I give it credit for being unique, I can't say I've had a pizza I can compare it to. But for me that's about where the credit ends. I don't understand the other reviews for this pizza. The crust is nothing special and almost rivals those you can find in a frozen pizza brand. It's not inedible, but I can't recommend it over the countless great pizza places in NEPA. They've been in business a while, so there must be a demand for this style of pizza, but I don't understand it.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
David Babinski
Top 3 pizza places in town. Also, it's been a family favorite for over 60 years, so I may be biased!Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian G
This is a hidden gem in Scranton!!Great pizza, seasoned perfectly.Specialty pizza's are awesome too!!Staff is always hard working & very friendly !!Definitely a must try pizza shop, that's my favorite part, they only sell pizza!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ghayas Salem
Best chicken wing and tomatoe basil pizzas in the world, period!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda
Wonderful pizza and wonderful staff. Do be prepared to pay in cash! (they have an atm inside)
Food: 5
L-Egance Designs
I have been going to Nicholas's since I was a kid and the atmosphere and food is awesome! In all these years, they're pizza is just as good as when I was a kid. They're pizza is unique and the best crust around!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Taralyn Lynch
I tried to call to tell him he's earned new customers but he was closed. We've been in Scranton for 6 years and this is by far the best pizza we've had and we are avid pizza eaters. Nicholas has earned lifetime customers!! The 7 cheese with sun dried tomatos is to die for and a must try!
Sharon Skeras
We have been trying pagash pizza all around for about 2 years. We tried many, but no one even comes close to Nicolais Pizza.#1 Pagash pizza...BEST EVER.
James Smurl
Pizza is always phenomenal. I ordered two nights in a row this week. You need to try their fresh tomato and basil pizza.Vegetarian options: Joe and the staff will create a pizza to your liking.Parking: Parking on the side of building.Wheelchair accessibility: No stairs.
Kayt Gavin
Order to pick up time is always very quick. Pizza is very good and a good value! Staff always incredibly nice. Please note this is a cash only business.
What a find!! We were in Scranton, watching our son's bestfriend play football, and I wanted pizza. I can't have gluten, so, I searched in Yelp, and this place came as a suggestion, that was really close to where we were. The pizza is NOT your regular Scranton/Old Forge pizza (thick pizzas). This a thin, crunchy pizzas, and so delicious!!! An old style pizza shop, it feels like you walked back in time. The employees were super nice, we ate there, and took the rest to go. The gluten free pizza is crunchy too, and delicious!!! Try the tomato and basil if you go there during the summer, it's soo good!!
claire335
Best chicken wing pizza -- regular cheese is also good. No mystery why in business lasted so long.
Nicki Boles
Taco pizza, fresh tomato and basil…?
Robert Foley
One of the finest and most popular pizza shops in NEPA. Eat there and you will find out why.
I give it credit for being unique, I can't say I've had a pizza I can compare it to. But for me that's about where the credit ends. I don't understand the other reviews for this pizza. The crust is nothing special and almost rivals those you can find in a frozen pizza brand. It's not inedible, but I can't recommend it over the countless great pizza places in NEPA. They've been in business a while, so there must be a demand for this style of pizza, but I don't understand it.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Top 3 pizza places in town. Also, it's been a family favorite for over 60 years, so I may be biased!Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is a hidden gem in Scranton!!Great pizza, seasoned perfectly.Specialty pizza's are awesome too!!Staff is always hard working & very friendly !!Definitely a must try pizza shop, that's my favorite part, they only sell pizza!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best chicken wing and tomatoe basil pizzas in the world, period!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wonderful pizza and wonderful staff. Do be prepared to pay in cash! (they have an atm inside)
Food: 5
I have been going to Nicholas's since I was a kid and the atmosphere and food is awesome! In all these years, they're pizza is just as good as when I was a kid. They're pizza is unique and the best crust around!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I tried to call to tell him he's earned new customers but he was closed. We've been in Scranton for 6 years and this is by far the best pizza we've had and we are avid pizza eaters. Nicholas has earned lifetime customers!! The 7 cheese with sun dried tomatos is to die for and a must try!
We have been trying pagash pizza all around for about 2 years. We tried many, but no one even comes close to Nicolais Pizza.#1 Pagash pizza...BEST EVER.
Pizza is always phenomenal. I ordered two nights in a row this week. You need to try their fresh tomato and basil pizza.Vegetarian options: Joe and the staff will create a pizza to your liking.Parking: Parking on the side of building.Wheelchair accessibility: No stairs.
Order to pick up time is always very quick. Pizza is very good and a good value! Staff always incredibly nice. Please note this is a cash only business.
Restaurantji Recommends
What a find!! We were in Scranton, watching our son's bestfriend play football, and I wanted pizza. I can't have gluten, so, I searched in Yelp, and this place came as a suggestion, that was really close to where we were. The pizza is NOT your regular Scranton/Old Forge pizza (thick pizzas). This a thin, crunchy pizzas, and so delicious!!! An old style pizza shop, it feels like you walked back in time. The employees were super nice, we ate there, and took the rest to go. The gluten free pizza is crunchy too, and delicious!!! Try the tomato and basil if you go there during the summer, it's soo good!!
Best chicken wing pizza -- regular cheese is also good. No mystery why in business lasted so long.
Taco pizza, fresh tomato and basil…?
One of the finest and most popular pizza shops in NEPA. Eat there and you will find out why.
Always excellent, Summer Pie is back, amazing