This place is totally different, order the medium pizza with one topping cost me $19, barely any topping on it and the cheese stopped about 3 in from the edge. I don't know what happened, I'm used to paying extra to order from Andy's but with what they're serving now I'm not going back.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
Colleen Gruber
I’ve been ordering from Mandy’s for 7.5 years, since being diagnosed with celiac. Things have been wonky since ownership changed, but on 12/28/24 I called at 5:15pm and was told they were out of gluten free pizza shells for the evening. Sold out at 5pm on a Saturday? So I ordered a gf turkey hoagie, to which I was told that the owner had taken this item off the menu! What?? I was flabbergasted! This is not an unconventional item, it’s a turkey hoagie! I continued my order of traditional food for the rest of my family, a pizza and two hoagies, and waited 55 minutes for them, even when the the girl answering phones was telling people 35 minutes(I know this because I stood in the restaurant for 20 mins waiting for my 3 items, since I arrived at the 35 minute mark.) It was very disappointing, and I hope that the restaurant can stay true to the original owners dream of food for those of us will allergies and restrictions.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Cakehand
The care they take for cross contamination is admirable, making it an allergen friendly restaurant. Even for vegan foods. The pizza is delicious, their vegan ranch is everything I've ever wanted in a ranch. There are smothered fries, hoagies, flatbreads, and desserts. The owner is very kind and open-minded. They have some amazing vegan food.
Han S
Mandy’s is the best! My favorite is their vegan buffalo chicken pizza, and the vegan ranch is incredible. I appreciate how allergy friendly they are, and the owner/employees are very kind. I also love that they have desserts from their bakery available. This is my favorite pizza place in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Keyz2026
gan grilled Chik’n tossed in Buffalo sauce, our homemade vegan ricotta, vegan pizza cheese, and our homemade vegan marinara sauce.
Bill Wagner
I just had the best Italian hoagie in years incredible taste thanks Bill
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joseph Harper
Bought a large 16 cut pepperoni pizza and large monster French fries. Everyone eating it complained both items were way too salty. The man operating the store seemed a bit annoyed and not very friendly. Something has changed at Mandy’s. Never had this experience in the past. 11-26-24
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Michael S
Whoever is working the phone needs to be fired
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Greg Nass
Great vegetated menu - best in the burgh
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alexander Kerr
They got epic vegan pizza. Good. Never been dissatisfied.
It’s great to have an option for pizza, along with wings and sandwiches. Great array of vegan toppings, too. They are very committed to providing vegan options and there is a special segment of the menu.
Karen Klicka
I have an extreme gluten and dairy allergy. Within 15 minutes of eating either one, I’ll have 103 fever, hives covering my whole body, and excruciating pain all over. This restaurant is so incredibly careful. I bought a meat lovers pizza with olives. It was so good! Like, so good I had to call to confirm the dough was indeed gluten free and the cheese was dairy free cause I couldn’t believe it. I had zero issues. Can’t wait to try it again. If you have allergies, and you love pizza, this is the place to go!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Gluten Free Vegan White Pizza, Cheese Pizza, Gluten Free Pizza with Pineapple
Katie Emmons
We were delivered the wrong order with the wrong toppings on our pizza. I called to request a replacement pizza or our money back, and was spoken to incredibly disrespectfully & unkindly by the store manager. He offered to repay me the price of the topping, but not to replace the pizza or give me a refund, and when I asked for one he laughed at me, told me I was disrespectful for asking, and said he would give me a few dollars off or nothing at all. We were left with a pizza we didn’t order, had to pay full price for, and dealing with rude staff who didn’t want to resolve the issue they created and we didn’t ask for. I’m sad to write this because I typically really like Mandy’s and the staff I’ve interacted before have been really nice, but this experience turned me off altogether. Being yelled at over the phone for asking for a refund of an incorrect order ruined my experience and overall view of the establishment.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Suzzi Watson
Mandy's pizza is our favorite pizza place. We have a gluten allergy. They are very accommodating. They have an allergen menu - gluten-free and vegan. The staff is always extremely nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Fries, Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Alan Watson
The best pizza! If you have allergies, they are very careful. Safe place to eat.
This place is totally different, order the medium pizza with one topping cost me $19, barely any topping on it and the cheese stopped about 3 in from the edge. I don't know what happened, I'm used to paying extra to order from Andy's but with what they're serving now I'm not going back.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
I’ve been ordering from Mandy’s for 7.5 years, since being diagnosed with celiac. Things have been wonky since ownership changed, but on 12/28/24 I called at 5:15pm and was told they were out of gluten free pizza shells for the evening. Sold out at 5pm on a Saturday? So I ordered a gf turkey hoagie, to which I was told that the owner had taken this item off the menu! What?? I was flabbergasted! This is not an unconventional item, it’s a turkey hoagie!
I continued my order of traditional food for the rest of my family, a pizza and two hoagies, and waited 55 minutes for them, even when the the girl answering phones was telling people 35 minutes(I know this because I stood in the restaurant for 20 mins waiting for my 3 items, since I arrived at the 35 minute mark.)
It was very disappointing, and I hope that the restaurant can stay true to the original owners dream of food for those of us will allergies and restrictions.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
The care they take for cross contamination is admirable, making it an allergen friendly restaurant. Even for vegan foods. The pizza is delicious, their vegan ranch is everything I've ever wanted in a ranch. There are smothered fries, hoagies, flatbreads, and desserts. The owner is very kind and open-minded. They have some amazing vegan food.
Mandy’s is the best! My favorite is their vegan buffalo chicken pizza, and the vegan ranch is incredible. I appreciate how allergy friendly they are, and the owner/employees are very kind. I also love that they have desserts from their bakery available. This is my favorite pizza place in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
gan grilled Chik’n tossed in Buffalo sauce, our homemade vegan ricotta, vegan pizza cheese, and our homemade vegan marinara sauce.
I just had the best Italian hoagie in years incredible taste thanks Bill
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bought a large 16 cut pepperoni pizza and large monster French fries. Everyone eating it complained both items were way too salty. The man operating the store seemed a bit annoyed and not very friendly. Something has changed at Mandy’s. Never had this experience in the past. 11-26-24
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Whoever is working the phone needs to be fired
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Great vegetated menu - best in the burgh
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They got epic vegan pizza. Good. Never been dissatisfied.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
It’s great to have an option for pizza, along with wings and sandwiches. Great array of vegan toppings, too. They are very committed to providing vegan options and there is a special segment of the menu.
I have an extreme gluten and dairy allergy. Within 15 minutes of eating either one, I’ll have 103 fever, hives covering my whole body, and excruciating pain all over. This restaurant is so incredibly careful. I bought a meat lovers pizza with olives. It was so good! Like, so good I had to call to confirm the dough was indeed gluten free and the cheese was dairy free cause I couldn’t believe it. I had zero issues. Can’t wait to try it again. If you have allergies, and you love pizza, this is the place to go!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Gluten Free Vegan White Pizza, Cheese Pizza, Gluten Free Pizza with Pineapple
We were delivered the wrong order with the wrong toppings on our pizza. I called to request a replacement pizza or our money back, and was spoken to incredibly disrespectfully & unkindly by the store manager. He offered to repay me the price of the topping, but not to replace the pizza or give me a refund, and when I asked for one he laughed at me, told me I was disrespectful for asking, and said he would give me a few dollars off or nothing at all. We were left with a pizza we didn’t order, had to pay full price for, and dealing with rude staff who didn’t want to resolve the issue they created and we didn’t ask for.
I’m sad to write this because I typically really like Mandy’s and the staff I’ve interacted before have been really nice, but this experience turned me off altogether. Being yelled at over the phone for asking for a refund of an incorrect order ruined my experience and overall view of the establishment.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Mandy's pizza is our favorite pizza place. We have a gluten allergy. They are very accommodating. They have an allergen menu - gluten-free and vegan. The staff is always extremely nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Fries, Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
The best pizza! If you have allergies, they are very careful. Safe place to eat.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Fries
Loading...