Muddy Cup Dormont

1412 Potomac Ave, Pittsburgh
(412) 207-9561

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Marc Anthony

I was just in the shop and ordered a macha latte.It may be the worst I've hadMy drink looks like it is just straight steamed milk. There is little to no macha flavor or color.I tried to call the place to complain but no one answered the call.That's $6.75 for a cup lukewarm milkI will not be a customer there anymore

Abraham Sultan

Met Renee, the owner today and chatted with her for a bit. She fixed me an expertly done foamy macchiato for $4 and a quarter . **Note belowWhat a lovely coffeehouse!A corner spot you can duck in daily.All the signs were done by the owner.Swing by for the midcentury and farmhouse vibes. Get a seat in one of the pews. Take in your day, the sun's 10am rays, and a sip of espresso or two.This place has been serving hot cups of goodness to the local community for the past 7 years.I really like the way its decked out. Next time you're over at Dor-Stop, head down to Potomac and stop in.**My review is for an espresso macchiato with foam, I didn't try the pastry shelf or the specialty drinks.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Alex Coyne

This place was great when Melissa worked there. Now every other thing on the menu is out of stock and the current employees are laughably apathetic. The ownership of this establishment clearly doesn’t value the opportunity she has with the Dormont community. Potomac station coffee is the way to go if you’re in the area.

Service: 1

dogmaster1264

Lady was extremely rude. Ordered a iced latte asked for light ice the order comes out 3/4 full I asked why isn’t it filled she gives me a rude response and says “well you ordered light ice what do you want me to do fill it up with more milk.”

Service: 1

Crafty Cindy

Owner/worker didn't know how to make a cappucino. She said they are not Starbucks, so there's is different. Cappucino is an Italian coffee drink that has been around forever. Geez, just google how to make it then! I was served a lukewarm milk beverage! Horrible. I returned it. At least, she offered me another type of beverage, but she never comped me the difference in price of what I paid for vs. just getting a one shot espersso replacement beverage.

Shannon Claar

The Thursday barista is the sweetest soul. Not to mention my iced s’mores latte was amazing! Can’t recommend this place enough

Phone Boy

First time here...30+ years of drinking coffee and can honestly say it's the best I've ever had. Nice little neighborhood spot. Skip on the $+@r$$$$ and give Muddy Cup a try.

Olivia Wilson

Im an avid local coffee shop goer.. nice vibes. Unique place with character but coffee was mediocre. The matcha was decent but not great. They were out of stock of my first two flavor choices. Barista was very kind though! Parking is difficult.

Steve G

Best iced coffee around. I really don't know how they make it taste so much better than others

Robert Kemp

First and last time I’ll ever darken the doorstep of this coffee shop. The elderly African American woman ( didn’t get her name) that served us was ultra rude and short with us. She was out of everything and we arrived at 10:15 am. My coffee was so bad i couldn’t drink it leading me to believe she didn’t know what she was doing. I even took the time to try and counter her rudeness by attempting to be so nice she would counter being pleasant in return. No luck. Never again.

Tom Clark

Awesome drinks and pastries.Merc, our Barista was awesome

Satya Devi

We used to love this place. Sadly went down hill. Last time we stopped in, we arrived at the same time the store bought muffins did. No reason to be bringing baked goods in from a grocery store when there are so many amazing local bakeries in town. The house coffee seemed to be day old (they had just opened and it was bitter) and the caramel machiato was way too sweet. So sad to see such a cute place lower their standards this way. Hopefully they are just in a slump and will go back to the quality they started with.

Dorea Reeser

Cute spot, but the coffee was just okay. They have a ton of flavor options, but I'd rather the focus was more on high quality options, rather than variety. They also messed up my order, but I understand that the barista had a lot to take care of!

Rosy Nosy

I love this coffee shop. I have since I've lived in Bellevue, however, my experience with one of the baristas has me considering never coming here again. From time and time again, I have heard both stories and experienced it firsthand where the barista, Charlotte is not the best with customers. Ive heard talk about her demeaning people with disabilities. She has been downright rude to my family when they've been in. And it couldn't be more obvious that she doesn't know what she's doing. When asked what goes into a drink she's outright told customers that she does not know. In my past experiences this cafe has NEVER done me wrong by a drink but whenever it's Charlotte making my drink, i can guarantee that it doesn't get made the way I've been drinking it since I was 14. I've told other employees about her and nothing seems to get done. I love this coffee shop and want to see nothing more than it thriving, but I cannot condone someone like that within a community I call home

Nick Kowal

Wonderful experience. The workers were very friendly and gave their personal suggestions as it was our first time. We definitely will be back

Loading...