I'm from New York and probably a pizza snob, so rating might reflect my bias. Pizza was ok. Pies were huge, which was a plus.
Dromesburg (dromesburg)
Sicilian pizza w/pepperoni, INCREDIBLE! Great taste, pepperoni and sauce were really tasty, best part was the crust was not greasy at all. Truly a tasty work of art!! Thanks!!!!
Chrissy's Life TrinItalianinNYC
She was awesome. She carries allergen friendly desserts as well. She understands food allergies like no other. Thank you 😊
k smith
Food was fantastic!!!
zombiesoybot
Everything vegan option I’ve had has been top notch. From the pizza to the hoagies. Worth your time.
Only downside is they wouldn’t add vegan meat options to a cheese pizza for my vegetarian wife.
Cory Johnston
Having a place that understands that even my lactose intolerant self would love to eat pizza and making that happen is amazing. The pizza was to notch.
Kimberly Alozie
Stopped in to order a quick dinner to take home to eat. Didn't want to eat at a restaurant bc we had just left the DMV and had spent alot of time waiting to get our license renewals....just wanted to head home. I was told 1/2 hour for 2 subs and a calzone....checked at a 1/2 hour, was told a few more minutes. I ordered at 4:50PM. A few minutes turned in to asking again at 6:00PM, order still wasn't ready. Lines were out the door bc peoples orders weren't ready. Several people who had been waiting as long as me got their orders and they were missing parts of their order, and had to wait to get their order corrected. At 6:30 my order STILL wasn't ready, and also heard them say they were out of tartar sauce.....at that point I WAS DONE. Canceled my order, asked for a receipt for my credit card refund, left and went down the street and got awesome Chinese food from Yeungs, and had it in 10 minutes. Also note.....there was a very young baby, probe about 6 months in a playpen in the kitchen entryway. Cleaning chemicals were on a shelf above the playpen, there are so many potential hazards in a kitchen environment......I didn't understand the thinking, or lack of thinking behind that. I can't imagine that if an inspector came in that that would have been an acceptable arrangement. I won't be back. Total disaster.
Update....If you request a refund and you paid with a credit card, be sure to ask for a receipt showing the credit. I asked for a receipt, it showed a refund amount, but it was not credited to my credit card. I had to call my credit card co to have the credit issued to my card. Fortunately for me, it was a simple process. If you choose to eat here.....Good Luck.
Eric Pferdekamper
This place is totally different, order the medium pizza with one topping cost me $19, barely any topping on it and the cheese stopped about 3 in from the edge. I don't know what happened, I'm used to paying extra to order from Andy's but with what they're serving now I'm not going back.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
Colleen Gruber
I’ve been ordering from Mandy’s for 7.5 years, since being diagnosed with celiac. Things have been wonky since ownership changed, but on 12/28/24 I called at 5:15pm and was told they were out of gluten free pizza shells for the evening. Sold out at 5pm on a Saturday? So I ordered a gf turkey hoagie, to which I was told that the owner had taken this item off the menu! What?? I was flabbergasted! This is not an unconventional item, it’s a turkey hoagie! I continued my order of traditional food for the rest of my family, a pizza and two hoagies, and waited 55 minutes for them, even when the the girl answering phones was telling people 35 minutes(I know this because I stood in the restaurant for 20 mins waiting for my 3 items, since I arrived at the 35 minute mark.) It was very disappointing, and I hope that the restaurant can stay true to the original owners dream of food for those of us will allergies and restrictions.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Cakehand
The care they take for cross contamination is admirable, making it an allergen friendly restaurant. Even for vegan foods. The pizza is delicious, their vegan ranch is everything I've ever wanted in a ranch. There are smothered fries, hoagies, flatbreads, and desserts. The owner is very kind and open-minded. They have some amazing vegan food.
Mandy’s is the best! My favorite is their vegan buffalo chicken pizza, and the vegan ranch is incredible. I appreciate how allergy friendly they are, and the owner/employees are very kind. I also love that they have desserts from their bakery available. This is my favorite pizza place in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Keyz2026
gan grilled Chik’n tossed in Buffalo sauce, our homemade vegan ricotta, vegan pizza cheese, and our homemade vegan marinara sauce.
Bill Wagner
I just had the best Italian hoagie in years incredible taste thanks Bill
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joseph Harper
Bought a large 16 cut pepperoni pizza and large monster French fries. Everyone eating it complained both items were way too salty. The man operating the store seemed a bit annoyed and not very friendly. Something has changed at Mandy’s. Never had this experience in the past. 11-26-24
I'm from New York and probably a pizza snob, so rating might reflect my bias. Pizza was ok. Pies were huge, which was a plus.
Sicilian pizza w/pepperoni, INCREDIBLE! Great taste, pepperoni and sauce were really tasty, best part was the crust was not greasy at all. Truly a tasty work of art!! Thanks!!!!
She was awesome. She carries allergen friendly desserts as well. She understands food allergies like no other. Thank you 😊
Food was fantastic!!!
Everything vegan option I’ve had has been top notch. From the pizza to the hoagies. Worth your time. Only downside is they wouldn’t add vegan meat options to a cheese pizza for my vegetarian wife.
Having a place that understands that even my lactose intolerant self would love to eat pizza and making that happen is amazing. The pizza was to notch.
Stopped in to order a quick dinner to take home to eat. Didn't want to eat at a restaurant bc we had just left the DMV and had spent alot of time waiting to get our license renewals....just wanted to head home. I was told 1/2 hour for 2 subs and a calzone....checked at a 1/2 hour, was told a few more minutes. I ordered at 4:50PM. A few minutes turned in to asking again at 6:00PM, order still wasn't ready. Lines were out the door bc peoples orders weren't ready. Several people who had been waiting as long as me got their orders and they were missing parts of their order, and had to wait to get their order corrected. At 6:30 my order STILL wasn't ready, and also heard them say they were out of tartar sauce.....at that point I WAS DONE. Canceled my order, asked for a receipt for my credit card refund, left and went down the street and got awesome Chinese food from Yeungs, and had it in 10 minutes.
Also note.....there was a very young baby, probe about 6 months in a playpen in the kitchen entryway. Cleaning chemicals were on a shelf above the playpen, there are so many potential hazards in a kitchen environment......I didn't understand the thinking, or lack of thinking behind that. I can't imagine that if an inspector came in that that would have been an acceptable arrangement. I won't be back. Total disaster.
Update....If you request a refund and you paid with a credit card, be sure to ask for a receipt showing the credit. I asked for a receipt, it showed a refund amount, but it was not credited to my credit card. I had to call my credit card co to have the credit issued to my card. Fortunately for me, it was a simple process. If you choose to eat here.....Good Luck.
This place is totally different, order the medium pizza with one topping cost me $19, barely any topping on it and the cheese stopped about 3 in from the edge. I don't know what happened, I'm used to paying extra to order from Andy's but with what they're serving now I'm not going back.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
I’ve been ordering from Mandy’s for 7.5 years, since being diagnosed with celiac. Things have been wonky since ownership changed, but on 12/28/24 I called at 5:15pm and was told they were out of gluten free pizza shells for the evening. Sold out at 5pm on a Saturday? So I ordered a gf turkey hoagie, to which I was told that the owner had taken this item off the menu! What?? I was flabbergasted! This is not an unconventional item, it’s a turkey hoagie!
I continued my order of traditional food for the rest of my family, a pizza and two hoagies, and waited 55 minutes for them, even when the the girl answering phones was telling people 35 minutes(I know this because I stood in the restaurant for 20 mins waiting for my 3 items, since I arrived at the 35 minute mark.)
It was very disappointing, and I hope that the restaurant can stay true to the original owners dream of food for those of us will allergies and restrictions.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
The care they take for cross contamination is admirable, making it an allergen friendly restaurant. Even for vegan foods. The pizza is delicious, their vegan ranch is everything I've ever wanted in a ranch. There are smothered fries, hoagies, flatbreads, and desserts. The owner is very kind and open-minded. They have some amazing vegan food.
Restaurantji Recommends
Mandy’s is the best! My favorite is their vegan buffalo chicken pizza, and the vegan ranch is incredible. I appreciate how allergy friendly they are, and the owner/employees are very kind. I also love that they have desserts from their bakery available. This is my favorite pizza place in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
gan grilled Chik’n tossed in Buffalo sauce, our homemade vegan ricotta, vegan pizza cheese, and our homemade vegan marinara sauce.
I just had the best Italian hoagie in years incredible taste thanks Bill
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bought a large 16 cut pepperoni pizza and large monster French fries. Everyone eating it complained both items were way too salty. The man operating the store seemed a bit annoyed and not very friendly. Something has changed at Mandy’s. Never had this experience in the past. 11-26-24
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Whoever is working the phone needs to be fired
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...