Carmella's Plates & Pints
1908 E Carson St, Pittsburgh
(412) 918-1215
Customers' Favorites
Dark Chocolate Mousse
Carmella's Breakfast
Wild Boar Meatballs
Gnocchi Portofino
Wagyu Beef Burger
Lobster Risotto
Sunday Brunch
Wagyu Burger
Bison Burger
Steak & Eggs
Menu
Photos
+97 photos
+96 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Had a reservation and had no problem getting seated. Service was slow but it didn't seem too busy even for a Saturday evening. The first two appetizers we ordered were out of stock. The 3rd choice we made was the potato pancakes. We waited 15 minutes for those and they came out cold. Not warm, cold. We sent them back and they were taken off of our bill. Our entrees took awhile but they came out hot. Our server was apologetic for the appetizer mess but made it right by comping...
The ambiance was amazing. Great drink list with a lot of options. However, our food was cold and they delivered two out of four meals (cold) and 10 minutes later they brought the other two meals (also cold). Services were ok, not great.
Have been to the bar at Carmella's many times to sample the unrivaled Whiskey and Bourbon selection. Last night we ate in dinning room which featured dark wood and stained glass windows a welcoming atmosphere.Service was top notch with the food to match Pesto risotto with heirloom tomatoes and shrimp hit the spot and my wife's Cacio e pepe ( which she shared a bit) was seasoned and cooked perfectly. Overall a great experience!
You May Also Like
Primanti Bros. Restaurant and Bar - 1832 E Carson St
![]()
Sports Bar, American, Sandwich Shop, New American, Vegetarian
The Pub Chip Shop - 1830 E Carson St
![]()
Sandwich Shop, British, Fish & Chips, Vegan, Vegetarian