birthday Cake and Oreo
Cannoli Mini Ricotta
Each.
Cannoli Mini Vanilla
Each.
Cannoli Mini Chocolate
Each.
Chocolate Covered Strawberries Small Box
Six to eight freshly dipped strawberries.
7" Fancy Cakes
Seven" fancy cakes.
Cookie Tray 2 Pound
Italian butter cookies.
Cookie Tray 3 Pounds
Italian butter cookies.
Chocolate Covered Strawberries Large Box
12 freshly dipped strawberries.
Apple Carmel Peanut Covered
Each

Specialty Cakes
Special Cake Slices
Various flavors to choose from.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+69 photos
Photo credit: google
+68 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Purchased a customized cake for my daughter’s birthday and it was EVERYTHING and my daughter LOVED IT!! I have been a patron of Oteri’s on 5th St since middle school and always go to them for specialty cakes…THEY NEVER MISS!! Thanks Oteri’s for helping to make my daughter’s birthday memorable!
February 2025
Excellent service, I was able to place my order online and immediately received an email confirming my order. I also received a call the following day to ensure the order and all details on the cake were correct. The cake was beautiful and delicious.
January 2025
One.. the cake I ordered from oter's was beautiful and what topped it off ..it was delicious and family and friends ask me where did I get the cake from. that's how much that cake drew attention..they cake speaks for it self thx oteri I will be ordering from you again
January 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Shaggy Caribbean Cuisine - 4909 N 5th St
Jamaican, Caribbean
Ribs-R-Us - 4912 N 5th St #3810
Fast Food, Barbeque, Chicken Wings
Restaurante Que Ricura - 4903 N 5th St

Oteri's Italian Bakery

4919 N 5th St, Philadelphia, PA 19120
(215) 457-4958