Worst pizza I have ever had. Bad sauce, cheese, and sponge like crust. Threw it in garbage.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Andrea Playso
First time at Nick’s Pizza, although I’ve lived in the neighbor since 2003. I wish I had found them sooner! I was drawn in with a deal/coupon and we do love pizza, so they were worth a try. My son and I went to the shop in person to order take out and as I usually do with new places get a feel for the shop and staff. The shop smelled and appeared clean ⭐️ and the staff was helpful friendly and accommodating to our requests. We got pizza and wings. All was delicious and we will return..often. Great job all around Nick’s Pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Corey Hartley
Very inconsistent. Pizza is either great or awful. Also lots of issues with being able to make things at the right time (food is ready either very late or has obviously been done for a while). Most of my issues were during busy hours, so take that as you will.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Jumbo Wings
Eric Harlan
Great pizza if you're in the South Hills area.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Elizabeth Sandhagen
1-10-24 I ordered pizza from Nick's about 4 times 2 large at a time some with pepperoni some plain. They have been constantly excellent. Every pizza was cooked without being overdone. Everyone who had it complemented how good it was asked where I got it. Today, I tried their hoagies. We purchased a steak and cheese it was excellent lots of meat. The bread was delicious and a capacola also plenty of meat the flavor and quality was excellent. I found them to be a happy surprise and intend to return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael M.
I wouldn't even give a one star had better pizza from gestation steak hoagie was horrible everything was not good didn't even bother to complain to them because if you give customers food like that you shouldn't be in business wast of 80 dollars. Guess im looking for a better pizza place in south hills
Melanie F.
New owners took over, the pizza is very good. We got an extra large during the holidays and it was huge! It tastes fresh- that's the best way I can describe it. Ordering again tonight!
Ashley Brookes
Worst pizza we ever had! Hubby and I tried this place twice. Jason is by far the worst owner this place has ever had. No passion! "specialty pie" we ordered the first time was a joke and not even what my husband ordered. "Jason" gave us a white pizza that tasted like a cardboard conveyor belt pizza you'd get at Dominoes. 2nd time we tried the steak hoagie - came with no toppings and tasted like rotten salt. You'd be better off going anywhere else. Price wise isn't any different for a better product!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Joyce Owens
They take cards for payment. They delivered. Service was awesome on the phone. Delivery was excellent & driver was extremely nice. I enjoyed Nick's Puzza very much. Good food. I will be using them often. Highly recommend!
Ordered from Nick's yet again .... this pizza joint is hands down my familys favorite !!! ... the pizza is ALWAYS delicious perfect sauce cheese ratio and the steak hoagie Supreme is always on point.... we call the cook the master steak hoagie making maniac at our house because we have never been disappointed... food always arrives on time fresh n warm... I sometimes get picky with what I'd like on the hoagie or off the hoagie it comes correct every time ... Thanks again master steak hoagie making maniac the food was great !!!!
Hi stopped at nicks pizza on Monday and ordered a calzone and a steak hoagie and when I went home I started eating the calzone and noticed there was a white substance that was very gooey in it. I believe it was supposed to be ricotta cheese, but it tasted more like sour cream for the next two days I could not hold anything in my stomach. I stopped down there today and talk to the remaining half. I did not eat and I asked for the owner and was told he was in the end and I explain to the young lady at the counter that I wanted to give the uneven half to the owner and let him try it, and she told me she did not want it. She was very disinterested and unconcerned so this will probably be my last visit to this establishment
Food: 1
Service: 4
Brett Moder
Ordered an x-large meat lovers pizza. It was great. Cooked perfect. Tasted wonderful. Everyone enjoyed it. Also ordered a side of fries. The fries were cooked good and tasty.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michele Camburn
Really good pepperoni pizza from Nick’s. Delivered piping hot and very, very good. Glad to have a good pizza place nearby.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Classic Pepperoni Pizza
Jeffrey Orr
Pizza is amazing every bite to the edge has cheese. The flavor is wonder. Top 3 pizzas I have ever had
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ryan Miller
Update: new owners have done a great job. The pizza and wings are excellent, and everything else we have tried is solid. They also deliver on time and offer reliable service, which is more than we can say for the other place over on Castle Shannon.
Worst pizza I have ever had. Bad sauce, cheese, and sponge like crust. Threw it in garbage.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
First time at Nick’s Pizza, although I’ve lived in the neighbor since 2003. I wish I had found them sooner! I was drawn in with a deal/coupon and we do love pizza, so they were worth a try. My son and I went to the shop in person to order take out and as I usually do with new places get a feel for the shop and staff. The shop smelled and appeared clean ⭐️ and the staff was helpful friendly and accommodating to our requests. We got pizza and wings. All was delicious and we will return..often. Great job all around Nick’s Pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very inconsistent. Pizza is either great or awful. Also lots of issues with being able to make things at the right time (food is ready either very late or has obviously been done for a while). Most of my issues were during busy hours, so take that as you will.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Jumbo Wings
Great pizza if you're in the South Hills area.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
1-10-24 I ordered pizza from Nick's about 4 times 2 large at a time some with pepperoni some plain. They have been constantly excellent. Every pizza was cooked without being overdone. Everyone who had it complemented how good it was asked where I got it. Today, I tried their hoagies. We purchased a steak and cheese it was excellent lots of meat. The bread was delicious and a capacola also plenty of meat the flavor and quality was excellent. I found them to be a happy surprise and intend to return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I wouldn't even give a one star had better pizza from gestation steak hoagie was horrible everything was not good didn't even bother to complain to them because if you give customers food like that you shouldn't be in business wast of 80 dollars. Guess im looking for a better pizza place in south hills
New owners took over, the pizza is very good. We got an extra large during the holidays and it was huge! It tastes fresh- that's the best way I can describe it. Ordering again tonight!
Worst pizza we ever had! Hubby and I tried this place twice. Jason is by far the worst owner this place has ever had. No passion! "specialty pie" we ordered the first time was a joke and not even what my husband ordered. "Jason" gave us a white pizza that tasted like a cardboard conveyor belt pizza you'd get at Dominoes. 2nd time we tried the steak hoagie - came with no toppings and tasted like rotten salt. You'd be better off going anywhere else. Price wise isn't any different for a better product!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
They take cards for payment. They delivered. Service was awesome on the phone. Delivery was excellent & driver was extremely nice. I enjoyed Nick's Puzza very much. Good food. I will be using them often. Highly recommend!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Mushroom Anchovie Pizza
Ordered from Nick's yet again .... this pizza joint is hands down my familys favorite !!! ... the pizza is ALWAYS delicious perfect sauce cheese ratio and the steak hoagie Supreme is always on point.... we call the cook the master steak hoagie making maniac at our house because we have never been disappointed... food always arrives on time fresh n warm... I sometimes get picky with what I'd like on the hoagie or off the hoagie it comes correct every time ... Thanks again master steak hoagie making maniac the food was great !!!!
Food: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Hi stopped at nicks pizza on Monday and ordered a calzone and a steak hoagie and when I went home I started eating the calzone and noticed there was a white substance that was very gooey in it. I believe it was supposed to be ricotta cheese, but it tasted more like sour cream for the next two days I could not hold anything in my stomach. I stopped down there today and talk to the remaining half. I did not eat and I asked for the owner and was told he was in the end and I explain to the young lady at the counter that I wanted to give the uneven half to the owner and let him try it, and she told me she did not want it. She was very disinterested and unconcerned so this will probably be my last visit to this establishment
Food: 1
Service: 4
Ordered an x-large meat lovers pizza. It was great. Cooked perfect. Tasted wonderful. Everyone enjoyed it. Also ordered a side of fries. The fries were cooked good and tasty.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really good pepperoni pizza from Nick’s. Delivered piping hot and very, very good. Glad to have a good pizza place nearby.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Classic Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza is amazing every bite to the edge has cheese. The flavor is wonder. Top 3 pizzas I have ever had
Food: 5
Service: 5
Update: new owners have done a great job. The pizza and wings are excellent, and everything else we have tried is solid. They also deliver on time and offer reliable service, which is more than we can say for the other place over on Castle Shannon.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5