Great pizza! Very fresh and lovely dough. Can get a bit crowded, but I guess rightfully so. The dessert special was super! Lots of vegetarian options.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Braedon Lehman
Very flavorful and unique pizza! Can taste the high-quality sourdough crust. We came here as a large group and ordered 7 pizzas to share, they were all extremely flavorful and individually unique! The service was attentive and the natural wine selection is great! We prefer the cozy outdoor patio space to inside. A great neighborhood pizza joint.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jonathan Mainguy
I have been doing Keto for the last 4 months, and decided to break it for some Pizza in Philly. I am so sad that I don't live here and can get Sally anytime I want. The pizza I got tonight is quite possibly the best pizza I have ever had, and pizza is my favorite food.
I got the red base pie, added basil, garlic, pepperoni and buffalo mozzarella. I also got the hot honey on the side and trickled some over each slice as I ate the pie. I was in heaven eating this work of art, amazing.
Pickup was easy, as soon as you walk in the door there is a employee managing the orders and sitting people at tables if they are eating in. I let her know I was a little earlyfor the pickup and she assured me she would bring it right out to me as soon as it was ready. I waited outside as the weather was nice. A few minutes later the employee came out and handed me the pies with a smile, she must have known the treat I was in for when I got back to my place to eat.
Next time I come to Philly, I am coming to Sally's and getting this order again, what a gem, great food, great people. Thank you so much for making my delicious dinner this evening.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Caroline Myers
We’ve lived here for almost two years and spent a long time trying to make Sally a “regular” spot for us. Their pizza is delicious, as are their veggies and wines (salads are hit-or-miss, sometimes a little salty). Unfortunately, their service has discouraged us from coming back. Although we were going almost weekly at one point and regularly bringing friends/family from out of town, no one ever acknowledged that they had seen us before. They were perfectly nice when we sat down, and we weren’t looking for anything crazy, but it was just weird and a little unsettlingly to talk to someone every week for three months and have them act like they’ve never seen you before. We were also disappointed that they stopped changing more of their menu seasonally, now it’s just one pizza special and some drinks that rotate. Anyways 3 stars because food is great but menu is limited, service is nice but impersonal, phone service is hit or miss (sometimes really nice, tonight got told to call back later because they couldn’t order ahead, then when we called back were told it was too busy). Still solid but not outstanding place— feels like they used to take more pride in what they do.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Courtney Miner
I’ve never been passionate about a salad before, but whatever is in the little gem dressing is amazing. Small plates are the star of the show, pizza is the side act here.
Caroline Wilson
A great experience every time we go! Our favorite date night spot. Everything is delicious, the staff is always so wonderful and kind.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Evelyn Schwartz
10/10 location, lovely outdoor seating, and the staff was exemplary!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alison Bashford
Food was really tasty but you don’t get a lot for the price. Our service was pretty terrible. Our waiter blatantly ignored us pretty much the whole time and we had to call him over just to be able to order or get the check. He was extremely cold to us and I could hear him being nice and telling other tables about the specials. We just got a “what do you want” kind of vibe instead and weren’t even told the specials. He accidentally gave us the wrong check so I let him know and he just looked at me and said “ok” and threw it away and came back with the correct one. Super weird
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Achille Verheye
Tasty! Music selection was super solid
Tim G
Hard not to come here 3 times a week! Excellent everything! The Kale Caesar is my fave salad in the city… Pizzas that doesn’t align with the typical Philly pies in the absolute best ways possible!
This place is great. Friendly and fast service. Excellent menu items and wine list. We had a great date night here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage and Rapini Pizza, Side of Hot Honey, Greens Salad
Jacklyn LeVito
Finally made it to Sally last week and it was worth the hype! Absolutely loved the red pie and the passionfruit cocktail. Service was excellent and staff helped with navigating the menu. Can’t wait for future visits.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
scale LAD
Rude people! Stuck up with no respect for their customers. The guy who answered the phone can’t answer simple questions and hangs up the phone then ignores my calls! God forbid my son has any allergies. I’ll take my business elsewhere
Pete Tavormina
Killer sourdough wood fired pies, great apps, good beer selection. Nice quiet location and excellent staff. Easy top 10 Philly pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Samyuktha Guttha
Food is excellent! The service was fine the first time. The second time the seating hostess was fairly standoffish and wouldn’t allow us to sit at specific tables despite having open reservations for the time we were there. If you’re okay sitting on the curb, half a block away—welcome!
Great pizza! Very fresh and lovely dough. Can get a bit crowded, but I guess rightfully so. The dessert special was super! Lots of vegetarian options.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very flavorful and unique pizza! Can taste the high-quality sourdough crust. We came here as a large group and ordered 7 pizzas to share, they were all extremely flavorful and individually unique! The service was attentive and the natural wine selection is great! We prefer the cozy outdoor patio space to inside. A great neighborhood pizza joint.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have been doing Keto for the last 4 months, and decided to break it for some Pizza in Philly. I am so sad that I don't live here and can get Sally anytime I want. The pizza I got tonight is quite possibly the best pizza I have ever had, and pizza is my favorite food.
I got the red base pie, added basil, garlic, pepperoni and buffalo mozzarella. I also got the hot honey on the side and trickled some over each slice as I ate the pie. I was in heaven eating this work of art, amazing.
Pickup was easy, as soon as you walk in the door there is a employee managing the orders and sitting people at tables if they are eating in. I let her know I was a little earlyfor the pickup and she assured me she would bring it right out to me as soon as it was ready. I waited outside as the weather was nice. A few minutes later the employee came out and handed me the pies with a smile, she must have known the treat I was in for when I got back to my place to eat.
Next time I come to Philly, I am coming to Sally's and getting this order again, what a gem, great food, great people. Thank you so much for making my delicious dinner this evening.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We’ve lived here for almost two years and spent a long time trying to make Sally a “regular” spot for us. Their pizza is delicious, as are their veggies and wines (salads are hit-or-miss, sometimes a little salty). Unfortunately, their service has discouraged us from coming back. Although we were going almost weekly at one point and regularly bringing friends/family from out of town, no one ever acknowledged that they had seen us before. They were perfectly nice when we sat down, and we weren’t looking for anything crazy, but it was just weird and a little unsettlingly to talk to someone every week for three months and have them act like they’ve never seen you before. We were also disappointed that they stopped changing more of their menu seasonally, now it’s just one pizza special and some drinks that rotate. Anyways 3 stars because food is great but menu is limited, service is nice but impersonal, phone service is hit or miss (sometimes really nice, tonight got told to call back later because they couldn’t order ahead, then when we called back were told it was too busy). Still solid but not outstanding place— feels like they used to take more pride in what they do.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
I’ve never been passionate about a salad before, but whatever is in the little gem dressing is amazing. Small plates are the star of the show, pizza is the side act here.
A great experience every time we go! Our favorite date night spot. Everything is delicious, the staff is always so wonderful and kind.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
10/10 location, lovely outdoor seating, and the staff was exemplary!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was really tasty but you don’t get a lot for the price. Our service was pretty terrible. Our waiter blatantly ignored us pretty much the whole time and we had to call him over just to be able to order or get the check. He was extremely cold to us and I could hear him being nice and telling other tables about the specials. We just got a “what do you want” kind of vibe instead and weren’t even told the specials. He accidentally gave us the wrong check so I let him know and he just looked at me and said “ok” and threw it away and came back with the correct one. Super weird
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Tasty! Music selection was super solid
Hard not to come here 3 times a week! Excellent everything! The Kale Caesar is my fave salad in the city… Pizzas that doesn’t align with the typical Philly pies in the absolute best ways possible!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Red Pizza, Meatballs, Red Pie
Restaurantji Recommends
This place is great. Friendly and fast service. Excellent menu items and wine list. We had a great date night here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage and Rapini Pizza, Side of Hot Honey, Greens Salad
Finally made it to Sally last week and it was worth the hype! Absolutely loved the red pie and the passionfruit cocktail. Service was excellent and staff helped with navigating the menu. Can’t wait for future visits.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rude people! Stuck up with no respect for their customers. The guy who answered the phone can’t answer simple questions and hangs up the phone then ignores my calls! God forbid my son has any allergies. I’ll take my business elsewhere
Killer sourdough wood fired pies, great apps, good beer selection. Nice quiet location and excellent staff. Easy top 10 Philly pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food is excellent! The service was fine the first time. The second time the seating hostess was fairly standoffish and wouldn’t allow us to sit at specific tables despite having open reservations for the time we were there. If you’re okay sitting on the curb, half a block away—welcome!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Loading...