Amato's Sandwich Shops

376 Butler St, Pittsburgh
(412) 781-9789

Recent Reviews

Sort by
thomasB110

Pizza has been in Etna for over 55 years and still with original family. You KNOW it has to be delicious. My favorite.

Andrea Miller

The only good thing here is the Italian hoagie. They are severely understaffed (even before COVID) and everything is bland and under seasoned AKA not seasoned at all. It is cheap and not bad just mediocre so if you want something quick, cheap and local this or Pizza Hut are your options (PH tastes way better).

Flynn O'Brien

Sorry to hear that they will be closing down because of the owner passing away. They have the best sicilian white pizza which I always get with tomato.I will definitely miss this place.

Christine Dombroski

One of the best and oldest pizza shop in Etna! Love thier pizza and hoagies!!

Jacquie Kennelly

Best pizza and hoagies!

aly dean

Best hoagies ever! Highly recommend trying the Italian.

Joe Styler

This is a must if you’re in Pittsburgh and want a pan style pizza. The place is unique to say. The least. It’s a hole in the wall but don’t let that fool you. They make amazing pizza and have been in business for 70 years or so for a reason. The pizza is amazing.

Mike Karis

The pizza was light and fluffy before. Now as thin as an Oreo cookie And burnt Meatballs burnt And no lettuce on Italian hoagie. Forgot dressing on the side. Didn’t even want to give to the family. But they picked around it and put our lettuce on it Took off meatballs

Harold Penn

THEY DON’T ACCEPT CREDIT CARD. CASH ONLY. I had a workmate who ordered lunch for a work group of 50 employees for a big project. They didn’t even mention beforehand that they didn’t take credit card. You would think they would have told him beforehand that they didn’t accept credit card for an order that big. The pizza was mediocre.

Noodle fusion

Very good pizza, Perfect amount of cheese and sauce, It has no crust, And it isn't full of salt. I haven't tried their other stuff but I bet it is just as good, Only downside is cash only.

Denise Hall

Favorite pizza in Etna, if not all of da Burg. Get it at least once a week with ham, pepperoni, and banana peppers. ❤

hotshot 007

My favorite pizza and hogies been eating there for years still taste the same. Sauce dough cheese . I love thereFood.

jerry geriatics

Always good been going there over 65 years

Christie Lowrey

Best Sam Special hoagie

Chris G

First off they gave my food to some1 else and i had to argue about that. So then i told the my order Again. Which you could tell they didn't wanna make it. And acted as they did nothing wrong. No apologies. So 1 hour and oh about 15 later i ask. It took 1 hour and 40 min to complete it. So i ask for a free 2 liter since it took so long. He said(So you dont want the food and grab it off the counter so when i went to grab it he messed it all up and said you aticking me with this food.. I said give me a 2 litter and I'll take it.. What a greedy owner.. As well as no employees where wearing mask and i watched a guy handle money then make a pizza.. Maybe they don't believe in cleaning or washing hands or grems.......

Loading...