Shiloh Gastro

123 Shiloh St, Pittsburgh
(412) 431-4000

Recent Reviews

Mary Munion

Great place for a drink & delicious food! Manuel is a fun & friendly bartender who is very attentive to his guests! Highly recommend the French dip-it’s delicious! Chill atmosphere & the owners are super friendly!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Felicia D.

Big fan! My friends and I came here for dinner and everything was great. This was my first time, but my friends said they come often and love the food. Nice atmosphere and great service! My friend and I got the autumn flatbread to split and the sweet potato fries. I LOVED the flatbread. It was a pretty decent size and tasted so fresh and flavorful! Sweet potato fries were also great.

Patrick Corp

Server was good. Food took about an hour to come out. Never got an explanation.Short rib tacos are a 3 out of 5Vegan stuffed peppers are tasty. ...could have used a bit more cooking and coring the stem.Piorgies were good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 2

Aidan Donnelly

Really great place!

LadyLi

They were friendly but severely understaffed. The deluscious foor made up for the tardiness of its arrival. The CRAB Cakes were OUTSTANDING!Parking: Small parking lot and street parking lot

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Pierogies

Kristina M.

The only time in my life I ordered broccoli and every single piece was burnt. One of the owners, and kitchen manager, was notified immediately and all he said was that they had a trainer working. Wouldn't even refund us for the $5 item that probably costs them less than $1. Another time, I was pregnant and they served me undercooked bacon - near raw. They made excuses instead of apologizing, said they would refund, and I never received that refund. Very poor customer service. This is not a place I would recommend to any tourists, or locals for that matter.

Meghan Kauer

The bar stools are terrible. They are nailed into the floor and if you're tall it's challenging to sit, and they are uncomfortable even if you are not tall.

Robert Kaup

Great food. great vibes. Can't wait to come back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Totchos

Melinda Knorr

First time here & we were in to see the end of the game. We had wings, burger & chicken sandy ? everything was delicious! Service was above & beyond. I'm lucky to have this place in my (temp) hood!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings, Fried Chicken Sandwich, Fries

Tim McPartland

Nice Saturday evening visit. Sweetest server. Chicken sandwich could feed a small village. Wife had a burger that she thoroughly enjoyed. Nice liquor selection and decent tap list. We'll be back.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

marilia lacombe

typical city restaurant, very elegant and comfortable.the delicious

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brittny Saville

I have been to Shiloh before but it’s been many years. The ambiance is great, staff is great, but the food is lacking.I was disappointed in the overall bland meals. The burger and loaded wing tots were pretty basic for the price. Nothing special.That being said the drink prices are ok and the location is good for me. We will be back in the summer when we can enjoy drinks on the patio.Parking: Small free parking lot next to building, other than that it’s street parking and limited

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Grace L

The food and service here has been great every time I've come! I also couldn't believe their great Monday happy hour deals.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Micaela M

We came with a group of 20+ and our bartender did great getting everyone taken care of. The food was delicious! We sampled a some of the Buffalo chicken and poutine taters tots along with the Mac n cheese from others in our group. DELICIOUS!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Andrew Bondi

One of the worst experiences I've had with a restaurant/bartender. I was here on a Friday with a group of three others. We sat down and nobody came up to us for about 15 minutes. My brother and I figured we would just go get drinks at the bar, no big deal. Mind you, we were here for happy hour and drafts were each $2 off. My brother and I each ordered two drafts, one for ourselves and one for our partners. I close the tab instead of keeping it open and notice that the bartender did not give me the happy hour discount, so I was overcharged by $4. I asked him if he gave me the happy hour discount and he said "sure" without even making eye contact with me. Considering I was overcharged and gave him the opportunity to realize his mistake, and he didn't own up to it, I didn't give him a tip. Now where it gets interesting is when I took the drinks and started walking back to my table, my brother was still at the bar. After I left, the bartender picks up my receipt and says loud enough for the people at the bar to hear "hope he tips his waitress at least." First, a tip is not automatic. Secondly, I would've tipped the man if not for his mistake on the overcharge. Lastly, no need to publicize our dispute to the entire bar. Turns out, he also overcharged my brother for his two drafts. After we were all back at the table, we made sure that we were not in the wrong and asked our server to confirm that it was happy hour and that entailed $2 off on drafts. She confirmed that was the situation. However, we didn't complain or mention the bartender, it was water under the bridge. But then... we ordered another round at the table. This time, my fiance and I were charged correctly with the $2 discount per draft, but my brother and his wife were still overcharged $2 each. So we asked the waitress about it and she said that she did give us the discount. My brother ordered two Miller Lites, which are $5 on the restaurant's menu and website. So his two drinks should have been a total of $6. Instead it was $10. So my brother's question to the waitress was "so you're telling me a Miller Draft is regularly $7, and the $5 is a discount?" Waitress said yes, even though that was not accurate. But the best part of this was right after this happened, the restaurant asked us to move tables to accommodate another party. All and all we were overcharged $12, embarrassed by the bartender, lied to by both the bartender and waitress, and then asked to move. Will not be back.

Atmosphere: 2

Service: 1

Load More