Quintessential local pizza spot with delicious homemade square pie. Light and crispy with delicious sauce. Absolutely 100% recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bennett Gauthier
ATE HERE EXPECTING A PLEASANT EXPERIENCE. Got a pizza for one and was AMAZED, as it was absolutely delish. the ambience? ABSOLUTELY HARROWING CHOICE OF MUSIC. made eating my pancetta spinach and white sauce pizza for ONE a deeply uncomfortable experience. Like being at YOUR LITTLE COUSINS Bar Mitzvah and her MOTHER (Your Aunt) is expecting you to participate in COKE VS. PEPSI. I don’t want to listen to KPOP DEMON hunters on my quiet Sunday evening. Signing off. -BubbleBumper99
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
DIANE BARNES
Great atmosphere. The food and staff were amazing. Like family
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fatima Ibrahim
We had such a wonderful experience at Square Pie Pizza today! I brought my students here, and everything from start to finish was exceptional. The food was incredibly fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care and pride.
Lew and Ed were beyond kind, warm, welcoming, and fun! Lew even took the time to show us how he coats the breadcrumbs for the Arancini, which was such a thoughtful and educational moment for my students. They made us feel truly included and valued, not just like customers but like special guests.
Their kindness, patience, and willingness to share their craft made the visit extra special. The atmosphere was inviting, the service was outstanding, and the pizza, meatballs and salad were absolutely delicious. We are so grateful for the experience and highly recommend Square Pie! We will definitely be back! :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Square Pie, Meatballs, Caesar Salad
May Shum
Called and spoke w/ the front staff a few months ago to make a reservation for a friend's bachelor party. Unfortunately, showed up for the reservation and was told they don't take reservations and wouldn't be able to seat our party. Was then told that if we waited 40 minutes they would be able to push some tables together for our party, so to grab some drinks elsewhere and they'd give us a call. After 45 minutes, we called back and were told to wait another 20-30. At that point, we finally got a call saying they wouldn't be able to seat us at all. Disappointing experience - wish they hadn't led us on.
Service: 1
Allie Whitefleet
Incredible pizza! 10/10!!
Food: 5
Sergei Peysakhov
Love their pizza, and the staff is super friendly. It is our go-to pizza spot
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Square Pie
Owen Kobasz
Awesome grandma style pizza. Honestly worth the trip to south for me
Adam Tarsia
Visited for our first time today around 4:30. We were the only people in there at the time, and were greeted instantly. Our server was great and attentive to both us and the customers coming in. She really multitasked perfectly between helping get ingredients for the team, checking on us, and paying attention to the people coming in for pick-up and the ones who wanted to be seated. The pizza was amazing (we got a plain and a pepperoni square) Even though this was our first visit I really enjoyed the fact that they had an adventurous idea for a special which was pulled pork pizza. We were going to order one of them to go for later but unfortunately we got too full on what we ordered and did not want to bring anything home besides our leftovers. 10/10 and we will be back again and again! This may be some of my favorite pizza in the city. HIGHLY recommend as everyone else has said; Thanks guys!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Thom van Tijn
Am amazing shop serving up Sicilian style square pies
Totally enjoyed our experience at Square Pie. Simple menu but outstanding food that exceeded our expectations.
The Arancini and Pizza was not only delicious but just about perfect.
The 'Sicilian' style was light and crunchy.
Great place for pizza lovers and I definitely would go back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Morgan Morris
Good takeout experience. I was wishing that both the large pepperoni pie and small white would have been more on the fluffy side in the dough department, both were a bit dense in my opinion. Otherwise very yummy and will be back to try some exciting pies out!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Evan Moorehead
Personal favorite for pizza. I’m always impressed by their high quality control.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
KARIM ELKHOLY
Got the mushroom pizza — super filling with a great crispy undercarriage. It was a little more burnt to my liking, and I felt it could use a bit more sauce, but overall it was solid. I’ll definitely be back to try more items on the menu.
Chris Terrell
The pizza here is excellent, and I recommend for takeout. Dining in was not worth it. The ambience isn’t great, service very average, and not a great value for $37 for two people. Skip that and order a very tasty pie and enjoy at home.
Quintessential local pizza spot with delicious homemade square pie. Light and crispy with delicious sauce. Absolutely 100% recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
ATE HERE EXPECTING A PLEASANT EXPERIENCE. Got a pizza for one and was AMAZED, as it was absolutely delish. the ambience? ABSOLUTELY HARROWING CHOICE OF MUSIC. made eating my pancetta spinach and white sauce pizza for ONE a deeply uncomfortable experience. Like being at YOUR LITTLE COUSINS Bar Mitzvah and her MOTHER (Your Aunt) is expecting you to participate in COKE VS. PEPSI. I don’t want to listen to KPOP DEMON hunters on my quiet Sunday evening. Signing off.
-BubbleBumper99
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great atmosphere. The food and staff were amazing. Like family
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had such a wonderful experience at Square Pie Pizza today! I brought my students here, and everything from start to finish was exceptional. The food was incredibly fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care and pride.
Lew and Ed were beyond kind, warm, welcoming, and fun! Lew even took the time to show us how he coats the breadcrumbs for the Arancini, which was such a thoughtful and educational moment for my students. They made us feel truly included and valued, not just like customers but like special guests.
Their kindness, patience, and willingness to share their craft made the visit extra special. The atmosphere was inviting, the service was outstanding, and the pizza, meatballs and salad were absolutely delicious. We are so grateful for the experience and highly recommend Square Pie! We will definitely be back! :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Square Pie, Meatballs, Caesar Salad
Called and spoke w/ the front staff a few months ago to make a reservation for a friend's bachelor party. Unfortunately, showed up for the reservation and was told they don't take reservations and wouldn't be able to seat our party. Was then told that if we waited 40 minutes they would be able to push some tables together for our party, so to grab some drinks elsewhere and they'd give us a call. After 45 minutes, we called back and were told to wait another 20-30. At that point, we finally got a call saying they wouldn't be able to seat us at all. Disappointing experience - wish they hadn't led us on.
Service: 1
Incredible pizza! 10/10!!
Food: 5
Love their pizza, and the staff is super friendly. It is our go-to pizza spot
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Square Pie
Awesome grandma style pizza. Honestly worth the trip to south for me
Visited for our first time today around 4:30. We were the only people in there at the time, and were greeted instantly. Our server was great and attentive to both us and the customers coming in. She really multitasked perfectly between helping get ingredients for the team, checking on us, and paying attention to the people coming in for pick-up and the ones who wanted to be seated.
The pizza was amazing (we got a plain and a pepperoni square)
Even though this was our first visit I really enjoyed the fact that they had an adventurous idea for a special which was pulled pork pizza. We were going to order one of them to go for later but unfortunately we got too full on what we ordered and did not want to bring anything home besides our leftovers. 10/10 and we will be back again and again! This may be some of my favorite pizza in the city.
HIGHLY recommend as everyone else has said;
Thanks guys!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Am amazing shop serving up Sicilian style square pies
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Totally enjoyed our experience at Square Pie. Simple menu but outstanding food that exceeded our expectations.
The Arancini and Pizza was not only delicious but just about perfect.
The 'Sicilian' style was light and crunchy.
Great place for pizza lovers and I definitely would go back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good takeout experience. I was wishing that both the large pepperoni pie and small white would have been more on the fluffy side in the dough department, both were a bit dense in my opinion. Otherwise very yummy and will be back to try some exciting pies out!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Personal favorite for pizza. I’m always impressed by their high quality control.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got the mushroom pizza — super filling with a great crispy undercarriage. It was a little more burnt to my liking, and I felt it could use a bit more sauce, but overall it was solid. I’ll definitely be back to try more items on the menu.
The pizza here is excellent, and I recommend for takeout. Dining in was not worth it. The ambience isn’t great, service very average, and not a great value for $37 for two people. Skip that and order a very tasty pie and enjoy at home.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Loading...