I Scream Shop

Called twice- message says Verizon cannot complete your call… is the phone disconnected??

Very nice ice cream shop, with a menu that offers all the classics as well as some very cool specialty items. I got to try out their brownies (they also serve a variety of baked foods outside of just ice cream) and their strawberry cheesecake milkshake.

Both were delicious. I was especially surprised by how amazing the brownies were. Awesome portion size, very chocolatey, pretty rich, and great texture as well.

The milkshake was also great. Portion was nice, and they managed to get a nice strawberry flavor. I will say the base itself doesn’t have much of a cheesecake flavor to it, but they include little bits of cheesecake throughout the milkshake to make up for that.

All in all, a fantastic little ice cream shop to support and visit!

Awesome little ice cream shop, great for kids!

They sell Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream! As a Wisconsin native, I usually need to drive 15 hours to get this ice cream. Now it's just a short drive to Pittsburgh away! The Espresso Oreo is amazing, but the best is Kitty Kitty Bang Bang. (Raspberry AND Oreo? Together?!?)
Wisconsin knows their dairy products. You won't be disappointed by the quality of this ice cream!

All their ice cream is delicious and they usually have a few oat flavors. When people are in town to visit in the summer I always try to take them here

Friendly, helpful staff. Great tasting ice cream.

Absolutely fantastic ice cream! Great service!

Fantastic experience all around! Love the ice cream, love the service, very friendly staff and owners, will definitely be back with friends and family. Very very very happy!!

Great ice cream flavor and texture. Soft service also excellent.

So delicious and kid friendly.. I had the blueberry lemon pound cake ice cream. 10/10 an also black owned clean establishment. Highly recommended

We went to I Scream for the first time and were pretty displeased to say the least. 1 singular scoop of ice cream is $4.50 and they told my husband they can give him a twist and ended up giving him chocolate only. The prices are extremely outrageous and I would recommend walking across the street to buy a tub of ice cream at Aldi’s for $5.00 instead.

Awesome little shop, locally owned and with genuinely delicious and creamy ice cream. Vegan options available, just as good as the more traditional offerings.

We'd come here way more often if we didn't live on the other side of town - but we always make sure to stop by when we're in the area. Really a hidden gem and glad we found it. Stop in for a scoop, you won't be disappointed!

Great spot!! Owner gave my dog some ice cream! Thanks so much. 😊

Arrived at 6:25, they close at 7. As I was getting out of my car to walk in they turned off the lights.

My partner and I had a very stressful day and the wonderful ladies here cheered us right up. We love coming here - it’s truly a treasure! They also have oat milk options for the dairy free girlies like me!