Pizza Fiesta (Garfield/Bloomfield)

Name: Pizza Fiesta (Garfield/Bloomfield)
Address: 4911 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, 15224, US
Telephone: (412) 362-2222
Price range: $
Rating: 3.7

$ • Pizza, Italian

Hours:
4911 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh
(412) 362-2222

Menu Order Online

About Pizza Fiesta (Garfield/Bloomfield)

Pizza Fiesta (Garfield/Bloomfield) is a highly acclaimed pizzeria known for its exceptional quality and dedication to customer satisfaction. The restaurant uses fresh ingredients to create mouthwatering pizzas with amazing flavors and consistent excellence. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or ordering for a large group, Pizza Fiesta always delivers great service and delicious, authentic pizza. Customers consistently praise the pizzeria's passion, quality, and commitment to providing an exceptional dining experience.

The dining area is clean and the staff is professional and friendly. The service is excellent, and the General Manager greets customers with a pleasant demeanor. Customers recommend the restaurant, especially the pizza, hoagies, and Fiesta rolls. The deluxe Italian hoagie is a popular choice. While the pizza may not have impressed one customer, the overall feedback is positive, with customers highlighting the late-night availability and dependability of the pizzeria.

Recently added reviews show that customers walk in and get their pizza quickly, often within about 10 minutes. The pizza is served fresh from the oven and is described as delicious, with a great crust, flavorful sauce, and stringy cheese. There are tables and chairs for those who prefer to dine in, and plenty of takeout options are available.

Customers who love Pizza Fiesta mention that it is their go-to spot, especially during First Fridays on Penn Ave. The Buffalo Chicken pizza is a favorite, with toppings like fries and spicy sauce that keep customers coming back. Some customers enjoy the pizza after drinking, calling it the perfect drunk slice, and find it equally good when sober—an amazing, not too greasy slice. Others have tried the Chicken Ranchero Pizza, which has a unique taste, and the Meat Lovers Pizza, which they found better than the Chicken Ranchero but not as good as standard cheese or Pepperoni pizzas.

One tip from customers is to avoid ordering small pizzas, as they are smaller than most frozen pizzas and not worth the price. Instead, paying a little extra for a normal-sized pizza is recommended. Overall, Pizza Fiesta continues to be praised for its quality, late-night service, and friendly staff.