Sadie's Bake Shop

313 Furnace Rd, Quarryville
(717) 786-1751

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Leah Markus

I went on a Thursday and was informed that everything in the shop was previously frozen, and that they don’t bake fresh goods until Friday. I was extremely disappointed, especially because this place is off the beaten path and I went out of my way to get there. It’s worth going if you go Friday or Saturday, but I would skip any other day.

Dave Hirst

It's not in the basement anymore. It's above ground outside in the garage. What used to be a garage I guess. Very good products

Laura Lewis

Excellent baked goods! Large selection of donuts and pies. The ladies working behind the counter are very helpful and kind. A must stop if you’re in the area!

Brandon Shirey

Hands down the best small town country bakery I've been to in a long time!! If your in the area or just looking for something delicious then do yourself a favor and stop in. You will not regret it!!

Lars

Nice bakery, authentic and so friendly. Loved the taste.

Romeo Cochrane

One would pass by this little hidden gem of a place thinking that it is just another random building beside a Pennsylvania Dutch Farm. However, its simplicity belies the tasty treats and warm welcome within. They are very welcoming to cyclists and it's always a joy stopping in for their freshly baked and reasonably priced treats.

Barry Kotsak

This bake shop is off the beaten path and in a beautiful country setting in Quarryville. A real bare bones bakery. We got several types of whoopie pies and donuts. They were amazing. You will be greeted by a a couple of amish women who are scurrying about and working hard. Not only a great bakery but a very REAL Amish experience. Great prices too.

Crystal

Awesome little Amish bakery. The donuts were to die for - went there today - place came highly recommended! A must go to when in the area!!

Mandy Drummey

Love Sadie's!! My go-to place for sweets!! Martha is a doll!

Rob VanAxen

They have great service, great product and are very generous people!

james dunnigan

Went there today for the first time and bought some doughnuts I have to say the boston cream ones are the best I've ever had and my wife said the bavarian cream was really good will definitely be going back.

Tyler Matthews

Very nice staff and delicious food

Amity Bahr Mamola

Great site with wonderful local small businesses.

Don K

No frills. Just good old fashion doughnuts and sticky buns.

E Colodonato

This is not the original Sadies bake shop in Narvon. This person bought the recipes from Sadie. Went there on fat Tuesday for fasnacht and they didn’t even know what a fasnacht was.

Loading...