I remember now why we stopped going in ... Overcharged every time, food was rushed chicken fingers can't eat bc hard as a Rock chicken dried out . chicken bacon ranch wrap NO BACON .....was no friendly hello we were ignored then our greeting consisted of hey we close at 7 tonight.. not hey what can I get you... We used to go on the regular but never felt welcomed with the exception of 2 bartenders .. won't allow me to add photos of the dried out chicken fingers
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
chris smith
Nice place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Barbara Meadows
Nice local pub, has has live music and Open Mic nights
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Crystal
Tuesday open mic is the best 👌
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Unimoggers Geocachers
We have so much fun here on Wednesday nights with trivia. It’s amazing how the wait staff remembers your order from weeks before!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terry D.
Great old school bar. Best cheesesteaks on the planet!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rich Ravz
The drinks, Garlic Parm wings where fire right along with the positive vibes from staff and everyone else... I'm most definitely going to be enjoying this place more in the future....
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bloodbath47
Foods good. Instead of raising the prices of the drinks… again, can you focus that energy towards giving the bartenders a raise so they don’t cry as much for tips?
Michael Pasquarelli
Ok. Great place to come for a drink. Food is not memorable. Always a fun crowd.
Would rate lower but cant, you advertise as being open to 2am but can't pick up a call round 10:30 I even waited 30mins afterwards and still nothing. Just why.... get it changed on Google maps or something for crying out loud.....tired of places like this still giving false times/ old time frames before covid jacked it up
S. J.
My husband and I came here for dinner for the first time as we had no time to make dinner ourselves. It was around 8 PM on Tuesday. The server was super friendly welcoming, and sweet and I thoroughly enjoyed it here. We will be back. This is our new spot.
Brett Foust
Great food and great service
JD Peifly
My first visit to Schmity's Old Mill Pub in Sciota, PA, was an absolute delight! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted warmly by Shelby, a veteran staff member who made me feel instantly welcome. It's clear she takes pride in making newcomers feel at home.
The atmosphere at Schmity's is fantastic – a fun, rustic vibe that's incredibly inviting. The pub is always thoughtfully decorated for each holiday, adding to the charm. The rest of the staff were equally friendly and attentive, ensuring a pleasant dining experience.
The food was outstanding! I ordered the Pot Roast Kelly waffle fries, which were incredibly delicious and satisfying. The flavors were rich and comforting, and the portion size was perfect. I also shared an order of the parmesan garlic wings, and they were simply amazing! Perfectly cooked and seasoned, they were a definite highlight.
I highly recommend Schmity's Old Mill Pub to anyone looking for great food, a warm atmosphere, and friendly service. I'll definitely be back to explore more of their menu!
Saw rats running around in the kitchen.
I remember now why we stopped going in ... Overcharged every time, food was rushed chicken fingers can't eat bc hard as a Rock chicken dried out . chicken bacon ranch wrap NO BACON .....was no friendly hello we were ignored then our greeting consisted of hey we close at 7 tonight.. not hey what can I get you... We used to go on the regular but never felt welcomed with the exception of 2 bartenders .. won't allow me to add photos of the dried out chicken fingers
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Nice place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice local pub, has has live music and Open Mic nights
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Tuesday open mic is the best 👌
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We have so much fun here on Wednesday nights with trivia. It’s amazing how the wait staff remembers your order from weeks before!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great old school bar. Best cheesesteaks on the planet!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The drinks, Garlic Parm wings where fire right along with the positive vibes from staff and everyone else... I'm most definitely going to be enjoying this place more in the future....
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Foods good. Instead of raising the prices of the drinks… again, can you focus that energy towards giving the bartenders a raise so they don’t cry as much for tips?
Ok. Great place to come for a drink. Food is not memorable. Always a fun crowd.
Restaurantji Recommends
Would rate lower but cant, you advertise as being open to 2am but can't pick up a call round 10:30 I even waited 30mins afterwards and still nothing. Just why.... get it changed on Google maps or something for crying out loud.....tired of places like this still giving false times/ old time frames before covid jacked it up
My husband and I came here for dinner for the first time as we had no time to make dinner ourselves. It was around 8 PM on Tuesday. The server was super friendly welcoming, and sweet and I thoroughly enjoyed it here. We will be back. This is our new spot.
Great food and great service
My first visit to Schmity's Old Mill Pub in Sciota, PA, was an absolute delight! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted warmly by Shelby, a veteran staff member who made me feel instantly welcome. It's clear she takes pride in making newcomers feel at home.
The atmosphere at Schmity's is fantastic – a fun, rustic vibe that's incredibly inviting. The pub is always thoughtfully decorated for each holiday, adding to the charm. The rest of the staff were equally friendly and attentive, ensuring a pleasant dining experience.
The food was outstanding! I ordered the Pot Roast Kelly waffle fries, which were incredibly delicious and satisfying. The flavors were rich and comforting, and the portion size was perfect. I also shared an order of the parmesan garlic wings, and they were simply amazing! Perfectly cooked and seasoned, they were a definite highlight.
I highly recommend Schmity's Old Mill Pub to anyone looking for great food, a warm atmosphere, and friendly service. I'll definitely be back to explore more of their menu!
Don't waste your time. Rude and slow
Loading...