Calabrese Pizzeria

311 Unity Trestle Rd, Plum
(412) 715-4538

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Micah Nelson

Loooove their pizza and their service! Great attitude!!

Denise Matassa

Always up for new places and man was I pleasantly surprised!! Great prices, great ingredients (the mini pepperonis that curb up? Yum!) and very quick service! Crust was perfectly crunchy and sauce was just the right amount. My new go to in Plum!

Ologolos

I've had some good deep dish pizzas, and this is up there. Great flavor, and great price for the size. Highly recommended, and I will definitely be back.

Daniel Evans

First time buying a pizza from here. We ordered the deep dish pepperoni. The people are extremely friendly, the service was great and the pizza priced right. The best part, this is most likely the best pizza that I've ever tasted. The taste of the dough, sauce, pepperoni and cheese was unreal and spot on. I would highly recommend making the trip to this parlor. I'm getting hungry just writing this review. Please call and give them a try.

David Miller

The deep dish pizza is incredible!
Absolutely delicious.
Will definitely being having this again.
Probably every week!

Thomas Richards

Deep dish pizza and pinball! I like this place. Great food and people

Bill Hart

The deepdish is amazing. The crust is the best part of it with an amazing taste. Best pizza in the area. No comparison to others near by.

David Pienaar

Cancelled my order when I placed it 1hr and 20 minutes before close. No one answers the phone either

not sure

Delicious ! There deep dish is somewhere between Chicago and Detroit, crushed tomatoes but cheese on top. Good crust and good sauce. Very filling and will be back for sure.

stephanie fike

We didn’t really like this pizza. We ordered a medium deep dish pepperoni and a small this with Italian sausage. Not our style. The dough for both had a pancake taste. We did love the deep dish chunky sauce.

Lisa Franklin-Robinson

This pizza is top notch! The flavor and crust were amazing and the owners are great people! I recommend this spot to all pizza lovers! You will not be disappointed.

Jessica Gilmore

Just got delivery and I am so impressed with the taste and quality. I got a pepperoni pizza and I meant to get an Italian hoagie but accidentally got an Italian calzone and I am glad I did! The bread was fluffy and delicious.

Jacinta Dutrieuille

All I can say is this is one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. I normally go for a thin crust, but I read the reviews for a deep dish and I went for it. So flavorful and baked to perfection. I didn’t get to my cupcake yet but I can only imagine. Chef’s kiss 😘

Stephanie Casey

I wish I had taken pictures of our food, but I did not! The deep dish pizza was out of this world! It did not disappoint. And the cupcakes…just incredible! This is such a charming spot, the owners were so kind and friendly, and you could tell their passion is pizza! I highly recommend!!

Sherrone Dillard

Why is this place not more popular! Ok, so I was craving deep dish pizza, and this place popped up 10 min from UPMC East. Most of the reviews are good, but when I arrived, the place was dead.. no customers. Employees were cool and presented me with my pizza and cupcake. Told me have a good evening, and I was out. Pizza looked good, but I was worried as like I said no other customers in the shop.

Got home, and WOW pizza was great. I mean, I was truly surprised. Buttery crust, nice pepperoni, and sausage. Whoever is making the pies at this joint....CHEF KISS!! Will be back, and you should go to! Pay em a visit, get a pie, and do a Die Hard! Deep dish!

Edit!!! And I'm back again, who made these cupcakes!!!! And where do I get more? This is insane. This place needs more foot traffic. And I need more Vanilla Cookie Butter cupcakes!!!

Loading...