Burgatory

300 McHolme Dr, Pittsburgh
(412) 809-9400

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Piggy Butter and Jelly Burger
Phat Patti's Veggie Burger
Morty's Steakhouse Burger
Kid's Deuce Burger Deluxe
Create Your Own Burger
Trippin Chicken Burger
Build Your Own Burger
Pale Ale Onion Rings
Double Smash Burger
Burger of the Month

Menu

Specials
Burger of the Month
Follow us @BurgatoryBar for the current special.
Special Shake
Follow us @BurgatoryBar for the current special.

Classic Shakes
Cookie Monster
Monsters unite! The only thing better than dunking chocolate chip cookies in milk is blending them into a shake.
Caramel Pretzel
A great combination of sweet and salty. It's impossible to take just one sip, so be careful if you decide to share.
Campfire S'Mores
All your best memories of summer camp blended into a shake. You may feel the urge to start a sing-a-long. Please refrain.
Strawberry Pretzel Salad
Fresh Strawberries, Cream Cheese & Salty Pretzel Crust. The best part of any potluck dinner you ever had to attend.
Oreo Peanut Butter Pie
Oreo. Peanut Butter. Pie. Seriously, is there anything else we need to say her
Salted Nutella Crunch
Some people are just meant for each other. Nutella & Nestle Crunch Bars are the shake equivalent. Try it & you'll fall in love too. Wait, this is starting to get weird.
Cold Brew Brownie
House Cold Brew Espresso + Just Baked Brownies. Like a great coffee house experience while hanging out in a bar, which is way more fun.
Choco's Taco
Crushed Waffle Cone, Fudge & Peanuts. A summer vacation classic without the hassle of chasing down the ice cream truck.
Strawberry Shake
Milk & Cereal
It doesn't get any better than eating Fruity Pebbles & watching cartoons on Saturday morning. This shake will take you there. Yabba-dabba-doo!
Birthday Cake
House Baked Birthday Cake brimming with all the sprinkles. Like your best birthday memory spun into one shake. Candles not included.
Chocolate Shake
Vanilla Shake

Vegan Shakes
Soy Vanilla Ice Cream Shakes

Fingers
Truffled Gorgonzola Fries
Tossed with white truffle oil and Amish Gorgonzola.
Fork It Fries
Sea Salt & Fresh Herb House Fries smothered with Braised Short Ribs, Cheddar Cheese Curds & Pan Gravy. You're going to need a fork.
Pale Ale Onion Rings
Fat brew battered onion rings served with spicy ketchup and chipotle horseradish dipping sauce.
Honey Habanero Wings
Not too hot. Not too sweet. Buffalo Sauce & Bourbon BBQ available for those more traditionally minded.
Six Napkin Nachos
Tony's Chicken Chili, Queso, Jack & Cheddar Cheese, Pickled Jalapeño Peppers, Grilled Corn, Shredded Lettuce, Pickled Red Onions & Toasted Chile Sauce. Extra napkins are complimentary.
Wicked Wings
Pan's Top Secret 13-Ingredient Dry Spice Rubbed Wings drizzled with Hot Honey Glaze. Perfect combo of sweet & heat. One bite & you'll be hooked.
Señor Cheese
House-Made Queso topped with Diced Tomatoes. Served with House-Fried Corn Tortilla Chips. Good for sharing with the whole congregation.
Buffalo Wings
BBQ Wings
Chili Cheese Fries
Sea Salt & Fresh Herb House Fries tossed with Queso, Tony's Chicken Chili, Pickled Jalapeños, Shredded Iceberg, Toasted Chile Sauce & Diced Tomatoes.

Forks
Sonoma Chopped Chicken
Grilled chicken breast, baby spinach and crisp greens, apple smoked bacon crumbles, hard cooked egg, cucumber, sweet onion, tomato, avocado, red pepper, Gorgonzola and herbed croutons with red wine vinaigrette.
The Farm House Salad
Baby lettuces and arugula tossed with sunflower seeds, shaved Parmesan, roasted Roma tomatoes, sweet corn, haystack onions and balsamic vinaigrette.
Green Goddess Bowl
Ancient Grains, Roasted Sweet Potato & Corn, Spiced Chickpeas, Pickled Red Onions & Feta with Green Goddess Dressing.

Spoons
Tony's Chicken Chilli
Small Batch Chili topped with Grated Farmhouse Cheddar, Toasted Chile Sauce & Diced Sweet Red Onions. Served with warm Jalapeño & Cheddar Cornbread.

Burgers
Standard Deluxe Burger
All natural beef burger with white American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and burger sauce. Served with fresh sweet and russet potato chips.
The Triple B Burger
All Natural Montana Range Bison slathered up with House-Made Queso, Applewood Smoked Bacon, Tomato & Pickled Jalapeños on a Pretzel Bun. Served with fresh sweet and russet potato chips.
The Impossible Burger
Impossible burger topped with white American cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion, dill pickles, and naughty sauce on a potato bun. Served with fresh sweet and russet potato chips.
Piggy Butter and Jelly Burger
Cajun dusted ground beef and ground bacon burger with white American cheese, candied bacon, bread and butter pickles, peanut butter, and habanero jelly. Served with fresh sweet and russet potato chips.
Double Smash Burger
Two Griddled Smash Burgers with Double White American Cheese, Griddled Onions, Naughty Sauce, Dill Pickles & Bacon on a Potato Bun. Served with fresh sweet and russet potato chips.
Meat Your Maker Burger
Dry Aged Wagyu Beef with Sweet Onion Crust, Sharp Swiss, Roasted Tomatoes, Organic Field Greens & Truffled Shallot Aioli. So good you'll think you died & went to heaven. Served with fresh sweet and russet potato chips.
Tortilla Fried Chicken
Tortilla Chip Crusted Fried Ground Chicken with Queso, Pickled Red Onions & Jalapeños, Tomato, Shredded Lettuce & Toasted Chile Sauce on Brioche.
Morty's Steakhouse Burger
Peppercorn crusted beef with horseradish cheddar, caramelized onions, haystack onions, and cabernet sauce. Served with fresh sweet and russet potato chips.
Elk Gone BBQ Burger
BBQ Rubbed Elk with Farmhouse Cheddar, Seared Pork Belly, Tomato, Bread & Butter Pickles, Pickled Red Onion & Honey Mustard on Brioche. Like a Texas BBQ feast on a burger. Served with fresh sweet and russet potato chips.
All Day Brunch
Breakfast Spiced Fiddy-Fiddy with American Cheese, Over Easy Egg, Applewood Smoked Bacon & Tabasco Mayo on Brioche.
Cha-Cha Chicken Burger
Everything Bagel Rubbed All Natural Chicken Burger with Sharp Swiss Cheese, Tomato, Avocado, Bacon & a schmear of French Onion Dip on a Pretzel Bun. Served with fresh sweet and russet potato chips.
Phat Patti's Veggie Burger
Ground Cremini Mushrooms, Ancient Grains, Cashews & Local Veggies mixed with a million secret ingredients. Topped with Smoked Salt Gouda, Baby Arugula, Tomato & Avocado on a Honey Wheat Bun.

Custom Creation
Build Your Own Burger
Name Your Creation below!

Hands
WTF Chicken Sandwich
Our Fried Chicken is topped with Shaved Iceberg, Dill Pickles & Honey Mustard on Brioche. One bite & you'll get the name! Served with lightly dressed field greens.
Hot Diggity Dog
House-Made Chicken Chili & Queso slathered on a Grilled All Beef Hot Dog & topped with Diced Red Onions. Served with House Russet Potato Chips.

Sides
Sea Salt and Herb Fries
Baked Fresh Jalapeno and Cheddar Cornbread
Served with Honey Butter.
Smoked Pepper and Pork Belly Baked Beans
Napa Slaw
Sunny Side Salad
Garden Quinoa Salad

Kids Meals
Deuce Burger Deluxe
Two mini cheeseburgers.
Foghorn's Fried Chicken
All natural chicken breast tenders.
Grilled Cheese
Gooey American cheese on griddled bread.
The Lucky Dog
Grilled all beef hot dog.

Beverages
Pibb Xtra®
Diet Cola
Coca-Cola®
Coca-Cola Soda
Pibb Xtra®
Spiced Cherry Cola
Coca-Cola® Cherry
Cherry Flavored Coca-Cola
Sprite®
Lemon Lime Soda
Natrona Root Beer
Apple Juice
Natrona Ginger Beer

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+49 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+48 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

The burgers are awesome. They are charbroiled and you can taste it after you're done. Their burger sauce is ok, it's made of mayo, ketchup and cinnamon. The milkshake is also awesome.
June 2025
I’ve been to the North Shore Burgatory before and they were excellent as well. This location wasn’t any different; friendly and helpful staff, great food and excellent service. I had the Morty’s Steakhouse burger and my son had a build your own. We shared a Gorgonzola fry. All of it was excellent and filling.
January 2025
Delicious, well cooked, flavorful burgers. Both burgers were cooked perfectly to temperature across the entire burger patty. The hormone free beef tasted fresh with a smooth beef flavor. The fresh russet potato chips were made fresh to order and at the perfect cook (fully browned) for that homemade chip flavor. Recommended for burger connoisseurs.

Vegetarian options: Impossible Burger is an option as well as the green goddess salad which has quinoa, couscous,...
January 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Crumbl - North Fayette - 306 McHolme Dr
Bakery, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Dessert
Panera Bread - 250 McHolme Dr
Cafe, Salad, Soup, Vegan
Firehouse Subs Pointe At North Fayette - 320 McHolme Dr
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food, Pet Friendly

Burgatory

300 McHolme Dr, Pittsburgh, PA 15275
(412) 809-9400