Casey and her team make truly incredible cakes and sweets. I have been a customer for a few years now and knew that hiring Casey for our wedding cake was the easiest decision in planning our wedding! We chose to do a small ceremony cake and ordered sheet cakes for our guests. Before finalizing our cake order we picked up one of the cake testing boxes, which was so helpful in narrowing down flavors. We ultimately went with vanilla cake and buttercream because a classic is a classic for a reason! The cake was so delicious, beautiful, and fresh on the wedding day. We couldn't have ask for a better treat to end the perfect night!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kelly Motter
This is the second time I've ordered a cake from her and both times the cake was DELICIOUS!!! Gluten free or not, you won't be disappointed! The cakes are delicious, completed on time, and worth every penny!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chelsea Hamilton
Casey did our wedding cake in 2024, and we live out of state. We had a few pieces left frozen at my in-laws, and just finished it off over the holiday.. it was INCREDIBLE, even a year and a half later which reminded me I never left a review! We had the chocolate olive oil cake and vanilla buttercream. I searched and searched for a quality baker in the Pittsburgh area that had the kind of buttercream I wanted (no Crisco!), and it’s safe to say that Casey is truly talented. She worked with me via email and even made us a to-go tasting over Christmas of 2023 which is an incredibly busy week for her as it was the only time we were in the area prior to our wedding. I cannot recommend Casey enough and we can’t wait to order some goodies in the future for family gatherings!
Anne Marie Melda
Obsessed with this cake, it's honestly a piece of art! Tastes delicious and I was able to order/pickup with just a few days notice!
Isabella Walstrom
There are not enough words to express how wonderful Casey is. She was so amazing to work with. We actually ordered a birthday cake from her and not only was the design incredible, after the first bite i knew i needed her to make my wedding cake. It looked absolutely perfect, even better than the inspo pictures and tasted AMAZING. We only had a bite or 2 at the wedding but we have been eating it for every meal for the last week because it is THAT good. I cannot recommend her enough. Thank you Casey for making the most amazing cake for our amazing day!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sydney Vlasach
Casey made a fantastic custom gluten free cake for my friend’s bachelorette party! Everyone (myself included) raved about how amazing it was & the cake was so moist you couldn’t even tell it was gluten free. Not only was the flavor amazing, but her design was flawless and was just what I had asked for as well. She was quickly responsive after I submitted my request & overall I had a wonderful experience and look forward to finding opportunities to buy her baked goods again in the future!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Irina Capozoli
The wedding cake was absolutely incredible! Not only was it beautifully designed but the taste was unbelievable - moist, flavorful and loved by every single guest. We couldn’t ask for anything better! Thank you for making our special day even more sweeter!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emily Baranik
My husband has several significant dietary restrictions, so for our wedding, my goal was simply to find him a small allergen-friendly cake so he could enjoy something special. We planned to have a separate “regular” cake for the rest of our guests.
But the cake we received from Casey Renee far exceeded all expectations- it was absolutely stunning. In fact, it was so beautiful that we ended up using it as our primary cake for photos and the cake-cutting. I still can’t believe how gorgeous it turned out!
The best part? It also tasted incredible. My husband said it was easily the best cake he’s ever had, and many of our guests actually preferred his allergen-friendly cake over the “regular” one (unfortunately for him! haha).
We are so grateful for the care and artistry that went into this cake. It made our wedding day that much more special, and we truly cannot wait for another excuse to order from Casey Renee again. Highly, highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steph Murray
Casey was friendly and accommodating. She had excellent customer service! She answered all of my questions. I ordered the chef's choice for cookies. I tasted pumpkin snikerdoodle for the first time, and I was surprisingly satisfied. They were delicious! I also had the chocolate chip and I forget the name of the third flavored cookie but it had mango as one of the ingredients. They too were delicious I love biting into a freshly baked cookies. You ever buy something for someone else but once you see it or taste it you want to keep for yourself? Well that is what happened with these cookies. They were a gift but I decided to enjoy for myself.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Victoria Slater
Ordered my bday cake from Casey. It was perfect and exactly what I wanted!! It was so beautiful but also tasted amazing. The chocolate olive oil cake and the Italian meringue buttercream icing was so so good. Will definitely continue to order from her! I bought my own plastic cake topper because I wasn’t sure what I wanted the cake to say when I ordered it, but the rest is all her work.
Our cake was delicious and beautiful. My daughter and the rest of my family loved it. I would definitely recommend Confections to anyone. Thank you Casey!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Christian Rieger
Casey is fantastic. We had a custom order for a birthday party, and she went above and beyond to tailor the order precisely to what we requested. Everyone loved it. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lquo
I had a cake that was served at a wedding this past weekend and OMG. I'm usually skeptical with vegan pastries and such, but this was absolutely delicious. It was light/fluffy and moist and the vanilla flavor was perfect. I'd love to see the rest of the bakery when I'm near the area.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Andrew Bensch
Get your wedding cake here. Plain and simple. Casey was not only communicative and kind, but her cakes are fantastic. We had a chocolate cake with chocolate ganache and chocolate frosting (can you tell we like chocolate?). It was exceptional and we received many compliments on it. The price was extremely reasonable. Overall, the whole process was super easy and the cake was fantastic. What more could we ask for? Thank you so much.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ebony Willie
Where should I start ..Casey did my sister's wedding cake and we couldn't have been more pleased with the final product not only did she do exactly what we asked but her attention to detail was spot on. We chose the vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream and everyone loved the cake ..it tasted like a sugar cookie...if you're looking for a dessert for any occasion from birthdays to a wedding please don't hesitate to call Confections by Casey Renee...you won't be disappointed.
Casey and her team make truly incredible cakes and sweets. I have been a customer for a few years now and knew that hiring Casey for our wedding cake was the easiest decision in planning our wedding! We chose to do a small ceremony cake and ordered sheet cakes for our guests. Before finalizing our cake order we picked up one of the cake testing boxes, which was so helpful in narrowing down flavors. We ultimately went with vanilla cake and buttercream because a classic is a classic for a reason! The cake was so delicious, beautiful, and fresh on the wedding day. We couldn't have ask for a better treat to end the perfect night!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is the second time I've ordered a cake from her and both times the cake was DELICIOUS!!! Gluten free or not, you won't be disappointed! The cakes are delicious, completed on time, and worth every penny!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Casey did our wedding cake in 2024, and we live out of state. We had a few pieces left frozen at my in-laws, and just finished it off over the holiday.. it was INCREDIBLE, even a year and a half later which reminded me I never left a review! We had the chocolate olive oil cake and vanilla buttercream. I searched and searched for a quality baker in the Pittsburgh area that had the kind of buttercream I wanted (no Crisco!), and it’s safe to say that Casey is truly talented. She worked with me via email and even made us a to-go tasting over Christmas of 2023 which is an incredibly busy week for her as it was the only time we were in the area prior to our wedding. I cannot recommend Casey enough and we can’t wait to order some goodies in the future for family gatherings!
Obsessed with this cake, it's honestly a piece of art! Tastes delicious and I was able to order/pickup with just a few days notice!
There are not enough words to express how wonderful Casey is. She was so amazing to work with. We actually ordered a birthday cake from her and not only was the design incredible, after the first bite i knew i needed her to make my wedding cake. It looked absolutely perfect, even better than the inspo pictures and tasted AMAZING. We only had a bite or 2 at the wedding but we have been eating it for every meal for the last week because it is THAT good. I cannot recommend her enough. Thank you Casey for making the most amazing cake for our amazing day!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Casey made a fantastic custom gluten free cake for my friend’s bachelorette party! Everyone (myself included) raved about how amazing it was & the cake was so moist you couldn’t even tell it was gluten free. Not only was the flavor amazing, but her design was flawless and was just what I had asked for as well. She was quickly responsive after I submitted my request & overall I had a wonderful experience and look forward to finding opportunities to buy her baked goods again in the future!
Food: 5
Service: 5
The wedding cake was absolutely incredible! Not only was it beautifully designed but the taste was unbelievable - moist, flavorful and loved by every single guest. We couldn’t ask for anything better! Thank you for making our special day even more sweeter!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband has several significant dietary restrictions, so for our wedding, my goal was simply to find him a small allergen-friendly cake so he could enjoy something special. We planned to have a separate “regular” cake for the rest of our guests.
But the cake we received from Casey Renee far exceeded all expectations- it was absolutely stunning. In fact, it was so beautiful that we ended up using it as our primary cake for photos and the cake-cutting. I still can’t believe how gorgeous it turned out!
The best part? It also tasted incredible. My husband said it was easily the best cake he’s ever had, and many of our guests actually preferred his allergen-friendly cake over the “regular” one (unfortunately for him! haha).
We are so grateful for the care and artistry that went into this cake. It made our wedding day that much more special, and we truly cannot wait for another excuse to order from Casey Renee again. Highly, highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Casey was friendly and accommodating. She had excellent customer service! She answered all of my questions. I ordered the chef's choice for cookies. I tasted pumpkin snikerdoodle for the first time, and I was surprisingly satisfied. They were delicious! I also had the chocolate chip and I forget the name of the third flavored cookie but it had mango as one of the ingredients. They too were delicious I love biting into a freshly baked cookies. You ever buy something for someone else but once you see it or taste it you want to keep for yourself? Well that is what happened with these cookies. They were a gift but I decided to enjoy for myself.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered my bday cake from Casey. It was perfect and exactly what I wanted!! It was so beautiful but also tasted amazing. The chocolate olive oil cake and the Italian meringue buttercream icing was so so good. Will definitely continue to order from her! I bought my own plastic cake topper because I wasn’t sure what I wanted the cake to say when I ordered it, but the rest is all her work.
Restaurantji Recommends
Our cake was delicious and beautiful. My daughter and the rest of my family loved it. I would definitely recommend Confections to anyone. Thank you Casey!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Casey is fantastic. We had a custom order for a birthday party, and she went above and beyond to tailor the order precisely to what we requested. Everyone loved it. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had a cake that was served at a wedding this past weekend and OMG. I'm usually skeptical with vegan pastries and such, but this was absolutely delicious. It was light/fluffy and moist and the vanilla flavor was perfect. I'd love to see the rest of the bakery when I'm near the area.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Get your wedding cake here. Plain and simple. Casey was not only communicative and kind, but her cakes are fantastic. We had a chocolate cake with chocolate ganache and chocolate frosting (can you tell we like chocolate?). It was exceptional and we received many compliments on it. The price was extremely reasonable. Overall, the whole process was super easy and the cake was fantastic. What more could we ask for? Thank you so much.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Where should I start ..Casey did my sister's wedding cake and we couldn't have been more pleased with the final product not only did she do exactly what we asked but her attention to detail was spot on. We chose the vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream and everyone loved the cake ..it tasted like a sugar cookie...if you're looking for a dessert for any occasion from birthdays to a wedding please don't hesitate to call Confections by Casey Renee...you won't be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Loading...