Heartlake Lodge

1598 Heart Lake Rd, Mayfield
(570) 254-9419

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Michael Burrell

I attended my Aunt's 90th birthday party here . Beautiful place and top notch employees

Donald Sparacino

What a beautiful place, right by the lake, the food was excellent and the service was great, friendly and prompt.

Debra Pleska

We went for lunch on St. Patrick 's Day(my first time) at Rustic Roots. Nice atmosphere. HOWEVER, we we told if we wanted hoagies they only had 3 available. 3? It was noon for Pete's sake. I ordered the brisket dinner, which was 14.99 or 16.99. When she delivered our plates, I was disappointed with what or what was NOT on my plate. No potatoes, 1 leaf of cabbage, maybe a second small one, carrots, and very little meat. It was tasty what little I had. But I'm very disappointed in the quantity for the price. Waitress was great though.

Robin L

It was only OK. They just opened so maybe that's the issue. We paid $9.00 for that tiny basket of gravy fries. Never again. The gravy was tasteless. The fries were warm. Sad start to our visit. The hamburger and cheeseburger platters were surprisingly good after the fail of the appetizer. The staff was nice, but they all seemed overwhelmed. The table behind us had a heck of a time trying to get everything that actually went with their meal. They waited more than 10 minutes for the dressing that went with their salad. Most of the tables had the same issue. Not everything came out of the kitchen with their meal and they had to wait while their food got cold. We might go back in a few months after they get things sorted out. But still never ordering an appetizer.

Greg Davis

Best steak and cheese pizza anywhere.

Henry Straub

We were here for a catered event and everything was perfect

Service: 5

Mark Wickizer

Nice menu with plenty of good food options and exceptional service. Excellent gluten free pizza. Definitely worth a visit.

U6422GBgaryc

The food is always good here. I usually order takeout. Pizza to go is always good. The beer is really good here also.

Lori Evans

JW Pub has excellent food and large portions! The chicken parmigiana is especially delicious!

Kevin Ryczak

Great service and food

Gary Cunningham

I ordered pizza to go and it was very good.

Juliann Doyle

Everything was perfect great food and service. Steak practically melted in your mouth.

Peter Barbiero

Excellent food, pizza, and service.

Kristin B

Nice people.

April Brennan

This food was be on good all home made stuff .. It was great and only found it bc of a detour... Man it was worth the extra few minutes off the highway to eat here.. Thanks for the great food and excellent service..

Loading...